Chapter 13 - The Hearing

The preliminary dependency hearing took place twenty-three days after the fog road.
Eirlys did not attend.
Tamsin told her only what she needed to know: adults were going to court to decide where she would live for now and what rules everyone had to follow.
"Do I get to decide?" Eirlys asked.
"Your feelings matter," Tamsin said. "But the judge decides the legal part."
"What if the judge says I have to go home?"
Tamsin crouched beside her.
"Your lawyer doesn't think that will happen today."
Eirlys had been appointed a children's attorney, Camille Ross, whose job was to represent her legal interests independently from Rhys, Isabeau, and the county.
Camille had visited the ranch twice.
The first time, Eirlys barely spoke.
The second time, she showed Camille where the goats slept and asked whether judges could make adults tell the truth.
"They can require testimony under oath," Camille said.
"Does that make people tell the truth?"
Camille answered honestly.
"It makes lying have consequences."
In court, the county asked that Eirlys remain with Tamsin under temporary protective supervision.
Isabeau's lawyer objected to any finding that abuse had occurred before a full adjudication.
"My client made a grave parenting error," Morgan Ellis said. "She disputes the characterization of an ongoing pattern of maltreatment."
The judge, Harriet Lin, looked over her glasses.
"Counsel, the court is not deciding criminal guilt today. The question is whether returning this child to the household presents a safety risk."
Morgan nodded.
"Understood."
Rhys's lawyer did not contest placement with Tamsin.
That surprised Isabeau.
She looked at Rhys from across the courtroom for the first time since the investigation began.
He did not look back.
The county presented the location data showing the station wagon traveling twenty-seven minutes away from Eirlys, the lodge receipt, and Deputy Park's report. It also summarized Eirlys's disclosures about isolation in the laundry room and bedroom.
Judge Lin asked Rhys directly, "Do you dispute that your daughter told you about at least one incident involving confinement before the road event?"
Rhys stood.
"No, Your Honor."
"What did you do?"
"I spoke to my wife. I accepted her explanation. I did not follow up with my daughter adequately."
"Do you believe that was sufficient?"
"No."
The judge studied him.
"Do you currently live with Ms. Vale?"
"No."
"Are you seeking immediate return of your daughter?"
Rhys forced himself to say the hardest correct answer.
"No. I want reunification when it is safe for her, not when it is comfortable for me."
Isabeau's face changed.
It was the moment she understood Rhys would no longer protect the marriage from consequences.
Judge Lin continued Tamsin's placement, maintained supervised visitation for Rhys, and prohibited Isabeau from direct or indirect contact with Eirlys pending further review.
She also ordered no removal of Eirlys from Oregon without court approval and no access by either Rhys or Isabeau to trust funds beyond ordinary trustee-approved expenses.
Afterward, Isabeau caught Rhys in the hallway.
"You performed beautifully," she said.
Daniel Ko stepped between them.
"My client will not discuss the case."
Isabeau ignored him.
"Do you think humiliating yourself makes you noble?"
Rhys finally looked at her.
"No."
"You let them make me sound monstrous."
"You left her."
"I came back."
"No, you didn't."
Her mouth opened.
He did not let her rewrite it.
"You drove to a lodge. You ordered coffee. You called me, not the police, after twenty-seven minutes. You did not come back. Mara Quinn came."
Isabeau's eyes flashed.
"You think your failures disappear because mine are worse?"
Rhys's answer was quiet.
"No. That's another thing I'm done pretending."
He walked away.
Outside, reporters had gathered because Vale Ridge was one of the region's largest private landholders and news of the financial investigation had leaked.
Rhys said nothing.
Isabeau said nothing.
But Luc Renard, watching coverage from Seattle, made a different decision.
May you like
He called a criminal defense lawyer and asked one question.
"How much cooperation buys immunity?"