Chapter 18 - WHAT SIMONE SAID AT DINNER

Two weeks later, Grandma Evelyn hosted another Sunday dinner.
This time Clara noticed the old phrases before the adults did.
Finn did not like the chicken.
Grandma Evelyn offered to make him macaroni.
Clara ate the chicken.
"See?" Grandma said. "Clara never makes a fuss."
Natalie looked at Clara.
Clara looked at her plate.
A month earlier, Natalie might have agreed.
"She doesn't have to earn dinner by being easier," Natalie said.
Grandma Evelyn blinked.
"I didn't say she did."
"I know. I'm just trying not to compare them that way."
Grandma waved a hand. "You young parents analyze everything."
Simone took a sip of water.
"Only the things that keep repeating."
Grandma gave her a look.
"Don't start."
For ten minutes, nobody started.
Then Finn asked Clara to trade desserts because her slice of cobbler had more crust.
Clara began moving her plate automatically.
Adam said, "You don't have to."
Finn looked at him.
Clara's hand stopped.
Grandma Evelyn laughed. "Oh, let her share. She's the big sister."
Simone put down her fork.
"No."
The table went quiet.
Grandma stared at her.
"Excuse me?"
"You keep making Clara's age into a bill she has to pay."
Natalie inhaled.
Adam leaned back.
Clara froze.
Grandma's eyes narrowed. "That's dramatic."
"Is it? Finn wants the crust, Clara gives up the crust because she's older. Finn wants Mom, Clara waits because she's older. Finn gets upset, Clara adjusts because she's older. At some point 'big sister' stopped describing her and started assigning her."
"Simone," Natalie said quietly.
Not to stop her completely. Only to remind her Clara was sitting there.
Simone looked at her niece.
Clara's face was red.
"Sorry," Simone said. "I shouldn't talk about you like you're not here."
Clara looked down.
Grandma Evelyn crossed her arms.
"Families make accommodations. That's what families do."
Adam nodded. "They do. But it can't always be the same person accommodating."
Grandma looked genuinely hurt.
"I raised two girls. I know something about siblings."
Natalie reached for her water.
"You also used to tell Simone she had to give me things because she was older."
Simone barked a laugh.
"My purple bike."
Grandma frowned. "You had outgrown it."
"I had not."
"Your knees were practically at your ears."
The tension cracked slightly.
Even Clara smiled.
Simone pointed at Natalie. "She painted it pink."
Natalie laughed. "I was seven."
"Exactly. A criminal."
Grandma tried not to smile and failed.
Then Clara spoke.
"I don't want Finn's dessert."
Everyone looked at her.
Her voice was quiet.
"And I don't want to give him mine."
Finn frowned. "But yours has crust."
Clara looked at him.
"I know. That's why I want it."
Finn stared at the cobbler.
The adults waited.
He looked at Grandma.
"Can I have more crust?"
Grandma hesitated, then stood.
"I can cut you another piece."
The crisis lasted twelve seconds.
Clara ate her dessert.
On the drive home, she sat quietly in the back seat.
Finn had fallen asleep beside her.
Natalie looked into the mirror.
"You okay?"
"Yeah."
"Aunt Simone got a little intense."
Clara smiled. "She does that."
Adam laughed.
After a moment, Clara said, "I liked what she said."
"Which part?"
"About being older not being a bill."
Natalie turned toward the window.
Adam saw her eyes shine in the streetlights.
Clara continued.
"I thought being older meant I had to need less."
No one spoke for several seconds.
Then Adam said, "No. It means you've been alive five more years. That's basically it."
May you like
Clara laughed softly.
Finn slept through all of it.