Chapter 20 - No Better Version of the Truth

In June, eight months after the shooting, Leah Brooks asked Harold to tell the story badly.
He looked at her across the interview-room table.
"I don't understand."
"Tell me the parts you wish weren't in it. The parts a defense lawyer will ask about. We are not rehearsing a better version. We are making sure nothing important has been left out."
Mara sat beside him. Ben had reviewed the issues concerning Harold's own conduct, and the lawyers had been careful about the boundaries between his representation and the prosecution's preparation of a witness.
Harold rubbed the numb patch on his arm.
"I should have opened the door."
Leah waited.
"I heard them planning to take advantage of him. I could have gone inside. I could have told June what I heard. Instead I decided Don would understand better in the morning."
"Why?"
"Because I was afraid. And because I had spent so long believing that a bad moment was something to manage quietly."
He described the plate, the trolley, Victoria asking whether he was still wandering. He did not improve his silence into a heroic strategy. The nurse's presence had reassured him, but it had also given him an excuse not to confront people with more power than he had.
Leah asked about the false affidavit.
He answered without minimizing it.
She asked whether he hated Victoria.
He took longer over that.
"There are days I think I do. Then there are days I'm too tired to hate anybody. I want what happened established properly. My feelings don't prove it."
Leah nodded and made a note.
The trial would begin in July. Ethan had entered a negotiated plea to a serious theft charge and agreed to testify truthfully, subject to the terms of his cooperation and the judge's ultimate sentencing authority. Voss had also entered a guilty plea in the financial case after the documentary record made his undisclosed interest in Vesper and his role in the payments difficult to explain away.
Neither would be presented as a trustworthy person merely because he had changed sides.
"Their testimony has to fit the independent evidence," Leah said. "The bank records. The provider records. The nurse's account. The documents and communications we can authenticate."
Victoria had chosen trial.
Harold imagined her in the witness chair, if she decided to testify, making a roomful of strangers feel cruel for asking her ordinary questions. He had watched her do it at dinner parties when someone challenged a donation figure or asked where a promised payment had gone.
"What if they believe her?"
"Then the jury will have heard both the claims and the evidence," Leah said. "I won't promise you a result."
He had once found that answer frightening. Now he found the absence of performance reassuring.
They discussed how the shooting would be handled in Victoria's financial trial. The jury would not be asked to punish her for Don's separate act. Relevant portions of the morning interaction could be addressed only within the court's rulings. The original recording would remain intact, regardless of what excerpts or transcripts were permitted.
Leah wanted the case proved, not inflated.
When the meeting ended, Harold's shoulder was aching from the long sitting. Mara asked whether he wanted to go straight home.
He had moved into the small rental near the park in April. His savings covered a modest life while his civil claim continued. The place had two bedrooms, a narrow kitchen, and a garden he was still learning not to approach as somebody else's groundskeeper.
"We said we'd have dinner," he reminded her.
"We can do it another night."
"Are you tired?"
"A little."
"Then we can make something easy. But I don't want to cancel because I think a difficult day gives me permission to disappear."
Mara looked at him.
It was the kind of sentence he used to say well and fail to live up to. She had learned to wait for what followed.
He bought bread on the way home.
In the kitchen, Mara chopped tomatoes while Harold attempted to make dressing one-handed. The bottle slipped. He caught it badly, swore, and then apologized for swearing.
"I'm thirty-four, Dad."
"Your mother disliked it at the table."
"She had an impressive vocabulary when the washing machine broke."
He laughed.
They ate from plates he had chosen himself. Ruth's blue bowl held the salad. The furniture did not match, and one chair rocked if he leaned too far back.
Mara told him about a difficult case at work, stopping where confidentiality required it. Harold listened without turning the conversation toward Don or the trial. He asked questions about how she felt rather than assuming the importance of a problem could be measured by the wealth of the people involved.
After dinner, she washed while he dried what he could manage safely.
"I'm glad you came to the hospital," he said.
"I know."
"I'm glad you're here now."
She handed him a plate.
"Those are different things."
"I'm learning."
Before she left, he asked her to choose a date for dinner the following week. She did not promise every week forever. She chose Wednesday.
Late that night, a message arrived from Mara after she got home. Victoria's defense had filed further papers challenging the cooperating witnesses' motives and attacking Harold's credibility. None of it was unexpected, but the trial was no longer an abstraction.
Harold read the message at his own kitchen table.
Then he wrote Wednesday on the calendar before he wrote the court date.
May you like
He would testify about the life the Morettis had nearly taken from him.
He would not give them every day of the life that remained.