Chapter 17 - TOO CAREFUL

The first complaint about Vivienne arrived in December.
It did not accuse her of prejudice.
It accused her of fear.
The anonymous submission said:
DIRECTOR ASHFORD IS SO CONCERNED ABOUT APPEARING FAIR THAT SHE WILL NOT GIVE DIRECT FEEDBACK TO CERTAIN EMPLOYEES. THIS IS NOT EQUITY. IT IS A DIFFERENT KIND OF UNEQUAL TREATMENT.
Marlene brought the complaint to her office.
Vivienne read it twice.
“Certain employees?”
“The reporter did not name them.”
“That’s convenient.”
Marlene’s eyes narrowed.
“Careful.”
Vivienne set the page down.
“You think it’s true?”
“I think you should find out.”
Vivienne immediately suspected the complaint referred to a project manager named Simone Carter.
Simone was Black, thirty-four, talented, and six weeks behind on a warehouse automation milestone.
Vivienne had noticed the delays.
She had also noticed herself softening every conversation about them.
Do you think there’s anything we can do to support the timeline?
Would it help to revisit the dependencies?
Is there context I might be missing?
She had not spoken that way to Dana when Dana missed a deadline.
With Dana, she had said, This is late. I need a recovery plan by noon.
Vivienne felt sick.
She called Simone into her office.
Simone arrived with a notebook.
“Close the door,” Vivienne said.
Simone did.
Vivienne placed the anonymous complaint face down on her desk.
“I need to ask you something uncomfortable.”
Simone sat.
“Okay.”
“Have I been unclear with you about the Ohio automation project?”
Simone looked surprised.
“Yes.”
The speed of the answer hurt.
“How?”
“You keep asking me how I feel about the schedule.”
Vivienne stared at her.
Simone continued.
“I’m the project manager. I need you to tell me whether I’m meeting expectations.”
“You’re not.”
“See?”
Vivienne blinked.
“That was the clearest thing you’ve said about it in a month.”
She leaned back.
“I was trying not to make assumptions.”
“About what?”
Vivienne chose honesty.
“About you.”
Simone’s expression cooled.
“Because I’m Black?”
“Yes.”
Silence filled the room.
Finally Simone said, “So I get worse management because you’re afraid of being the woman from the article?”
Vivienne looked down.
“Yes.”
“That’s exhausting.”
“I know.”
“No, I mean for me.”
Vivienne looked up.
Simone’s voice remained controlled.
“I don’t need you to be scared of me. I need you to manage me. If I’m late, say I’m late. If I’m good, say I’m good. If you think there’s bias involved, examine it. But don’t make me walk around wondering whether every soft sentence is because you see me as a test.”
Vivienne felt each word land.
“You’re right.”
“I know.”
A small smile appeared at the corner of Simone’s mouth.
Vivienne almost laughed.
Then she opened the project file.
“Okay. The Ohio milestone is six weeks late. Two of the vendor delays are not your fault. The integration-testing delay is. I need a recovery plan by tomorrow at noon.”
Simone picked up her pen.
“Now we’re working.”
They spent forty minutes rebuilding the schedule.
Before leaving, Simone paused at the door.
“For what it’s worth, I don’t think you’re the same person you were in that waiting room.”
Vivienne looked at her.
Simone added, “But sometimes you’re so busy proving it that you become weird.”
Vivienne laughed.
“That may be the most accurate feedback I’ve received all year.”
The complaint remained in her file.
She asked Marlene not to remove it after the issue was resolved.
“Why?” Marlene asked.
“Because improvement isn’t the same as having no record.”
Marlene nodded.
“That’s a useful sentence.”
May you like
Vivienne shook her head.
“Don’t put it on a poster.”