Chapter 16 - SABINE'S VERSION

Sabine had spent years telling herself she was not competing with a dead woman.
Competition required two living people.
Mirelle could not enter a room, contradict her, forget a permission slip, burn dinner, lose patience, or make a parenting mistake that survived until morning. Mirelle existed in photographs, stories, and the careful silence that fell whenever Sabine complained about something that had once belonged to her.
The dead did not have bad days.
Sabine did.
She remembered the first time Oren called her Mom by accident. He was six, half-asleep with a fever. The word slipped out while she held a cup of water.
For one wild second, joy rushed through her.
Then Oren woke fully and began to cry.
"I didn't mean it," he said.
Sabine had replied, "It's fine."
But it had not been fine.
After that, she stopped trying to occupy Mirelle's place and began trying to build a separate place so clearly that no one could confuse them.
Her family. Her traditions. Her son's room. Her holiday photographs.
She never said Oren did not belong.
She simply kept arranging things until he belonged at the edge.
On Monday, she sat across from Odette in a quiet cafe and admitted that.
Odette listened without rescuing her.
"I loved him," Sabine said.
"Past tense?"
Sabine looked up sharply. "No. I love him."
"Then say what you did, not what you felt."
Sabine stared into her untouched coffee.
"I asked for the blue room because I hated walking past Mirelle's painting every day. I packed photographs because I was tired of being introduced to guests beneath pictures of Alaric's first marriage. I scheduled things on Saturdays because I thought Odette was judging everything I did."
"I was."
Sabine almost smiled. "I know."
"That does not make canceling Oren's time with me acceptable."
"No."
"And the cake?"
Sabine's face heated.
"Lucien cried the night before because he wanted a birthday too. I was tired. The bakery called about the names. I chose his. I told myself Oren was older and would understand."
"Why not choose Oren's? It was his birthday."
Sabine's eyes filled.
"Because Lucien would have complained."
Odette waited.
Sabine's voice became almost inaudible. "Oren wouldn't."
There it was.
The whole architecture of the problem in four words.
Odette looked out the window.
"He became easier to disappoint."
"Yes."
"And you rewarded that by disappointing him more."
Sabine covered her mouth.
Odette did not soften the truth, but she lowered her voice.
"What are you going to do with that understanding?"
Sabine wiped beneath one eye. "I don't know yet."
"Then start smaller. Ask before taking. Believe the answer."
Sabine nodded.
That evening she stood outside Oren's door and knocked.
"Can I come in?"
He looked up from a book. "Yes."
"Are you sure?"
Oren frowned at the strange question. "Yes."
She entered but remained near the door.
"I want to ask you something. Your father's birthday is next month. I usually plan dinner here. Would you like to help choose the dessert, or would you rather not be involved?"
Oren studied her face.
"Can I say no?"
"Yes."
"Will Dad be sad?"
Sabine swallowed. "Maybe. But his feelings are his job."
Oren thought for a long time.
"I want to choose dessert."
"All right."
"Not cake."
Sabine nodded.
"Definitely not cake."
He looked back at his book.
Sabine turned to leave.
"Sabine?"
She stopped.
"Can I have the blue shelves from Lucien's room? Not the room. Just the shelves Mom put up."
Sabine felt the answer rise automatically: They fit that wall. Lucien uses them. We can buy you new ones.
She stopped herself.
"They were yours first," she said. "Let me ask Lucien what he wants to keep on them, and then we'll move them."
Oren nodded.
It was a tiny negotiation.
No one sacrificed everything.
Nothing collapsed.
May you like
Sabine began noticing how often language had done work for her. Mature. Helpful. Big brother. Understanding. Good. None of the words were cruel on their own. She had used them like ribbons around unequal requests. When Oren gave up a seat, she called him thoughtful. When he stopped asking for piano, she called him adaptable. When Lucien demanded something Oren had first, Sabine told Oren he was old enough to know better. Praise had made the surrender harder to refuse. That week she changed one habit. Whenever Oren helped Lucien, she asked whether he had wanted to help before praising him for it. Sometimes he said yes. Once, when Lucien wanted Oren to abandon a book and build blocks, Oren said no. Sabine felt the old correction rise. He's little. It won't take long. Be a good brother. She swallowed all three. Lucien complained for four minutes and then built alone. The house survived. Oren kept reading. Sabine stood at the sink afterward, shaken by how many crises she had created simply because she feared the sound of a younger child being disappointed.
Sabine stood in the hallway afterward, stunned by how ordinary fairness could have been all along.