Chapter 9 - WHAT HONORIA SAID

Ms. Croft requested a meeting.
Not with Cressie.
With Isadora.
Cressie learned about it because her mother told her before accepting.
“I won’t go if you don’t want me to.”
Cressie considered that.
“Do you want to?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because I want to hear what she says when she can’t talk through a
school memo.”
The meeting took place at a mediator’s office.
Cressie stayed with her aunt.
When Isadora returned, she looked exhausted.
Cressie met her in the hallway.
“Well?”
Isadora removed her coat.
“She apologized.”
Cressie waited.
“That’s all?”
“No.”
They sat in the study.
Isadora told her only what was appropriate.
Honoria had admitted throwing away the lunch.
She said she believed Cressie had been eating beyond hunger cues.
“She watched me eat?”
“She says she observed students generally.”
“That’s creepy.”
Isadora did not disagree.
Honoria also said the foundation’s training encouraged teachers to
intervene when they saw “concerning patterns.”
“Did the training say throw food away?”
“No.”
“Did it say call kids big?”
“No.”
Cressie looked at the carpet.
“Then why did she?”
Isadora’s answer came slowly.
“She said she made a serious error in judgment.”
“That’s not why.”
“No.”
Cressie knew there was more.
“What about college?”
Isadora looked toward the window.
“She brought it up.”
Cressie’s stomach tightened.
“What did she say?”
“That seeing me at career day surprised her. That old feelings came
back.”
“What feelings?”
“Resentment.”
Cressie stared.
“So it was because of you.”
“Partly, maybe.”
“Because you won a debate?”
“It was more complicated.”
Isadora explained that Honoria’s complaint had made her unpopular. She
believed Isadora’s family connections had protected her. Years later,
Honoria still believed the college had dismissed legitimate concerns.
“Was she wrong?”
“I don’t know anymore.”
That answer startled Cressie.
Isadora opened the old clipping.
“My father did know that judge. I didn’t choose him. I didn’t ask for
help. But I also didn’t ask many questions after I won.”
“So Miss Croft was right?”
“About the appearance of favoritism? Maybe. About me cheating? No.”
Cressie thought about Dr. Bell’s sentence.
Adults can believe they are helping and still cause harm.
Could adults also be wrong about one thing and right about another?
The mystery became uncomfortable.
Honoria was not a monster from nowhere.
She had been hurt.
Then she had hurt someone else.
That did not balance anything.
It only made the line longer.
Two days later, the outside investigator contacted Isadora.
The anonymous agenda was authentic.
The 2019 file had not been destroyed.
It had been moved from the student-support archive into a restricted
legal file after Dr. Price left.
“Why?” Cressie asked.
“The school says because it involved personnel.”
“Is that normal?”
“Maybe.”
“But the investigator didn’t get it.”
“No.”
The board’s attorney had now produced it.
Inside were three complaints.
Not one.
One involved comments about a child’s weight.
One involved a lunch thrown away.
Cressie went cold.
“They knew.”
“In 2019, yes.”
“And she did it again.”
“Yes.”
The third complaint was different.
A parent alleged that Ms. Croft had singled out her daughter after a
disagreement with the parent.
Cressie looked up.
“Like you.”
Isadora’s face tightened.
“Possibly.”
The report from 2019 had recommended that Ms. Croft not participate in
individualized nutrition counseling and that she receive supervision
regarding personal conflicts with families.
Cressie whispered, “Then why was she running Healthy Choices?”
May you like
Isadora closed the folder.
“That,” she said, “is what the school has to answer now.”