Chapter 9 - Thirty-Eight Thousand Four Hundred Dollars

Nadia Park arrived at Nora's duplex with two folders and no opinion about Harold's character.
He found that unsettling until he realized it might be a form of kindness.
"I'm reviewing the numbers," she said. "Being liked isn't a control procedure. Being disliked isn't evidence of theft."
They sat at Nora's kitchen table. Harold wore a borrowed cardigan over his sling. Mara had placed the old affidavit in a separate folder after reporting it fully to Ben. Whatever Ada had exposed would not be left for opposing counsel to reveal first.
Nadia opened the current household accounts.
The suspected theft consisted of twelve payments to a vendor called HB Domestic Services, totaling thirty-eight thousand four hundred dollars over seven months. The description referred to relief staffing and household supplies. Harold's initials appeared in an authorization field.
"I never approved these," he said.
"What did you approve?"
He described the paper purchase sheets, the limits on petty cash, and the process for replacing damaged linen. Nadia asked him to demonstrate with a blank form. He could manage the pen in his right hand, but turning pages was difficult.
Mara waited rather than reaching for them.
"This vendor was created in the electronic system," Nadia said. "Your paper initials were entered later. That tells us what the record contains. It doesn't yet tell us who entered them or why."
"Where did the money go?" Mara asked.
"The ledger contains masked banking details. We need reliable account-holder information from the bank, not a guess based on four digits. Celia is seeking expedited records in the civil case, and the investigators have their own process."
Harold studied the invoices.
One billed for replacement curtains in a room whose curtains had not changed since Elena was alive. Another charged for a temporary kitchen worker on a day Nora remembered cooking alone.
"I can show you the rota," Nora said. "I keep my own hours."
"Good. Preserve the original. We'll compare it with payroll and the staffing agency's records."
They worked for an hour. Harold began to understand why a lie could look convincing in a file: it did not have to describe the whole house. It only had to occupy a box nobody had checked.
Nadia moved to the second folder.
"HB Domestic Services is part of a wider review. The payment descriptions and supporting material overlap with entries involving Bridge House Consulting. Over eighteen months, three point two million dollars left through that group of transactions."
Nora stared at her.
"And they accused him over thirty-eight thousand?"
"That amount is included in the larger total," Nadia said. "Not added to it. We have to be precise. Some entries may have legitimate explanations. Some don't appear to."
"Who approved them?" Harold asked.
"The system shows Ethan's credentials approving a number of payments."
Mara glanced at her father.
Nadia continued before he could speak.
"Credentials aren't a person. Shared access, delegated entry, or misuse are possibilities. We'll need the audit trail, supporting communications, and bank evidence."
Harold remembered Ethan at sixteen, admitting a school failure only after Harold promised to stand beside him when he told Don. He had mistaken confession under protection for the beginning of courage. Perhaps it had only taught Ethan to find somebody else to absorb the consequences.
A knock interrupted them.
Detective Ruiz stood outside with a colleague. They had arranged to take Nora's formal statement and wanted to confirm a few points about the immediate aftermath.
Nora straightened the tablecloth before sitting down.
"I know he shot him," she said.
"Tell me what you personally saw," Ruiz replied.
Nora drew a breath.
"I heard the shot. I came into the hall. Harold was coming out of the sitting room, bleeding. Mr. Moretti appeared behind him holding a gun."
"Did you see the trigger pulled?"
"No."
Her face tightened as though she had failed Harold.
He shook his head gently.
"That's what happened, Nora. Say that."
For the first time that afternoon, Mara looked directly at him.
Nora described the towel, the order to remove Harold, the phone still recording, and the call for an ambulance. Ruiz asked about the guard and the position of the doors. She did not ask Nora to improve the story.
After the detectives left, the kitchen felt smaller.
"They could say anything about us," Nora said. "People with offices. People whose names are on buildings."
"That's why we keep the ordinary records," Nadia replied. "A staffing invoice. A bank statement. A shift schedule. They don't care whose portrait hangs in the hallway."
Her phone rang. She stepped into the front room to answer, then returned with an email open.
The company correspondence Celia had lawfully obtained included a message Don had sent eleven days before the disputed signature. Nadia read it aloud.
No sale of Dock Eleven below independently supported value. No management changes before the external review. I will not authorize either by informal instruction.
Harold looked at the date.
It preceded Don's return from the hospital.
"That's why they needed him confused," Nora said.
"It's evidence of his earlier position," Nadia answered. "They may claim he changed his mind. We'll test that claim."
Mara read the distribution list beneath the message.
Victoria. Ethan. Martin Voss.
All three had received it.
May you like
All three had known that the one thing standing between them and the transaction was not a missing signature.
It was an awake man saying no.