scribe
THE ROAD AFTER THE LIGHTS / Chapter 3 / 10

Chapter 3 - QUESTIONS ON PAPER

Caroline took the photograph to the station before breakfast. The senior detective, Malcolm Reed, studied the pale tape on Daniel's truck and asked her how certain she was about the vehicle she had seen near the stockyard. She said she remembered the mark but not the registration. He asked whether she had seen Daniel driving. She said no. He wrote both answers down. She kept listening. Caroline appreciated the care until he explained that dozens of tradesmen used reflective tape on their trucks, particularly on rural roads with poor lighting.

“Then ask him where he was,” she said.

“We will.”

“Today?”

“We're following several leads.”

She went home with a copy of her statement and a fierce new respect for the difference between suspicion and proof. She did not want an innocent person blamed because grief had made her desperate for a face. But neither did she want another useful detail to disappear into the word several. She placed the statement in a blue folder and wrote the date across its cover. It was the first of many folders that would crowd the cupboard beside the washing machine.

The investigation settled into patterns Caroline came to recognize. Detectives called before visiting. Neighbors lowered their voices when she entered the supermarket. Somebody left flowers at the roadside and somebody else knocked them over, apparently by accident. The local paper printed a picture of the empty road every time an anniversary approached. Each year, the last streetlight looked smaller in the photograph. Each year, Caroline thought about the difference between the length of that road and the length of the silence afterward.

Peter returned to driving freight because bills arrived regardless of the police investigation. He took longer routes rather than passing the stockyard at night. When he came home, he was exhausted and tender with Josie, but he avoided Evie's room. Caroline began to resent his silence until one evening she saw him sitting in his truck behind the shed, gripping the steering wheel while the engine was off. He had been there for an hour. She climbed into the passenger seat and waited. When he finally spoke, he said that every road in the district led back to the one he had failed to travel that night.

“You were asleep,” Caroline said.

“I could have woken up.”

“And done what?”

“Something.”

She wanted to argue that love did not make people clairvoyant. She could not find a way to say it without sounding like a person who had learned the lesson in a different house. Instead she placed her hand over his, and they remained in the parked truck until Josie called them inside.

Police interviewed Daniel about the night of Evie's disappearance. He said he had driven home after visiting a cousin and had stopped near the stockyard because his engine overheated. He showed a receipt from a petrol station thirty kilometers away. It bore a time that made his route possible, if not certain. Investigators examined his truck, but no usable evidence connected it to Evie. The tape matched Caroline's description. It also matched tape sold in hardware shops throughout the district. Detectives told her he remained one of several people whose movements were being checked.

Caroline still resisted telling the town about her growing suspicions. Anna disagreed. She wanted every detail made public, believing someone might remember seeing Daniel near the road. They argued in the bakery after closing, surrounded by trays dusted with flour. Anna accused Caroline of protecting a man she barely knew. Caroline said a rumor could destroy the wrong life and still leave Evie's killer free. Their disagreement frightened them both because grief had been the one thing they thought they shared without question.

Eventually Mrs. Daley intervened. She placed Evie's unfinished recipe notebook on the counter and asked them to look at a page near the back. It contained a sketch of a cake decorated like the Bellcross football ground, complete with tiny goalposts. Beneath it Evie had written, For the next fundraiser, if we survive the committee meetings. Mrs. Daley said the girl had been working on the design for weeks. Caroline closed the notebook and realized that she and Anna were arguing about a future that had been stolen from both of them, though in different ways.

In August a laboratory report returned. The fibers on Evie's cardigan were too degraded to identify a vehicle. A small biological sample did not produce a database match. Detectives described the result as inconclusive. Caroline learned how quickly that word could become a wall: neither negative nor positive, neither empty nor helpful, simply waiting for tools that might not yet exist. She asked whether the evidence would be kept. Reed promised that it would be stored for future examination.

When winter came, Josie turned twelve. She refused a party and asked to walk with her mother to the last streetlight. Caroline wanted to say no. The road had become a place she could not pass without searching the grass. But Josie put on her school shoes and stood beside the gate. They walked before dusk, when the paddocks still held warmth. At the light Josie pressed the yellow ribbon Anna had brought into a crack in the post.

“Will they catch the person?” she asked.

“I hope so.”

“Does hope mean you think they will?”

May you like

Caroline looked toward the darkening road and could not answer honestly with yes. “It means I won't stop caring whether they do.”

Back at the house, a message waited on the answering machine. A woman from another town had seen the roadside photograph on television. She said that five years earlier a man in a truck had stopped beside her on a lonely road. She had escaped before he could hurt her. She remembered his voice and his strange habit of tapping the dashboard three times before he spoke. She did not know his name, but she had never forgotten the pale strip of tape on the tailgate.

Related Stories

Other posts