Chapter 5 - Bianca's Version

For several minutes the room at the private attorney's office seemed to contract around one fact: Bianca insisted she suppressed contact to protect Xavier from manipulation. Nobody in the immediate vicinity could pretend not to understand that something had shifted. Xavier felt the old temptation to smooth the edges of the moment, to explain another person before anyone asked. The habit had been useful once. It had also helped create the present trouble. Xavier set that habit aside and concentrated on the next honest thing that could be done.
Outside, Chicago continued with its ordinary business. People carried shopping bags, checked appointment times, argued about parking and hurried back to work. Their indifference would have seemed cruel if it had not also been a reminder that the world was larger than one family or one disputed decision. Inside, Xavier could still hear the small mechanical complaint of an elevator. The small objects nearby looked stubbornly normal. Xavier found the ordinary smell of a building that had witnessed too many arguments oddly reassuring. Nothing in the room promised an easy ending, but everything offered a place to begin again in the present tense.
The difficulty with Bianca Lao was not that every word was false. Some facts were real; the interpretation wrapped around them was where the trap lay. Xavier had once accepted that interpretation for the sake of peace. Peace, in those days, had usually meant the absence of immediate conflict rather than the presence of trust. Now the distinction felt impossible to ignore. Xavier could accept being uncertain. What Xavier could no longer accept was being ordered to treat uncertainty as guilt.
"What do you need me to do?" Phoebe Varga asked when there was finally a moment to speak privately. Xavier almost gave the easiest answer: nothing. It was the reflex of somebody who had grown accustomed to handling trouble alone. Instead, Xavier said, "Help me keep the facts straight. I don't want to say something that isn't true because I'm angry." Phoebe Varga considered that. "Then we start with what you saw, and we leave the rest for someone who can verify it." It was not a grand promise. It was a useful one.
The first useful piece of information arrived without ceremony: System logs and an access request contradict her story. Xavier read the surrounding dates carefully. Memory could be bent by fear and by the passage of time, but a record had to be tested against other records. If the documents were wrong, they would need correction. If they were right, somebody would need to explain the discrepancy. Xavier resisted the urge to show the page to everyone who had offered an opinion. Evidence deserved to be handled as evidence, not turned into a new form of public humiliation.
For most of the day, Xavier kept returning to the difference between a motive and a fact. Anger might explain why somebody wanted an outcome, but it could not establish what had occurred. Fear might make a person say something quickly, but it did not make the words accurate. Xavier wrote down three questions, crossed out the one that was merely an insult, and kept the two that somebody could answer. The small discipline felt like work. It was also a way to regain a measure of control without borrowing the methods of Bianca Lao.
Some memories were stubbornly ordinary. The way someone left a cup near the sink. The route home after a long day. The small satisfaction of putting the twins' medical records where it belonged. Nothing dramatic happened in those memories, which was why they were difficult to surrender. Xavier understood that the present dispute could not retroactively make every good day false. Nor could a good day excuse the choices that followed it. Holding both truths at once was uncomfortable, but it was better than pretending life had always been one thing.
A younger person watching all of this might learn the wrong lesson. They might see the loudest adult rewarded, or assume that being hurt meant having no choices. Xavier considered the example being set. The past could not be rewritten, but the next response could show that authority and rightness were not the same thing. It could show that an apology needed behavior behind it and that a boundary was not the same as revenge. Those were lessons worth the discomfort of a difficult conversation.
"You do not owe anyone an instant answer," Phoebe Varga said. Xavier knew that intellectually and still felt compelled to provide one. For years, hesitation had been treated as defiance and a refusal as cruelty. The pattern took time to unlearn. Xavier looked down at the twins' medical records and let the silence continue. Nothing disastrous happened because a question went unanswered for another minute. That small discovery made the next conversation easier: not pleasant, not simple, but possible to conduct without surrendering all the ground at the beginning.
May you like
At the private attorney's office, nothing would be solved by guessing what another person meant. Xavier wrote the next date in the notebook and left room for an answer. Xavier wanted a future built from actions that could be explained without shame. A word spoken in anger could not replace a careful account of events. The decision was difficult, but at least it was not a lie. There would be time for other questions later in the week. The question remained open.
In the end, the choice came down to a single practical step. Xavier removed Bianca from all trusted roles and submitted evidence for legal review. Xavier did not pretend it would settle everything. It could, however, keep another person from defining the entire situation unopposed. The next day might bring embarrassment, anger, or more complicated information. It might also bring a chance to be heard. Xavier gathered the twins' medical records and the materials needed for the morning, then allowed the evening to be finished. The future was uncertain; the immediate decision was not.