Chapter 10 - What Arthur Knew

Arthur asked for water before the deposition began and barely touched it. Victoria watched condensation slide down the glass while the court reporter tested the recording equipment. For decades, Arthur had been one of the adults who made the Sterling family appear organized. He remembered birthdays, corrected tax mistakes, drafted prenuptial agreements, found specialists when Evelyn became ill, and stood beside Edmund at both children’s graduations. Victoria had never imagined him as someone who could be frightened of her father. Yet fear was visible now in the way he arranged his papers twice, then a third time. Naomi had warned Victoria not to confuse familiarity with loyalty. "Family lawyers often become custodians of everyone’s rationalizations," she said. "Sometimes they protect the client. Sometimes they protect the system around the client. Sometimes, eventually, they cannot tell the difference." When Arthur raised his right hand to swear that his testimony would be truthful, Victoria felt an irrational urge to ask which year he intended to start telling it from.
Arthur Hendricks had spent thirty-four years protecting the Sterling family from lawsuits, taxes, partners, regulators, creditors, and one another.
By the time Naomi Chen deposed him, he had finally understood that protection could become another word for concealment.
The deposition took place in a neutral conference room with a court reporter at one end and three lawyers at the other. Marcus attended with Caleb Ross. Victoria sat beside Naomi.
Raymond did not attend, but his attorney did.
Naomi began gently.
“Mr. Hendricks, did Edmund Sterling ask you to prepare a new will in the six weeks before his stroke?”
“No.”
“Did he ask you to revise his estate plan?”
“Yes.”
“How?”
Arthur looked toward his lawyer.
His lawyer nodded.
Arthur answered. “He wanted to separate company voting power from beneficial ownership for a period of five years after his death.”
“For whose benefit?”
“He was considering giving Marcus enhanced voting authority during that period.”
Marcus shifted in his chair.
“And economic ownership?”
“Equal between Victoria and Marcus, after resolving a historical issue involving Evelyn Sterling’s shares.”
Victoria closed her eyes briefly.
Naomi continued. “Did Edmund say he wanted to disinherit Victoria?”
“No.”
“Did he say he wanted to disinherit his grandchildren?”
“No.”
“Did he intend Marcus to receive one hundred percent of the estate?”
“Not in any conversation I had with him.”
Marcus stared at Arthur.
Naomi placed a copy of the disputed will in front of him.
“When did you first see this document?”
“The day after the alleged execution date.”
“Who gave it to you?”
“Raymond Hale.”
“What did he say?”
“He said Edmund had changed his mind and wanted a simpler plan.”
“Did you call Edmund?”
Arthur’s face tightened. “Yes.”
Everyone in the room became still.
“What did Edmund say?”
Arthur looked down at his hands.
“He was irritated. He said, ‘I signed what we discussed.’”
Naomi paused.
“Did you ask whether ‘what we discussed’ was the will Raymond delivered?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
Arthur’s voice became almost inaudible. “Because I was afraid of what he would say.”
Victoria stared at him.
Naomi let the silence work.
“What were you afraid of?”
Arthur looked at Victoria and Marcus.
“That the document was wrong. And that correcting it would force open the older problem with Evelyn’s shares.”
Marcus leaned forward. “You knew?”
Arthur looked at him. “Yes.”
“You knew our mother’s shares belonged to us?”
“Yes.”
“And you said nothing for twenty-nine years?”
“Yes.”
Marcus stood abruptly.
Caleb touched his sleeve. “Sit down.”
Marcus remained standing for a moment, breathing hard, then sat.
Naomi continued. “Did Raymond know about the Evelyn issue?”
“Yes.”
“For how long?”
“Since at least 2008.”
“How?”
“He reviewed historical capitalization during a refinancing.”
“Did he ever discuss the legal problem with you?”
“Yes.”
“What did he say?”
Arthur swallowed. “He said reopening it would be catastrophic.”
“Catastrophic for whom?”
“He did not specify.”
Naomi placed another document on the table.
It was an email Arthur had produced the previous night.
FROM: Raymond Hale
TO: Arthur Hendricks
DATE: Five weeks before Edmund’s stroke
SUBJECT: Cleanup
We cannot let old ownership errors destabilize current control. Keep the governance revision narrow. No archaeology.
Naomi asked, “What did ‘no archaeology’ mean?”
Arthur’s eyes filled with shame.
“It meant Evelyn.”
Victoria felt something inside her become quiet.
Not healed. Not forgiven.
Quiet.
For years she had believed the central story of the Sterling family was that Edmund favored her and belittled Marcus.
Now she saw a larger pattern.
Their father had spent decades deciding which truths other people were allowed to know.
Naomi leaned forward.
“Mr. Hendricks, did you prepare a draft governance restatement for Edmund?”
“Yes.”
“How many pages?”
Arthur looked at the disputed eleven-page will.
“Thirteen.”
Lena Park’s words came back to Victoria.
The signature page had old staple impressions that did not align with the current document.
Naomi asked the question slowly.
“Was page thirteen the signature page?”
May you like
Arthur closed his eyes.
“Yes.”