Chapter 5 - THE QUESTION HE CHOSE

The man called himself Adrian Pike. He was forty-six, with cropped hair and the restless hands of somebody who liked arranging objects until they appeared symmetrical. He arrived at the station carrying a laptop and a leather folder. He had grown fascinated by the case after seeing search volunteers pass the house. For years he collected press clippings, copied public documents, and drew maps. The blue notebook was his work. He had sent it to Eva because he believed the family had a right to know what was being overlooked.
Eva asked why he had written Anna's private phrase in handwriting that resembled hers. Adrian replied that he had traced it from a published birthday card. He seemed pleased with the effect. Eva felt the room contract around her. The copied words had made her believe that Anna might have held the book. Adrian said he had wanted her attention. He shrugged and said sometimes people needed a shock to make them act. Eva looked at the notebook and saw not a message from the past but an object deliberately designed to disturb her.
Adrian then made his accusation. He pointed to the camera, the anonymous figure reflected in the film, and a pale vehicle mentioned in one witness account. On his laptop, arrows connected those details to the name of a man who had worked near the harbor. He spoke confidently and quickly, treating each unverified resemblance as confirmation of the next. Saira asked whether he had evidence that the man knew Anna. Adrian said the pattern spoke for itself. The detective answered that patterns could not testify in court.
The man he named had since died. His daughter still lived in town and had been threatened online after the name circulated. Eva thought of Lucy and felt sick. He answered that public pressure was sometimes necessary. Eva asked what he would do if the man had been innocent. Adrian replied that innocent people had nothing to fear from questions. Saira said that was false. The room went quiet. Eva realized that she was not speaking to a villain in the dramatic sense; she was speaking to someone who enjoyed being certain more than he cared about the consequences.
Adrian insisted there was one question Eva had never asked: why had the bookshop owner kept the camera? She answered that she had asked it repeatedly and still did not know. He smiled, disappointed that his revelation had failed to surprise her. Saira asked whether he had forged the interview page in the second envelope. He said he had copied it from material obtained through a lawful request. She asked whether he had altered anything. He admitted highlighting a sentence while leaving out the next line, in which the witness said he might have confused the blue notebook with another person's belongings. Eva closed her eyes. He had supplied a genuine document in a way designed to mislead.
When the interview ended, Eva walked to the river and sat beneath a fig tree. She tried to understand why she had been so ready to trust Adrian's message. But he had not given her truth. He had given her certainty with its foundation removed. Martin found her there after Saira called to say the meeting had been difficult. Eva told him everything. She expected a lecture about recklessness. He sat beside her and said it must be painful to learn somebody had used Anna's memory that way.
The police did not arrest Adrian. His conduct was troubling, but the documents did not establish a crime under the facts then available. Saira warned him not to contact the family again and examined the evidence of online threats separately. Eva disliked that the result was so limited. Yet she also understood the distinction between wrongdoing that felt enormous and conduct that could be proved under a specific law. She had spent years pleading for those distinctions when strangers accused Daniel, Anna's former boyfriend. She could not abandon them now merely because Adrian had wounded her.
That evening Lucy joined Eva at the kitchen table. She asked whether the notebook had really belonged to Anna. Eva said no, explaining that its author had copied a phrase to make it seem personal. Lucy studied the cover and asked whether adults could be fooled because they wanted something to be true. Eva said yes. Lucy was silent for a while, then asked whether she could keep the photograph of Anna laughing with a horse. Eva said of course. The girl put it beside her homework, where it became an image of an aunt she had never met rather than a symbol of danger.
May you like
Owen Bell sent a short note apologizing for the trouble caused by the camera. Eva called him and said it was not his fault. He asked whether he should donate his father's remaining papers to the historical society. She suggested he preserve them until the police had checked whether anything else was relevant, and then decide what felt right for the family. Owen thanked her. Their conversation was ordinary, almost businesslike, but it marked a change. She had stopped treating everyone connected to the case as either a suspect or a savior. The world had more categories than those.
A week later Saira invited Eva to review the surviving evidence inventory with her. There was no dramatic lead. She wanted the family to understand what was documented, what was missing, and which tests might still be possible. Eva agreed, though she feared being disappointed again. Before the meeting, she stood before Anna's new photograph and studied the expression on her sister's face. The laughter was real, unconnected to any crime. Eva touched the frame once and whispered that she would ask better questions now. At the station, Saira opened the inventory. On the second page, beside the black shirt, Eva saw a handwritten note indicating it had been temporarily stored in an unsealed bag before proper packaging. Nobody had told her that before.