Chapter 6 - The Answer He Couldn't Give

Grant asked me to meet him on Sunday. Not at our house, not at the lodge, not where a waiter could overhear us. He suggested the public garden near the Deschutes River, a place we'd visited a hundred times while planning hikes that sometimes turned into sandwiches on a bench.
Brooke dropped me off and promised to return when I called. I could have driven myself. I chose not to. I didn't want to have to be calm enough for the road afterward.
Grant was waiting under a maple tree, wearing the navy jacket I'd bought him for his birthday. He had shaved badly. There were shadows beneath his eyes. My heart did something cruel and automatic when I saw him: it reached toward the familiar shape of his face.
He stood as I approached.
“Hi, Ave.”
“Hi.”
“I don't know whether I can hug you.”
“Not today.”
He sat again.
For a while we watched the river. A cyclist passed. Somebody's dog shook water onto the path. Ordinary life went on with an indifference I almost envied.
“I was an idiot,” Grant said eventually.
I waited.
“I did something thoughtless and humiliating. I should have known how it would look.”
“You knew how it would look. You arranged a spotlight.”
He rubbed his palms together. “I wanted a moment.”
“What kind of moment?”
He looked down. “I don't think I understood it myself.”
“Try.”
“Lila left. You know that. For years I thought she'd been the person who was supposed to choose me and didn't. When we got engaged, I was happy. I was. But there was this part of me that wanted her to see I was happy. I wanted her to see what she'd lost.”
“So you asked her to dance.”
“I thought it would be... I don't know. Poetic.”
I looked across the river, where a pair of ducks were pushing against the current.
“Grant, you weren't satisfied with her seeing you happy. You wanted her to interrupt your wedding.”
He flinched.
“I didn't think she'd actually do it.”
“You told her that if she took your hand, you'd understand.”
“I was being dramatic.”
“You keep using that word as if drama happens to people without their permission.”
He said nothing.
I turned toward him. “If she had stood up, what would you have done?”
He stared at the path.
“Grant.”
“I don't know.”
“Would you have danced with her?”
“Maybe for a minute. I wouldn't have left you.”
“You were willing to let me wonder.”
He looked up sharply. “I thought you knew I loved you.”
“I did. I loved you too.”
“Then why can't we fix this?”
“Because you still think the problem was how it looked.”
His jaw tightened. I watched the anger come and go, competing with what I hoped was shame.
“I spent weeks on that surprise,” he said quietly.
“Yes,” I answered. “That's why this isn't a mistake that lasted ten seconds.”
He covered his face with both hands.
I remembered the kindnesses he'd given me: heating the car, remembering my mother's birthday, sitting beside my bed after I had surgery to remove a benign growth two years earlier. People like simple stories about monsters and saints. I wanted one too. It would have been easier to hate a man who had never been good to me.
But I had married someone capable of tenderness, and he had still made a choice that told me exactly how far that tenderness reached when his pride was involved.
“I have done everything I can think of,” he said. “I called. I apologized. I told everyone I was wrong.”
“You told people you were misunderstood.”
“Fine. I was wrong.”
The words landed between us like a coin he expected me to pick up.
“Do you see the difference?” I asked. “You wanted her to regret leaving you. To get that reaction, you made your own wife stand alone in the middle of the dance floor. I wasn't even a person in the plan. I was proof that someone had chosen you.”
He stared at me.
Then he whispered, “That's not how I thought of you.”
“Maybe not. But it's how you treated me.”
His eyes filled. He reached into his jacket and took out my wedding band. It was threaded onto a narrow silver chain, the kind people sometimes use to hold a key.
“I didn't know what to do with it,” he said.
Neither did I. Seeing it there made me want to run to him and away from him at the same time.
“Are you coming home?” he asked.
“I don't know.”
“Can you at least tell me there's a chance?”
I thought of my mother's voice on the phone: There is no decision you have to make tonight. It had been more than a week. The permission still mattered.
“I can tell you I won't decide because you're afraid of what people think,” I said. “And I won't decide because you're lonely.”
He gripped the chain.
“Then what do I do?”
“Answer the question you keep avoiding. Why did you need Lila to choose you on the night I already had?”
May you like
I stood and walked toward the parking area. Grant didn't follow.
He was still sitting beneath the maple when Brooke's car pulled up, one hand closed around the ring he had spent so many hours planning to give me.