scribe

Chapter 12 - Why Cece

Ms. Price had been teaching for seventeen years. Her evaluations praised order, academic rigor, and classroom control.

They also contained a repeated phrase: can become defensive when challenged.

The investigator, Dr. Elaine Brooks, asked her about Cece.

“She questions instructions,” Ms. Price said.

“Give me an example.”

“Once I said the class had ten minutes remaining on an assignment. She pointed to the clock and said there were twelve.”

Dr. Brooks waited.

“That bothered you?”

“It undermined authority.”

“She stated the time.”

“In front of everyone.”

Another example involved a vocabulary answer. Ms. Price had marked Cece wrong, then discovered the teacher’s guide supported Cece’s definition.

“Did you correct the grade?”

“Yes.”

“Did you apologize?”

Ms. Price hesitated.

“No.”

The pattern became clear.

Cece was not disruptive. She was precise.

And Ms. Price, already sensitive to losing control, interpreted correction as defiance.

That bias made Cece an easy suspect beside the puddle.

At home Laura explained only the age-appropriate version.

“She had decided certain things about you before the spill.”

“Like that I was difficult?”

“Yes.”

“Am I?”

Laura smiled sadly. “Sometimes.”

Cece almost laughed.

“But difficult isn’t dishonest,” Laura added.

At school, Cece and Maddie remained cautious around each other.

One afternoon Maddie said, “I knew Ms. Price didn’t like when you corrected her.”

“So you thought she’d believe you.”

Maddie nodded.

Cece’s anger returned.

“You used that.”

“I did.”

“Even though we were friends.”

Maddie looked down. “That’s why it was worse.”

Cece had been avoiding that word: friends.

Before the spill, Maddie had borrowed her markers, shared snacks, and sat beside her during assemblies. They had not been best friends, but there had been trust.

“You didn’t just lie,” Cece said. “You knew who she would blame.”

“I know.”

“Stop saying you know.”

Maddie flinched.

Cece immediately regretted the sharpness but did not apologize.

Maddie whispered, “What do you want me to say?”

“I don’t know.”

That was the truth.

That night Cece wrote in a notebook the counselor had given her.

What would make it fair?

She listed possibilities: Ms. Price apologizes. Maddie apologizes. Everyone believes me. The school changes my record. Nobody calls me a liar.

Most had already happened or were happening.

Still, the feeling remained.

Then Cece wrote one final sentence:

I want to stop feeling like I have to prove every word I say.

She showed it to Laura.

Her mother read it twice.

“That,” Laura said, “may take longer.”

The next morning Hawthorne announced that Ms. Price’s employment review would conclude within two weeks.

May you like

But before the school could make its decision, Ms. Price requested one thing.

She wanted to apologize to Cece in person.

Related Stories

Other posts