Chapter 6 - THE MISSING MESSAGES

The police copied Aldric’s phone that afternoon.
He watched an officer scroll through the messages between him and Melusine.
They looked ordinary.
Too ordinary.
Dinner reminders. Estate repairs. Travel schedules. Pictures of Eirlys smiling at breakfast.
Then Pell asked, “Where are the arguments?”
Aldric frowned.
“What arguments?”
“You told me you and Mrs. Vane had been fighting about your travel.”
“We had.”
“There are almost no disagreements in this thread.”
Aldric took the phone.
Pell was right.
He remembered several long exchanges.
Melusine accusing him of being absent.
Aldric accusing her of spending without explanation.
A fight about firing a gardener.
Another about whether Eirlys should attend boarding school later.
None were present.
“Messages have been deleted.”
“By you?”
“No.”
“Does anyone else have access to your phone?”
“Melusine knew the passcode.”
Pell nodded slowly.
The officer photographed the device.
“What about backups?”
Aldric looked at him.
Melusine had managed the household technology. Cloud subscriptions. Shared calendars. Smart-home access.
A simple arrangement, he had thought.
Convenient.
By evening, a digital forensics specialist had been contacted.
Aldric spent the wait going through paper files with Sebastian.
Bills.
Travel receipts.
Invoices.
One set caught his attention.
A company called Northfen Child Development Services had billed the household three times over six months.
Each invoice was marked PRIVATE CONSULTATION.
Aldric pointed.
“Did you approve these?”
Sebastian shook his head.
“Household expenses under five thousand do not require trust review.”
The invoices totaled fourteen thousand four hundred pounds.
Aldric called the number listed.
Disconnected.
He searched the company registry.
Northfen existed.
Barely.
It had been incorporated fourteen months earlier.
The registered director was a woman named Mara Elling.
Aldric did not know her.
Tamsin did.
She stared at the screen.
“That isn’t her real name.”
“You’ve seen her?”
“She came to the manor twice. Mrs. Vane introduced her as a therapist.”
“For Eirlys?”
“Yes.”
“Did she meet with my daughter?”
Tamsin’s expression tightened.
“She said she was evaluating routines.”
“What does that mean?”
“She watched breakfast. She watched Eirlys play. Once she asked everyone to leave the nursery.”
Aldric stood.
“You left my child alone with a stranger?”
Tamsin flinched.
“I believed she was licensed.”
“Did you check?”
“No.”
He turned away.
The room filled with shame from both of them.
Tamsin spoke quietly.
“I should have.”
Aldric closed his eyes.
“So should I.”
The statement changed the air.
Tamsin looked at him.
Aldric sat.
“No more pretending Melusine was the only adult who failed her.”
Tamsin’s eyes filled.
Before either could say more, the front door bell rang.
Pell entered carrying printed pages.
“We recovered part of a deleted backup.”
Aldric rose.
Pell laid the pages across the table.
The messages were between Aldric and Melusine.
Only they were not messages Aldric remembered writing.
MELUSINE: You frightened Eirlys again today.
ALDRIC: She needs to stop being so fragile.
MELUSINE: She is four.
ALDRIC: Then teach her.
Aldric stared.
“I never wrote that.”
Pell said nothing.
Another exchange.
MELUSINE: Please do not grab her when you are angry.
ALDRIC: Stay out of how I discipline my daughter.
His hands began to shake.
“They’re fake.”
“The metadata is being examined.”
“I did not write them.”
Pell met his eyes.
“I’m not saying you did.”
Sebastian leaned forward.
“Can messages be inserted into a backup?”
“With access, knowledge, and time, many things can be manipulated.”
Aldric read another page.
The pattern was obvious.
Melusine as concerned protector.
Aldric as impatient father.
Eirlys as frightened child.
A record being built.
Not for conversation.
For court.
Pell turned to Tamsin.
“You said Mrs. Vane threatened to fabricate evidence of theft against you.”
“Yes.”
“Do you still have anything proving that?”
“No.”
“Any messages?”
“She never wrote it.”
“Witnesses?”
Tamsin shook her head.
Pell looked back at Aldric.
“Whoever did this was careful.”
Aldric picked up the first fake message.
“She wasn’t hiding abuse.”
Pell waited.
Aldric looked toward the ceiling, where Eirlys slept.
“She was creating an abuser.”
And for the first time, he saw the full outline of Melusine’s strategy.
If Aldric looked violent, every frightened reaction Eirlys had could be blamed on him.
If he were removed, Melusine became the safe parent.
If Melusine became the safe parent, she became guardian.
And if she became guardian, the trust opened.
The cruelty toward Eirlys was not separate from the financial plan.
It was part of the evidence.
May you like
Fear had been manufactured.
Then assigned to the wrong person.