scribe

Chapter 20 - THE RECITAL LIST

Ms. Bell accepted Oren back without ceremony.

"Your hands still know more than you think," she told him.

His first lesson lasted forty-five minutes. Odette sat outside the studio reading a magazine she did not turn a page of.

When Oren came out, he was flushed and serious.

"I forgot the left hand in the middle."

"Did the building collapse?"

"No."

"Promising."

He smiled.

By December, he could play the piece Mirelle had taught him in fragments when he was small: a simple arrangement called Evening Boat.

The title made him think of the yellow-moon painting above his bed.

Ms. Bell announced a winter recital.

Oren's stomach tightened immediately.

"Do I have to?"

"No."

He blinked.

"You can choose," she said. "Performing is useful, but usefulness does not make it mandatory."

Adults had begun saying choose to him so often that sometimes it felt like another test.

He looked at the recital sign-up sheet.

"Can I think?"

"Absolutely."

At home, he mentioned the recital during dinner.

Alaric looked up too quickly. "I'd love to come."

Oren's fork stopped.

Alaric saw it.

"If you decide to play," he added.

Sabine asked, "Do you want us there?"

Oren looked around the table.

Lucien was making a tunnel in his mashed potatoes.

"Grandma too?"

"Of course," Alaric said.

Oren considered the possible seating arrangement as if planning a diplomatic summit.

"Can everyone come and not argue?"

Sabine answered first. "Yes."

Alaric nodded. "Yes."

Oren looked at Lucien. "And you have to sit still."

Lucien looked offended. "I sit still."

Everyone laughed.

Oren did too.

The sound surprised him.

Two days later, he signed up.

His name appeared fourth on the recital list:

OREN VALE - EVENING BOAT

He stood in the studio hallway reading it.

His own name.

Not beside Lucien's. Not beneath a correction. Not squeezed out because there was only room for one.

Ms. Bell came up behind him.

"Everything all right?"

Oren nodded.

"Can I take a picture?"

"Of the list?"

"Yes."

"Certainly."

He used Odette's phone.

That evening, he asked her to print the photograph.

"Big or small?"

"Small."

He taped it inside the bottom drawer where he kept the yellow birthday hat.

Odette watched from the doorway.

"Why there?"

Oren shrugged.

"So I remember."

"Remember what?"

He closed the drawer.

"That my name fits."

May you like

The photograph of the recital list became another private object, but unlike the birthday hat, Oren did not hide it because he was ashamed. He hid it because it belonged to him. That distinction mattered. At school, Mrs. Arlen asked students to write about a time they had been brave. Oren almost wrote about the cake. Instead he wrote about signing the recital sheet. He described how his hand had hovered above the pen because saying yes meant risking a public mistake. When Mrs. Arlen returned the assignment, she had written one sentence at the bottom: Brave does not always mean loud. Oren cut out the comment and tucked it behind the recital photograph. His drawer was becoming a small archive of evidence: the hat, the list, the teacher's note. Not evidence for lawyers. Evidence for himself. Proof that feelings and choices could exist even when no adult approved them first.

Odette turned away for a moment so he would not see her cry.

Related Stories

Other posts