scribe

Chapter 7 - Sophie’s Bargain

Sophie Vale stopped Evie after art class.

“Can I talk to you?”

Evie kept walking.

“No.”

“Please.”

“You told her.”

Sophie’s face fell.

“Told who?”

“You know.”

“I didn’t mean to.”

Evie stopped near the stairwell.

“You told Lillian about my dad.”

“I told Mason first.”

“That makes it better?”

“No.”

Sophie’s eyes filled.

“It was months ago. You were crying. I didn’t know it was a huge secret.”

“It was private.”

“I know.”

“You laughed when they said I stole my clothes.”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You laughed.”

Sophie looked ashamed.

Evie turned away.

“Wait.”

Sophie grabbed her wrist, then immediately let go.

“I’m sorry.”

Evie looked down at the place Sophie had touched.

Sophie whispered, “Lillian has screenshots.”

“Of what?”

“Messages between us. Old ones. The night you told me your dad yelled about the bracelet.”

Evie’s stomach dropped.

“You sent them to her?”

“No. She took my phone at a sleepover.”

“Why?”

“She said she wanted to look at pictures.”

“And you let her?”

“I didn’t know.”

Evie stared at her.

Sophie’s voice shook. “She has stuff about everyone.”

“What stuff?”

“Mason cheated on a science quiz. Liam made a fake account to make fun of another kid. Me…” Sophie looked toward the hall. “I said something horrible about my sister when I was mad. Lillian saves everything.”

Evie felt cold despite the heated hallway.

“So that’s why nobody says anything.”

Sophie nodded.

“She makes you think if you tell, she’ll destroy you too.”

Evie’s anger faltered.

Not disappeared.

Changed.

“You still left me in the mud.”

Sophie looked down.

“I know.”

“Why didn’t you help?”

“Because I was scared she’d turn everyone against me.”

“She already turned everyone against me.”

Sophie began crying.

Evie wanted to comfort her.

She hated herself for still wanting to.

Instead she said, “Tell Ms. Price.”

Sophie shook her head immediately.

“You have to.”

“She’ll call my parents.”

“Then tell them.”

“You don’t understand.”

“What don’t I understand?”

“My parents think Lillian is my best friend. My mom drives us to dance. Our families know each other.”

Evie’s voice hardened. “That’s not a reason.”

Sophie looked at her.

Evie heard herself say the sentence Ms. Price had once told her.

“If someone is using fear to control you, that’s not friendship.”

Sophie stared.

Then footsteps sounded.

Lillian appeared at the end of the corridor.

She looked at both girls.

“Everything okay?”

Sophie wiped her face.

“Yeah.”

Evie said nothing.

Lillian smiled.

“Good.”

She walked past them.

As she did, she whispered so softly only Evie heard:

“Careful.”

That night Sophie sent Evie one message.

I’ll tell the truth if you do.

Evie read it again and again.

Then typed:

Tomorrow.

She did not press send for almost ten minutes.

When she finally did, the word felt heavier than any confession she had ever made.

Sophie barely slept after sending “Tomorrow.”

At breakfast, her mother noticed the dark circles beneath her eyes.

“Dance stress?”

Sophie shook her head.

“School?”

Another shake.

Her mother sighed. “You know I can’t help if you answer everything with your neck.”

Sophie nearly told her.

Then she pictured Lillian’s screenshots.

She imagined her mother reading the cruel message about Sophie’s younger sister: I wish Mom had never had her.

Sophie had written it after an argument and regretted it within minutes. Lillian had saved it for months.

By the time Sophie reached school, fear had turned into anger.

Not at Evie.

At herself.

At Lillian.

At the strange system they had all agreed to without ever saying it aloud.

When she and Evie stood outside Ms. Price’s room, Sophie whispered, “If I chicken out, don’t let me leave.”

Evie looked at her.

“That’s not my job.”

Sophie flinched.

Then Evie added, “But I’ll go in first.”

That was enough.

Inside, Ms. Price saw their faces and immediately closed the door.

“You don’t have to tell me together.”

“We do,” Sophie said.

Evie looked surprised.

Sophie’s voice trembled.

“If I’m alone, I’ll lie.”

The statement broke something open.

Ms. Price called Dr. Grant.

While they waited, she offered water.

Neither girl drank.

They sat side by side without touching.

For the first time since recess, Evie understood that courage did not feel like certainty.

May you like

It felt like sitting in a room while every part of you wanted to run.

And staying anyway.

Related Stories

Other posts