Chapter 5 - THE OLD COMPLAINT

The clipping was twenty years old.
Cressie sat cross-legged on the study rug while Isadora read it.
The article described a campus debate competition and a complaint about
judging procedures. No names appeared except Isadora’s, because she had
won.
“What did H.C. complain about?”
Isadora rubbed the edge of the paper.
“She said I had an unfair advantage because one judge knew my father.”
“Did he?”
“Professionally. They’d met twice.”
“Was she right?”
Isadora considered that.
“She was right that it looked bad. She was wrong that I cheated.”
Cressie liked that her mother did not make herself perfect.
“What happened?”
“The college reviewed it. They found no misconduct.”
“And Miss Croft?”
“She stopped speaking to me.”
Cressie looked at the photograph again.
“That was twenty years ago.”
“Yes.”
“So why me?”
“I don’t know.”
The next day, Ms. Croft was absent.
Mrs. Vale taught the class.
Nobody explained why.
Cressie should have felt safe.
Instead she spent the morning waiting for the door to open.
At lunch, she ate half her food.
It was more than yesterday.
When she returned home, Isadora had received an email from Hawthorne.
Ms. Croft had been placed on administrative leave while the school
reviewed the complaint.
Cressie read the sentence three times.
“Did I get her fired?”
“No.”
“But she’s not teaching.”
“That is the school’s decision while they investigate.”
“What if I misunderstood?”
Isadora knelt so they were eye level.
“Did she throw away your lunch?”
“Yes.”
“Did she say you were too big?”
“Yes.”
“Then you didn’t misunderstand those facts.”
Cressie nodded, but guilt remained.
That evening, someone called the house.
Isadora answered.
Her face changed.
“Yes, this is she.”
A pause.
“No. Please don’t contact Cressie directly.”
Cressie stopped on the stairs.
Isadora listened.
“I understand what you’re saying, but that doesn’t excuse it.”
Another pause.
Then:
“No, Honoria. We are not discussing college.”
Cressie’s hand tightened on the railing.
Her mother ended the call.
“Was that her?”
“Yes.”
“What did she want?”
“To explain.”
“Explain what?”
Isadora hesitated.
“She said she was concerned about your health.”
Cressie felt heat rise in her face.
“I’m not sick.”
“I know.”
“Did she say I was fat?”
“Cressie.”
“Did she?”
Isadora’s silence answered.
Cressie went upstairs.
She did not slam the door.
She wanted to.
Instead she sat at her desk and opened the Monday note.
Eat what makes you strong.
She had thought strength meant not crying.
Now she wondered if it meant saying what happened even when someone
called it help.
The next morning, Mrs. Vale asked Cressie to stop by her office.
A woman from the school’s student support team was there.
“We’re speaking with several students,” Mrs. Vale said.
“Several?”
Cressie looked from one adult to the other.
The support counselor nodded.
“Your report helped us identify concerns that may not involve only you.”
Cressie’s stomach turned.
“What concerns?”
“We can’t discuss other students’ private experiences.”
Cressie understood.
But when she left the office, she saw a sixth-grade girl sitting
outside.
The girl was crying.
Beside her was a lunchbox.
Cressie recognized her from the cafeteria.
Her name was Maeve.
As Cressie passed, Maeve looked up.
Their eyes met.
Maeve whispered, “She did it to you too?”
Cressie stopped.
The hallway suddenly seemed very quiet.
This was not about a debate trophy.
Or at least, not only that.
May you like
And for the first time, Cressie understood that the mystery might be
larger than her family.