scribe

Chapter 19 - Ellie’s Answer

Dear Ms. Cross,

I read your letter.

Ellie stopped.

She crossed out I forgive you before she had fully written it.

Then she continued.

You were wrong about me.

She stared at the sentence.

Once, saying those words would have terrified her.

Now they felt clean.

You were wrong when you said I spilled the water. You were wrong when you said I lied. You were wrong when you said I was trying to hurt Maddie. I kept telling you because I knew what happened.

Ellie paused.

Sarah sat across the room, reading, deliberately giving her privacy.

The hardest part was not that you didn’t believe me at first. People can make mistakes. The hardest part was that every time I tried to explain, you made my explaining into another bad thing about me.

Ellie’s eyes watered.

For a while I thought maybe being quiet was safer.

She breathed slowly.

I don’t think that anymore.

She ended the letter:

I hope if a child tells you something someday and you think they are lying, you ask questions before you decide who they are.

Ellie

She gave it to Sarah.

“Can you send it?”

“Are you sure?”

“Yes.”

Victoria received it three days later through the school.

She read it alone.

She cried at the line: People can make mistakes.

Because Ellie had offered her the mercy Victoria had refused Ellie.

Not absolution.

Context.

A distinction between a mistake and a person.

Victoria wrote no reply.

Ellie had not asked for one.

Instead, Victoria enrolled in a professional program on restorative practices and child-centered conflict resolution. She did not announce it to the Bennetts. It was not a performance for them.

She also wrote to Owen Shaw and his parents.

Then to two other families.

Some never answered.

One replied angrily.

She accepted that too.

Remorse, she began to understand, did not control the response of the person harmed.

Back at school, Ellie’s class prepared for the winter assembly.

She volunteered to read a short passage onstage.

When Sarah heard, she nearly asked, “Are you sure?”

She stopped herself.

May you like

Ellie noticed.

“Yes,” Ellie said with a smile. “I’m sure.”

Related Stories

Other posts