scribe

Chapter 14 - His Own Name

Ethan chose a coffee shop beside a grocery store, a place where nobody would mistake their meeting for a family occasion.

Clara told Miriam where she was going. She did not record the conversation or promise to keep it private.

"I won't help you hide anything," she said before sitting down.

"I know."

He looked worse than he had in the garden. His shirt was clean, but he had missed a patch while shaving. There were two coffees on the table. He had ordered hers the way she used to drink it in college.

She no longer took sugar.

The small error made her sadder than she expected.

"How's Thomas?"

"Learning how to use his shoulder again. Slowly."

Ethan pushed his untouched cup away.

"I want to see him."

"Ask through his lawyer. Let him decide."

He nodded.

Outside, a woman wrestled a bag of groceries into the back of a car while a child held the door. Clara watched them until Ethan spoke again.

"I signed the loan consent."

"I know your signature's there."

"I mean I actually signed it. Mine wasn't copied."

"And you knew ours weren't real?"

He opened his mouth, then closed it.

"By the time the packet was complete, yes."

Clara set both hands flat on the table.

"When did you decide my name was yours to use?"

He looked at her as though she had asked a question in a language he had once known fluently.

"I didn't think of it that way."

"That's the problem."

He began to explain the nursery's debts, George's insistence, Rebecca's confidence that the loan would save everyone from having to sell anything.

Clara let him finish.

"The land was the security, Ethan. Selling it later wasn't the only way to lose it. And the fact that you hoped it would work doesn't make our signatures real."

"I know that now."

"You knew it then. You just wanted something else more."

The sentence left him silent.

She remembered being ten and knocking over an ink bottle on their father's desk. Ethan had helped her blot the stain, then stood beside her when she confessed. He had not taken the blame. He had made sure she did not stand there alone.

She wondered when he had begun believing that safety came from giving George somebody else to punish.

"Was it Rebecca?" she asked.

His eyes lifted.

"Did you care about her, or did you need her to care about you?"

He rubbed a thumb along the paper sleeve of his cup.

"Both, I think."

Clara looked away. The admission hurt, but not because it surprised her anymore.

"You were an adult. So was she. Nobody made you cross that line."

"I know."

"And Thomas didn't create what he saw."

Ethan's eyes filled.

"I know that too."

For a moment, Clara wanted to reach across the table. Then she remembered Thomas trying to open a milk carton with one hand.

She left her hands where they were.

"Dad always made me feel like I had to be worth what he'd done for me," Ethan said. "Rebecca understood that."

"Mom adopted you too. She didn't send you a bill for it."

Ethan remembered the first week after he arrived. Eleanor had let him choose a mug, an ordinary yellow one from a shelf of kitchen things. He had asked whether he could keep using it if he broke something else. She had looked startled, then told him the mug was his. For years afterward, he had remembered George's generosity more loudly than Eleanor's uncomplicated welcome. Sitting across from Clara, he understood that he had built an explanation for himself by listening to only one of the voices that raised him.

His face changed.

"You're right."

"You're my brother. That was never conditional for me. But being my brother doesn't mean I have to protect you from what you've done."

He stared at the table, and she saw the tears fall before he could hide them.

They sat through the small sounds of the shop: the grinder, the register, a chair scraping against tile. No music rose to tell either of them how to feel.

Finally, he took out his phone and set it facedown.

"There's more."

Clara's stomach tightened.

"Then you need your own lawyer. Not Dad's. Not somebody Rebecca chooses."

"Will they think I'm only talking because I'm trapped?"

"Maybe. Are you?"

He looked at her.

"Yes."

"Then tell the truth anyway. It doesn't become useless because you waited too long."

He almost smiled at the severity of that mercy.

Clara stood. "I'm not the person who can make a deal with you. And I don't want you giving me things that need to be preserved properly."

"You won't stay?"

"Not for this part."

At the door, she turned back.

"Don't delete anything. Don't ask anybody else what you should remember. Start with what happened."

He nodded.

Outside, she sat in her car for several minutes before starting it. She cried for the brother who had once stood beside her at their father's desk. Then she called Miriam and reported the conversation accurately, including what Ethan had not said.

Inside the coffee shop, Ethan searched the number of a criminal defense lawyer unconnected to his family. He had been given the name the previous day and had stared at it for hours without calling.

This time, he pressed the screen.

When the receptionist asked what the matter concerned, he looked at the phone's message history.

Rebecca's instruction was still there. Beneath it was his reply, sent while Thomas lay beside the roses.

Done.

He had remembered her words so often that he had almost allowed himself to forget his own.

May you like

"I need advice about evidence I have," he said. "And about something I did after a shooting."

He gave his name before fear could persuade him to give a smaller truth.

Related Stories

Other posts