scribe
1 THE LIGHT IS STILL ON / Chapter 11 / 30

Chapter 11 - THE DRAWING IN THE CLOSET

Natalie found the drawing while looking for winter sheets.

It had slipped behind a storage bin in Clara's closet and curled at the corners. The paper was thick construction stock, the kind teachers used for kindergarten projects.

At first, Natalie almost threw it into the recycling pile.

Then she saw the names.

MOMMY.

DADDY.

FINN.

ME.

The figures were drawn in crayon. Adam stood beside Finn. Natalie stood beside Finn. Clara stood farther away beneath a yellow square with orange lines around it.

A lamp.

Natalie sat back on her heels.

At the bottom, written in a child's uneven handwriting, were the words:

MY FAMILY AT NIGHT.

She checked the date.

Two years earlier.

Clara had been seven.

Natalie stayed on the closet floor for several minutes.

She tried to reconstruct the assignment. Maybe Clara had drawn the bedrooms literally. Maybe the lamp meant nothing. Maybe she was inventing meaning because Simone and Mrs. Pierce had made her self-conscious.

Then she remembered something.

For nearly a year after Finn's hospitalization, Natalie had slept on a folding mattress beside his bed.

Adam often fell asleep there too.

Clara's room had been across the hall.

The drawing was not metaphorical.

It was architecture.

Natalie carried it downstairs.

Adam was rinsing dishes.

"Look at this."

He dried his hands and took the paper.

His eyes moved from the three figures grouped together to the small girl under the lamp.

"When is this from?"

"Two years ago."

Adam stared.

"Did she show us?"

"I don't remember."

That was the worst answer.

Finn ran into the kitchen holding two socks.

"Which one?"

Natalie looked down.

One sock had a red stripe. One had a blue stripe.

"Whichever you want."

"You pick."

"Blue."

He ran away.

Natalie looked back at the drawing.

"Do you remember when Clara stopped coming into our room at night?"

Adam frowned.

"She got older."

"Did she? Or did we keep walking her back because we were afraid she'd wake Finn?"

He leaned against the counter.

"Nat."

"I'm asking."

Adam rubbed his face.

"Probably both."

Natalie shook her head.

"We keep saying 'probably.'"

She placed the drawing on the island.

"We don't know. That's the problem. We know every noise Finn made for two years. We don't know when Clara stopped asking us to stay."

Adam looked toward the stairs.

"What do you want to do?"

"I don't know."

"We can't undo it."

"I know."

"Then what?"

Natalie touched the edge of the paper.

"I think I want to stop making ourselves feel better before she feels better."

That night, Natalie did not bring the drawing to Clara.

She worried that showing it would turn Clara's childhood work into evidence in an adult trial.

Instead she knocked at bedtime.

Clara was arranging books on her nightstand.

"Can I sit?"

"Sure."

Natalie sat on the bed.

"I found one of your old drawings today."

Clara glanced at her.

"Which one?"

"Family at night. You drew yourself under a lamp."

Clara's hands stopped.

She remembered immediately.

Natalie saw that.

"Do you remember making it?"

"Yeah."

"What did the lamp mean?"

Clara shrugged.

"It was on."

Natalie waited.

"Why?"

Clara looked at the lamp beside her.

"I used to think if I turned it off, nobody would know I was awake."

Natalie's throat tightened.

"Did you want us to know?"

"Sometimes."

"Why didn't you call us?"

Clara's eyes moved to her mother's face.

The answer was so obvious to her that the question seemed strange.

"Because you were with Finn."

"You could still have called."

Clara looked down.

"Dad said not to wake him."

Natalie closed her eyes.

Adam had probably said it hundreds of times without meaning anything beyond the immediate moment.

Quiet, Clara.

Not so loud, Clara.

Your brother is sleeping.

Your brother just settled down.

Don't start him up again.

Each sentence ordinary.

Together, they had become a rule.

"I am so sorry," Natalie whispered.

Clara's expression grew cautious.

Natalie remembered what she had told Adam downstairs.

Stop making ourselves feel better first.

She did not reach for a hug.

She did not ask Clara to say it was okay.

She only added, "You should not have had to make yourself smaller so the rest of us could keep Finn calm."

Clara stared at her.

Her eyes filled, but she did not cry.

"I wasn't trying to be smaller."

"I know."

"I was trying to be good."

May you like

Natalie looked down.

That hurt more.

Related Stories

Other posts