scribe

Chapter 2 - The Seat Beside Him

The birthday table had twenty seats, and Anthony counted them twice. Beatrice occupied the head beneath a portrait of his late father. His uncles gathered around glasses of expensive bourbon. His cousins wore the fixed smiles of people who had learned early to depend on the family's approval. Beside Anthony's place lay a card printed with the name Valentina Bellini.

Valentina was not simply an acquaintance. She was the daughter of a shipping partner whose company had just entered negotiations with Moretti Logistics. Years ago, before Serena, their families had hinted that Anthony and Valentina would make an excellent match. Anthony had dismissed the idea. He hadn't imagined his mother would remember it this fondly.

“Valentina is back from Rome,” Beatrice announced as he entered. “She wanted to celebrate with us.”

“Where is Serena's place?” Anthony asked.

A few conversations stopped.

His mother lifted a glass. “We agreed to keep tonight uncomplicated.”

“We did not agree,” he replied. “You informed me.”

Valentina appeared in a silver dress and offered him an awkward embrace. She lowered her voice. “For what it's worth, I was told Serena couldn't come.”

Anthony felt the first unmistakable embarrassment of the evening. He had spent seven years explaining his mother's behavior away. Here was the result: a stranger had been given a more comfortable story than his wife.

Before dinner, a photographer arranged the family around the fireplace. Beatrice directed Valentina to stand beside Anthony. Then she told everyone to lean closer and smiled with the satisfaction of a person straightening the last piece of a display.

Anthony stepped away. “Not that photograph.”

“Don't be childish,” Beatrice whispered. “The Bellinis are important.”

“My wife is important.”

Beatrice's smile hardened. “Apparently not important enough to be here.”

The sentence struck because it was technically true. Anthony had left Serena standing at home. No one had locked her out. He had simply accepted the lock and called it a compromise.

At dinner, his mother rose to toast him. She praised the Moretti legacy, the endurance of old relationships, and “the people who truly belong at this table.” Then she thanked Valentina's father for helping forge the company's future. Cameras lifted. Valentina looked mortified. Anthony heard his wife asking for a chair, and suddenly the immaculate room seemed unbearably small.

He stood before the toast ended.

“I'm going home,” he said.

Beatrice froze. “Your guests have just sat down.”

“Then apologize to them.”

“You will humiliate me in my own house?”

Anthony looked at the empty space where Serena should have stood in the photograph. “I learned from an expert.”

Valentina had caught Anthony beside the coatroom. “I didn't know,” she said, looking understandably upset. “Your mother told me your wife was traveling.” Anthony found himself unable to accuse her of anything. She had attended a dinner arranged by people she trusted, just as Serena had attended occasions organized by people who should have welcomed her. “I'm sorry she put you in that position,” he said. Valentina nodded, then removed the photograph from her phone.

He left without waiting for an answer. Marco was already at the car. He had apparently expected an early departure and kept the engine warm.

“Call Mrs. Moretti,” Anthony said.

Marco hesitated. “I did before dinner, sir. She asked me not to interrupt you.”

A hard knot formed in Anthony's stomach. “What else did she say?”

“That she hoped you enjoyed your birthday.”

Anthony called her himself. The phone went straight to voicemail. He tried again as the sedan crossed the bridge toward Westchester. There was no answer. He told himself she was punishing him with silence. The idea was easier to bear than the possibility that she had stopped caring whether he suffered.

The house was illuminated when he arrived, but its usual sounds were missing. No music from Serena's kitchen speaker. No voice calling from upstairs. Clara waited in the foyer wearing her coat.

“Where is she?” Anthony demanded.

“She left this afternoon.”

“For where?”

“Mr. Moretti, she asked me not to say.”

“I'm her husband.”

Clara's face changed. She had spent decades serving the family and almost never risked an opinion. Tonight she seemed tired of being careful.

“I know precisely who you are,” she said. “I also know she spent the morning packing while you worried about your cuff links.”

Anthony climbed the stairs two at a time. Serena's side of the dressing room was orderly, not empty. She had taken the ordinary clothes she loved, a few books, and her mother's belongings. The expensive jewelry he had given her remained in its velvet drawers. On her pillow sat a folded letter.

Anthony,

I spent seven years trying to earn a place that marriage should have given me. Every time your mother pushed me away, you asked me to understand her. You never asked her to understand me. I don't need your permission to leave, and I won't make the decision in the middle of another argument. I am safe. Please do not send your men to find me. If you want to speak, contact Leah. I need you to respect at least this one boundary.

Serena.

Anthony read it three times. He knew Leah Navarro by name and had always considered her an unnecessary precaution in Serena's independent life. Now he understood why she had needed someone who answered only to her.

His phone rang. Beatrice.

“You made a spectacle,” she snapped. “Valentina's father is furious.”

“My wife left me,” Anthony said.

His mother paused. “She'll come back. Women like Serena always do when they remember what they have.”

Anthony stared at the jewelry she had deliberately abandoned.

May you like

“No,” he said. “That is what you told yourself about her. And it is what you taught me.”

He ended the call, sat on the floor beside their bed, and listened to the house settle around him. All his resources could locate almost anyone. For the first time, he understood that finding someone and being welcome were two entirely different things.

Related Stories

Other posts