scribe

Chapter 25 - THE VOICE ON THE RECORDING

The trial turned on a recording no one had known existed until the defense challenged the audio from Arthur’s laptop.

The prosecution ordered a deeper forensic review.

Technicians recovered a longer version from a corrupted backup.

The original excerpt contained Arthur saying:

“He needs to look unstable, not monstrous.”

Melusine had replied:

“Then we teach her fear and give the fear his name.”

The recovered audio continued.

Arthur asked, “How far are you taking this?”

Melusine laughed.

“As far as necessary.”

“No injuries.”

“Obviously.”

“I mean it.”

“She bruises like fruit. I’m not stupid.”

A pause.

Arthur said, “And if she talks?”

“She already does. Nobody listens because she’s four.”

In the courtroom, Aldric’s hands went numb.

He had read transcripts of terrible things.

Hearing Melusine’s voice was different.

Calm.

Bored.

Familiar.

The same voice that once reminded him to buy milk.

The same voice that told bedtime stories.

Nobody listens because she’s four.

Aldric looked at the jury.

Several faces changed.

The defense attacked authenticity.

Experts testified.

Metadata.

Waveform continuity.

Device history.

No evidence of splicing.

Then Melusine chose to testify.

Amara had thought she might.

Aldric had hoped she would not.

Melusine entered the witness box composed.

She admitted saying the words.

Then explained them.

“Teach her fear” referred to controlled exposure therapy.

“Give the fear his name” referred to helping Eirlys identify separation anxiety connected to her father.

“She bruises like fruit” was a crude joke.

“Nobody listens because she’s four” referred to Eirlys’s tendency to tell imaginative stories.

Each phrase received an innocent translation.

The prosecutor did not argue immediately.

She built.

“Who diagnosed separation anxiety?”

Melusine named Maribel.

“Is Maribel Cale a licensed child psychologist?”

“No.”

“Did you know that?”

“I believed she had relevant training.”

“Why did you hide Northfen’s connection to Arthur Cale?”

“I did not.”

The prosecutor showed payments.

Then emails.

Then the pond video.

Melusine watched herself standing beside Eirlys on the stone rim.

The child was crying.

Melusine did not touch her.

Tomas approached.

Eirlys slipped.

Tomas grabbed her.

On video, Melusine laughed.

The courtroom was silent.

“Was that exposure therapy?”

Melusine’s composure cracked.

“It looks worse without context.”

“What context makes a terrified four-year-old slipping toward water therapeutic?”

The defense objected.

Sustained.

The prosecutor moved on.

The cellar.

The cards.

The forged messages.

The psychiatric inquiry.

“Did Mr. Vane authorize that inquiry?”

“No.”

“Did you?”

“No.”

“Did Arthur Cale?”

“I don’t know.”

“Did you possess Mr. Vane’s old tablet?”

“Yes.”

“Did you know his passwords?”

“Yes.”

“Did you access his email?”

“For household matters.”

“Did you ever impersonate him?”

“No.”

Then came the forensic login records.

A fake message had been created at 2:14 a.m.

The old tablet was connected to the manor network.

At 2:12 a.m., Melusine’s phone unlocked the smart-home system in the same room.

At 2:17 a.m., her phone left the room.

Not proof alone.

But not alone.

Piece after piece.

The prosecutor returned to the recording.

“Nobody listens because she’s four.”

Melusine stared ahead.

“Why did you say that?”

“I explained.”

“Why did you believe nobody listened?”

“I did not mean it literally.”

“Did Eirlys tell people about the games?”

“She complained.”

“To whom?”

“Staff.”

“Did you dismiss staff after complaints?”

“Not for that reason.”

“Did you threaten Tamsin?”

“No.”

“Did you forge a letter to Imogen Hale?”

“No.”

“Did you know such a letter existed?”

“No.”

The prosecutor held up the page.

The printer analysis showed it was produced on Melusine’s private printer.

Her fingerprint was on the reverse.

Not decisive by itself.

Again, not alone.

At the end of cross-examination, the prosecutor asked one final question.

“Mrs. Vane, when you said nobody listens because she’s four, were you counting on that?”

Melusine looked toward Aldric.

For one second, the courtroom disappeared.

He saw the woman in the garden.

Laughing beside the trampoline.

Then she answered.

May you like

“No.”

But this time, her voice shook.

Related Stories

Other posts