scribe

Chapter 27 - A LETTER WITH NO DEMAND

The first letter from Melisende arrived seven months later.

Nerys screened it.

Then Mira.

Only then did Tavian read it.

Tavian,

I have rewritten this so many times that the paper feels dishonest before the words begin.

I will not ask you to tell Eirlys I love her.

I know what that request would do to you.

I will not ask you to forgive me.

I do not know what forgiveness would even mean here.

There is one thing I want placed somewhere outside my control.

I knew the pillow would frighten her.

I knew the camera was running.

I knew the fear could be used.

I told myself I would stop before actual harm.

That sentence is disgusting to me now because fear was actual harm.

You were absent too much.

That is true.

It is also irrelevant to what I chose.

Do not let me use your guilt to carry my responsibility.

If Eirlys ever asks whether she caused any of this, tell her no.

M.

Tavian read the final paragraph again.

Do not let me use your guilt to carry my responsibility.

For months, that was exactly what he had been tempted to do.

Not because Melisende demanded it.

Because guilt felt like control.

If the entire tragedy could be explained by Tavian’s failures, then perhaps a better Tavian could have prevented everything.

Reality was less comforting.

He could have been more present.

He should have listened.

He should have checked.

Those failures mattered.

And Melisende still made independent choices.

Both.

Mira asked whether the letter should eventually reach Eirlys.

“Not now,” Tavian said.

“I agree.”

“Someday?”

“Maybe.”

Tavian smiled without humor.

“You love that word.”

“It is accurate.”

He placed the letter in the same archive as his own.

Two adults recording responsibility in different ways.

Eirlys would decide later whether she wanted either.

That spring, she asked to send Melisende a drawing.

Tavian’s first instinct was no.

He paused.

“What drawing?”

“A flower.”

“Do you want her to answer?”

Eirlys thought.

“No.”

They spoke with Mira.

A copy of the drawing was sent through legal channels with a request for no direct reply.

Melisende complied.

No letter.

No card.

No message hidden through someone else.

Tavian noticed the restraint.

He did not call it redemption.

But he allowed himself to recognize it.

A boundary had been respected.

That mattered because change, if it existed, would have to begin there.

Melisende’s letter remained private for nearly two years.

Then Eirlys, now six, asked:

“Did Mom ever say sorry?”

Tavian had prepared for many questions.

That one still frightened him.

“She wrote something that included taking responsibility.”

“Is that sorry?”

“Partly.”

“Can I see?”

Tavian did not answer alone.

He called Mira.

They discussed what Eirlys wanted to know rather than assuming she wanted the full letter.

Mira asked her, “Do you want to read grown-up details, or do you want to know whether Melisende understands she hurt you?”

Eirlys thought.

“Second.”

So Tavian did not hand her the letter.

He said:

“Yes. She wrote that she knew the pillow frightened you and that frightening you was harm. She said it was her choice, not your fault.”

Eirlys listened.

“Did she say love?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“I don’t know.”

Eirlys nodded.

That was enough for now.

The letter remained sealed.

Access did not require immediate exposure.

May you like

Transparency could include timing.

That distinction helped Tavian avoid repeating his opposite fear: hiding nothing so aggressively that Eirlys was forced to carry adult information before she was ready.

Related Stories

Other posts