scribe

Chapter 4 - Maddie’s Silence

Maddie had expected the lie to disappear.

Instead, it grew.

At first she told herself Ellie would be fine. Ms. Cross would forget. The class would move on. Water dried.

But reputations did not.

Three days after the spill, Maddie watched Ellie raise her hand during math, hesitate, then lower it before Ms. Cross called on anyone.

That was new.

At recess, Ellie stayed near the wall.

That was new too.

Maddie approached her.

“Ellie.”

Ellie looked up.

“I…” Maddie glanced toward the supervising teacher. “Are you mad at me?”

Ellie’s face went still.

“You said I did it.”

“I panicked.”

“So tell Ms. Cross.”

Maddie’s eyes widened. “I can’t.”

“Why?”

“Because then she’ll know I lied.”

Ellie almost laughed at the cruelty of the logic.

“She already thinks I lied.”

“I know.”

“Then tell her.”

Maddie looked down. “She’ll hate me.”

Ellie’s voice became very quiet. “She already hates me.”

“No, she doesn’t.”

“You don’t know.”

Maddie whispered, “I’m sorry.”

Ellie stared at her.

“Sorry doesn’t change what she thinks.”

Maddie’s eyes filled with tears.

For a moment Ellie felt guilty for making her cry.

That frightened her.

Why should she feel guilty?

Ms. Cross’s voice lived inside the question before Ellie could answer it: being right matters more to you than honesty.

“I have to go,” Ellie said.

Maddie caught her sleeve. “Please don’t tell.”

Ellie pulled free.

“I already told.”

That afternoon Ms. Cross assigned partners for a history project.

“Ellie and Maddie.”

Both girls froze.

Ms. Cross noticed.

“Is there a problem?”

“No,” Maddie said quickly.

Ellie shook her head.

They sat together in the library, surrounded by books about colonial New York. Maddie tried to talk about the project, but Ellie answered with one-word responses.

Finally Maddie whispered, “I’ll tell her.”

Ellie looked at her.

“When?”

“Soon.”

“When?”

“I don’t know.”

Ellie closed her book.

“That means never.”

Ms. Cross appeared at the end of the table.

“What does?”

Neither answered.

Victoria’s gaze moved between them.

“Maddie?”

Maddie swallowed.

“Nothing.”

Ms. Cross looked at Ellie.

“Were you pressuring her about the water incident?”

“No.”

Maddie said nothing.

Victoria’s eyes narrowed.

“Ellie, I thought we discussed this.”

“I wasn’t—”

“Enough.”

Maddie stared at the tabletop.

Ms. Cross leaned toward Ellie.

“When someone has been falsely accused by you once, continuing to confront her can become intimidation.”

Ellie’s face drained of color.

“I didn’t intimidate her.”

“Then demonstrate that by leaving the subject alone.”

That evening, Maddie took out a sheet of notebook paper.

She wrote: I spilled the water.

She folded it twice.

May you like

The next morning, she carried it to school in her coat pocket.

But before she could give it to Ms. Cross, she heard the teacher say something to Ellie that made her stop cold.

Related Stories

Other posts