Chapter 19 - The Question With No Good Answer

Winter settled over central Oregon.
The fog road closed intermittently for snow.
Eirlys turned ten in January.
Tamsin baked a crooked chocolate cake, Rhys brought no expensive gift, and Mara Quinn - the watershed worker who found Eirlys - sent a card with a drawing of five pine trees.
Inside she wrote:
Five things that do not move, whenever you need them.
Eirlys taped the card above her desk.
She had not seen Mara since the rescue. Tamsin had offered to arrange it, but Eirlys was not ready.
"I don't want her to remember me like that," she said.
"She probably remembers you as brave," Tamsin replied.
Eirlys frowned.
"I wasn't brave. I was scared."
"Those can happen at the same time."
"Maybe later."
Later was becoming one of Eirlys's most important words.
Not no forever.
Not yes before she was ready.
Later.
Her visits with Rhys moved from the advocacy center to a supervised community setting. They went to the library, walked along the river, and once spent forty minutes trying to assemble a model bridge whose instructions were missing page six.
Rhys did not complain about supervision.
He completed parenting classes, individual therapy, and every requirement the court imposed. He sold the Vale house because Eirlys said she never wanted to sleep there again.
He moved into a modest townhouse in Bend.
He kept one bedroom empty.
He did not call it Eirlys's room.
He told her, "If you ever want to help choose things for it, you can. If not, it can stay a guest room."
Eirlys said, "Later."
One afternoon in therapy, she asked the question Rhys had been dreading in different forms for months.
"If Mom warned you about Isabeau, why did you marry her?"
Dr. Lila Benton did not rescue him.
Rhys rubbed his palms together.
"Because I thought your mom was wrong about some things."
"But she wasn't."
"No."
"So why?"
"I was lonely. Isabeau made me feel capable when I felt like everything was falling apart. She helped at the company. She organized the house. She never seemed overwhelmed."
Eirlys's expression hardened.
"So you liked her because she made your life easier."
"At first, yes. I also cared about her."
"More than Mom?"
"Different from Mom."
"More than me?"
Rhys's answer came quickly.
"No."
Eirlys flinched anyway.
"Then why did you choose her when I told you?"
Rhys forced himself not to answer with intention.
He did not say I didn't mean to.
He did not say I loved you the whole time.
Both things could be true and still dodge the question.
"Because I was a coward about what believing you would require me to do."
Lila watched Eirlys.
"What do you hear when Dad says that?"
Eirlys thought.
"That it was easier for him if I was wrong."
Rhys whispered, "Yes."
"I hate that."
"You can."
"I hate you a little."
Rhys's eyes burned.
"You can do that too."
Eirlys began crying.
"I don't want to."
Lila leaned forward.
"You don't have to decide how you feel all at once. Love and anger can exist together. So can missing someone and not trusting them."
Eirlys wiped her cheeks.
"I miss Dad at breakfast."
Rhys looked down.
"I miss you too."
"But I don't want to live with you."
"Okay."
"Stop saying okay like it doesn't hurt."
Rhys let out a broken laugh through tears.
"It hurts a lot."
That made Eirlys laugh once, unwillingly.
The room softened.
Not healed.
Softened.
After the session, Lila spoke privately with Rhys.
"You are doing something difficult," she said. "You're letting her experience your sadness without making her responsible for fixing it. Keep doing that."
"How long until she trusts me?"
Lila's expression sharpened.
"That question is still about your timeline."
Rhys winced.
"Right."
"Ask instead whether your behavior is trustworthy today."
He nodded.
That evening, federal prosecutors sent Isabeau a plea proposal.
It required her to plead guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and one money-laundering count, forfeit her interest in Alder Basin, and stipulate to restitution calculations to be determined. The state would separately resolve the child-endangerment case, with sentencing coordinated but not guaranteed to be concurrent.
There was one provision Serena Pike underlined.
If Isabeau accepted, prosecutors would not require Eirlys to testify at trial unless unforeseen circumstances made it necessary.
May you like
Isabeau stared at that sentence longest.
Then she asked for forty-eight hours.