Chapter 12 - A Father’s Two Children

Denise Calder arrived twenty minutes early and apologized for being early. That detail unsettled Victoria more than it should have. Denise did not look like a conspirator. She looked like someone terrified that a temporary office assignment had become the most consequential hour of her life. Before questioning began, Naomi explained the difference between remembering and guessing. If Denise did not know, she should say she did not know. If she was unsure, she should say she was unsure. "Do not help me," Naomi told her. "Help the truth." Marcus heard the instruction from the other side of the table and gave Victoria a brief, unreadable glance. Their father had raised them in a household where uncertainty was treated as weakness. Edmund rewarded decisive answers even when the available facts did not justify them. The entire case now depended on people resisting that instinct. Victoria wondered how different her childhood might have been if someone had once told Edmund that saying I don’t know was not a failure of leadership.
The deposition of Denise Calder lasted less than an hour before she began crying.
“I thought it was normal,” she said.
Denise was thirty-four and worked now for a medical billing company. She had no lawyer until Naomi advised her to get one.
“What did you witness?” Naomi asked.
“Mr. Sterling signing papers.”
“What papers?”
“I don’t know.”
“What was on the first page?”
“I didn’t read it.”
“Did you watch him sign every page?”
“No. He signed the last page in front of us.”
“Was the document stapled?”
Denise frowned. “I think it had a binder clip.”
“Blue cover sheet?”
“Yes.”
Victoria felt Naomi’s shoe touch hers under the table, a silent warning not to react.
“What did the blue cover say?”
“I don’t remember all of it. Something about governance.”
“Did you see the words ‘Last Will and Testament’?”
“No.”
“Who asked you to witness?”
“Mr. Hale.”
“Raymond Hale?”
“Yes.”
“Did Edmund Sterling say it was his will?”
“No.”
“Did anyone?”
“No.”
“And the five-thousand-dollar bonus?”
Denise wiped her eyes. “Mr. Hale said it was for confidentiality and extra hours.”
Paul Renner’s testimony was similar but more damaging.
He remembered Edmund asking Raymond, “Is this the version Arthur cleaned up?”
Raymond had replied, “Exactly.”
Paul also remembered Edmund saying, before signing, “I’m not cutting either child out. That is the whole point.”
Raymond’s attorney spent thirty minutes attacking Paul’s memory.
“You did not write that sentence down, correct?”
“No.”
“You are recalling it months later?”
“Yes.”
“You received a subpoena before you remembered it?”
“I remembered the old man being angry,” Paul said. “I just didn’t know it mattered.”
Outside the deposition room, Marcus stood alone by the elevator.
Victoria approached him.
“You heard him.”
Marcus looked at the floor numbers above the doors.
“I heard.”
“You still think Father left you everything?”
He turned toward her. “Do you need me to say you were right?”
“I need you to stop helping the people who may have used both of us.”
His face hardened. “You still think I’m one of them.”
“You fought me for the will.”
“Because for five minutes I had a piece of paper saying Father chose me.”
“And that mattered more than whether it was real?”
“Yes!”
The word echoed down the hallway.
Marcus lowered his voice.
“Yes,” he repeated. “For five minutes, it did.”
Victoria stared at him.
He laughed bitterly. “Do you know what he said to me when I was seventeen? I came second in a state debate tournament. Second. He drove me home in silence and then said, ‘Your sister would have won.’”
Victoria’s anger faltered.
Marcus continued. “At twenty-six I brought him my first acquisition proposal. He wrote ‘ASK VICTORIA TO CHECK THE MATH’ across the cover in red pen.”
“I never saw that.”
“No. Because he didn’t need you in the room to use you against me.”
Victoria looked away.
Their father had praised her relentlessly in front of Marcus. She had enjoyed it more than she wanted to admit.
“He did things to me too,” she said.
Marcus gave her a skeptical look.
“He told me love was trust. Then every time I made a choice he disliked, he asked whether I wanted to become ‘unreliable like Marcus.’ He made me terrified of needing anyone.”
Marcus’s expression shifted.
Neither apologized.
Not yet.
The elevator opened.
Before stepping inside, Marcus said, “Raymond’s brother financed my debts.”
Victoria stared at him.
Marcus looked ashamed.
“Seven point two million.”
“How?”
“Bad investment. Worse pride. Then borrowing to hide the first mistake.”
“Does Raymond know?”
“He arranged it.”
The elevator doors started to close.
Victoria put out a hand and stopped them.
“Marcus, if they have a lien on what you inherit—”
“They do.”
Her face went cold.
May you like
Marcus nodded.
“Now you understand why someone might have wanted me to inherit everything.”