scribe
1 THIS SEAT IS FOR MY PAPERS / Chapter 15 / 30

Chapter 15 - THE LAWYER’S LINE

Everett Shaw believed in lines.

Legal lines. Contract lines. Reporting lines. The line between what a company regretted and what it admitted.

His career had been built on knowing exactly where those lines were and keeping clients from crossing them accidentally.

The culture audit complicated that instinct.

Celia’s draft report contained language Everett considered legally reckless.

PATTERN OF STATUS-BASED UNEQUAL TREATMENT.

INCONSISTENT RESPONSE TO RACE-RELATED AND CLASS-RELATED CONCERNS.

MANAGEMENT INCENTIVES FAVOR ISSUE CLOSURE OVER ISSUE RESOLUTION.

He invited Celia to his office.

“I need you to revise three sections.”

She sat across from him.

“Why?”

“Because you make conclusions that can be interpreted as admissions.”

“They are conclusions.”

“From a culture review, not a judicial finding.”

“I say that in the methodology.”

“Most people don’t read methodology.”

Celia crossed her arms.

“What language do you want?”

Everett slid a marked copy across the desk.

“Instead of pattern of unequal treatment, say reported perception of inconsistent treatment.”

“No.”

He blinked.

“No?”

“That changes the finding.”

“It qualifies it.”

“It relocates the problem into the minds of the people reporting it.”

Everett’s voice cooled.

“My job is to protect the company.”

“So is mine.”

“No. Your job is to assess it.”

“And a false sense of safety does not protect it.”

Everett leaned back.

“You understand that plaintiffs’ attorneys could quote this report?”

“Yes.”

“Regulators could request it.”

“Yes.”

“Clients could use it in negotiations.”

“Yes.”

“And you still think the strongest language is necessary?”

“I think accurate language is necessary.”

The conversation ended without agreement.

That evening, Everett took the draft home.

His wife, Margaret, found him reading it at the dining table after midnight.

“You look like you’re studying for the bar again,” she said.

“Feels worse.”

She poured water into a glass.

“What’s the problem?”

“I know what the report should say legally.”

“And?”

“I’m not sure that’s what it should say honestly.”

Margaret sat across from him.

“That sounds inconvenient.”

“Extremely.”

He showed her the disputed paragraph.

She read it twice.

“You want them to say people perceived inconsistent treatment.”

“Yes.”

“Did the audit find inconsistent treatment?”

“Yes.”

“Then your version sounds slippery.”

Everett frowned.

“Thank you, counsel.”

“You married a school principal. We recognize evasive language professionally.”

He laughed despite himself.

Then she said, “Who are you protecting the company from?”

“Litigation.”

“No. In that sentence.”

Everett looked at the document.

He understood her question.

Was he protecting the company from false accusation?

Or from having its own accurate description used against it?

The next morning, he met with Celia again.

“I’m withdrawing two of the three edits.”

“Which one remains?”

“The sentence saying management incentives favor closure over resolution. We need data attached to support it.”

Celia nodded.

“That’s fair.”

Everett looked almost disappointed by how quickly she agreed.

“That’s it?”

“That’s it.”

“You don’t want to argue?”

“I argue when lawyers try to turn findings into feelings. Asking for evidence is your job.”

He sat back.

May you like

For the first time, he understood that the audit did not require him to abandon his role.

It required him to stop using the role as a hiding place.

Related Stories

Other posts