scribe

Chapter 24 - WHAT LOVE DOES NOT EXCUSE

Eirlys never heard Melisende’s testimony.

Not then.

Tavian and Mira agreed the details belonged to a later age.

But she noticed the adults changed.

Briony cried in the pantry.

Marcus stayed two extra days.

Tavian stared out windows too often.

“What happened?”

Eirlys asked.

They were at breakfast.

She was four now.

Barely.

Older enough to notice more.

Tavian sat beside her.

“Melisende told the court she did some of the things people were worried about.”

Eirlys stopped spreading jam.

“Pillow?”

“Yes.”

“Quiet?”

“Yes.”

She looked down.

“Why?”

Tavian considered every bad answer.

Because she wanted money.

Because she wanted control.

Because she was cruel.

Because I let her into our life.

None was adequate for a four-year-old.

“She made choices that were wrong because she wanted grown-up things more than she protected you.”

Eirlys frowned.

“Did she love me?”

The question arrived exactly where Tavian feared it would.

He did not answer quickly.

“I think she had loving feelings for you.”

Eirlys looked up.

“But?”

He swallowed.

“Love does not make harmful choices okay.”

Eirlys touched Pip’s ear.

“Can love hurt?”

“People who love us can hurt us.”

“Then love bad?”

“No.”

He struggled.

“Good love listens when you say stop. Good love protects you. Good love says sorry and changes.”

“Did Mom change?”

“I don’t know.”

Eirlys thought.

“Did you?”

Tavian almost laughed from the precision of it.

“I’m trying.”

“You go less.”

“Yes.”

“You ask hugs.”

“Yes.”

“You still burn toast.”

“Yes.”

She nodded.

“Some change.”

He smiled.

“Some.”

That afternoon Mira spoke with him privately.

“You handled the love question well.”

“I hated it.”

“Why?”

“Because any answer feels like I’m defining Melisende for her.”

“You are giving her language, not a verdict.”

Tavian looked through the glass door.

Eirlys was putting stickers on Toast.

“Will she hate me someday for not seeing it?”

“Maybe.”

The answer was brutal.

Tavian appreciated it.

“Will she forgive me?”

“Maybe.”

“Very helpful.”

Mira smiled.

“You are still trying to control the future.”

He exhaled.

“Yes.”

“You can give her truth, repair, safety, and room. You cannot prearrange her adult feelings.”

That night Tavian wrote a letter to Eirlys.

Not for now.

For later.

He described what he missed.

What he knew.

What he did not know.

The afternoon with the pillow.

His failures before it.

His decisions after.

He did not ask forgiveness.

He placed the letter in a sealed envelope.

TO EIRLYS, WHEN YOU WANT THE LONG VERSION.

Then he locked it with Celestine’s documents.

Not as evidence.

As accountability.

A record written before memory could flatter him.

Tavian’s letter to Eirlys grew over time.

He added dates in the margins.

Not arguments.

Corrections.

When memory shifted, he checked records.

When he realized he had misunderstood something, he revised.

He wanted the future letter to resist the temptation every adult had to make themselves look better in hindsight.

One paragraph read:

I may tell you later that I knew something was wrong before I came home that day. The records do not support that. I knew there had been tension in the house. I did not know what was happening to you. I wish I had known. Wishing is not memory.

He underlined the last sentence.

Wishing is not memory.

The principle became important because family stories were already forming.

Briony remembered certain days one way.

Marcus another.

Lucille had records.

Tavian had gaps.

Eirlys would have her own memories.

None should be forced into perfect agreement.

Mira told him, “Children become adults partly by revising the stories adults gave them.”

Tavian found that frightening.

Then healthy.

Eirlys would not owe him permanent acceptance of his version.

One day she might read the case file and become angry at him.

One day she might understand Melisende differently.

One day she might reject parts of what everyone believed now.

May you like

His task was not to preempt those possibilities.

It was to leave her enough honest material to think for herself.

Related Stories

Other posts