scribe

Chapter 23 - Under Oath

Major Celeste Ardin’s case was the hardest for Avie to understand because Ardin occupied the uncomfortable space between corruption and cowardice.

By then Avie had learned how badly people wanted moral arithmetic. Soldiers asked whether Ardin was “as bad as” Mae, whether Mae was “worse than” Lorna, whether Stephen Vale was the true villain and everyone else merely weak. Avie stopped answering. Those comparisons flattened choices that needed to remain distinct. Stephen had participated in financial fraud. Ardin had concealed and influenced. Mae had coerced and sabotaged. Lorna had weaponized private records. Wen had altered safety equipment under blackmail. Avie had struck Wen in anger. The fact that the acts connected did not make them interchangeable.

The evidence did not show that Ardin forged Daniel’s appraisal.

It did show she knew her brother was pressuring personnel during the Alder transaction, suspected records had been manipulated, and failed to make a complete report.

Years later, after becoming a senior operations officer at Bellwether, she allowed Rainline to become deeply embedded in installation programs despite knowing about her family’s historical connection.

She created the mentorship network that Mae converted into a control system.

She described Avie as a risk because of Daniel’s history.

She told Mae to “manage” that risk.

She retained the red box for eleven months instead of reporting it.

She had not ordered Wen to switch the locking insert.

That distinction remained.

At her administrative hearing, Ardin testified under oath.

Avie attended only the portion for which she was authorized.

Ardin’s attorney asked why she had written Stephen in 2018 telling him to stop pushing the appraisal.

“Because I knew something was wrong,” Ardin said.

“Why did you later tell him you needed it contained?”

“Because I became afraid that his conduct would be treated as mine.”

“Was it yours?”

“No.”

“Then why not report it?”

Ardin looked toward the panel.

“Because I had spent fifteen years becoming the first person in my family whose career did not depend on Stephen’s money or connections. I believed reporting him would collapse the distinction between us.”

Avie felt something cold move through her.

Ardin had tried to protect the distinction by hiding evidence that would have proved it.

The panel asked about Mae.

“Did you intend Sergeant Corvane to manipulate evaluations?”

“I intended her to influence outcomes informally.”

“How?”

“Mentoring, discouraging unsuitable applicants, identifying risk.”

“Outside published criteria?”

Ardin hesitated.

“Yes.”

“Did you understand that was improper?”

“Not fully at first.”

“And later?”

“Yes.”

“Why continue?”

Ardin’s answer was quiet.

“Because the results benefited programs I believed were important.”

There it was.

Not money.

Not a hidden envelope.

Power justified by purpose.

The panel substantiated serious failures of judgment, improper influence in training processes, undisclosed conflicts and mishandling of evidence. Ardin was permanently removed from operations leadership and received formal adverse administrative action. She later submitted retirement paperwork while additional review determined the appropriate terms of her departure.

No one called it exoneration.

No one called it the same as Stephen Vale’s fraud.

Different acts received different names.

After the hearing, Ardin asked to speak to Avie in the presence of counsel.

Avie agreed.

They stood in an empty conference room.

Ardin looked older than she had in their first meeting.

“I owe you an apology.”

“Yes.”

The answer surprised her.

Ardin nodded.

“I told myself keeping you off the review team prevented a conflict.”

“You knew it protected your past.”

“Yes.”

“You let people turn my father’s name into a warning label.”

“Yes.”

Avie waited for explanation.

Ardin did not give one.

Instead she said, “Your father confronted me once after the 2018 review. He said silence was a decision, not an absence of one. I resented him for that.”

Avie’s throat tightened.

“He was right.”

“Yes.”

Avie looked through the window toward the wet training fields.

“Do you want forgiveness?”

“No.”

“Good.”

Ardin almost smiled.

Avie continued, “I don’t know if I’ll ever forgive you. But I don’t need to make you worse than you were in order to know what you did was wrong.”

Ardin lowered her eyes.

“That is more mercy than I gave your father.”

“It isn’t mercy.”

“What is it?”

“Accuracy.”

Avie left before Ardin could answer.

Outside, Wen waited under the awning.

“How was it?”

“Complicated.”

“I hate that word too.”

They started walking.

Wen nudged Avie’s shoulder lightly.

“You know, a year ago you would’ve called her evil and gone for a run.”

“A year ago you would’ve hidden a crisis until it ate the furniture.”

“That is unfairly specific.”

“You alphabetized solvent.”

Wen groaned.

May you like

The rain fell harder.

Neither hurried.

Related Stories

Other posts