scribe

Chapter 7 - The Paper Leontis Had Already Seen

Leontis worked for Fenwick & Vale, a mid-sized Manhattan law firm that advised property owners on financing and development agreements. He did not practice the courtroom law that television made exciting. He reviewed leases, found risks buried in schedules, and composed sentences precise enough to prevent disputes no one wanted. He had joined the firm four years earlier and earned a reputation for being calm under pressure.

On Wednesday, a partner named Martin Greaves summoned him to discuss the Ashford portfolio. Bram Ashford's holding company had retained the firm before Leontis became engaged to Vesperine. The relationship had been disclosed, and Leontis was formally separated from certain decisions affecting his in-laws. But the work was familiar: a cluster of aging commercial properties, proposed renovations, financing terms, and tenants who complicated the balance sheet.

Martin pushed a folder across the desk.

—We're updating the schedule for the West Thirty-Seventh property. They want a clean path to the end of the current leases. Just review the assumptions.

Leontis opened it. On the third page, under a list of occupants, he found Hearthside Stitch House. The date beside the name was December 31. In a memo he himself had reviewed eight months earlier, Hearthside's tenancy was described as small and nonessential. He remembered approving the phrase after receiving a spreadsheet that showed the workshop's rent contributed almost nothing to the building's income.

Back then the name had not troubled him. He knew his grandmother volunteered somewhere in the Garment District, but he had never asked for the legal name. She spoke of students and needles, of a difficult zipper or a young woman who had learned to make a coat. He spoke of his job in abstractions, and they had each left the other's world comfortably indistinct.

Now he stared at the paper until Martin noticed.

—Problem?

—My grandmother teaches there. At Hearthside.

Martin leaned back. —Then you shouldn't handle this part. Let me have the file.

The instruction was appropriate and simple. Leontis knew that recusal would address the firm's conflict. It would not address his own. For months he had passed through meetings about the future of a building without considering that it housed people for whom the work meant more than rent.

—Has the owner made a decision? —he asked.

—Not that I'm aware of. But they don't want an extension complicating financing. You need to step away from the file, Leo.

Leontis closed the folder. His name sat on the earlier memo in small print. He could not pretend he had never touched it.

He opened the firm's conflict policy and read it despite knowing the relevant paragraphs by heart. It prescribed disclosure, independent assignment, and preservation of client confidences. It did not prescribe how to speak to a grandmother who might lose her weekly community because of work one had treated as abstract. He wrote down what he could legitimately do: direct Tamsin to independent counsel, identify public sources, keep the firm informed, and answer Evadne's questions truthfully about his own role. Then he crossed out a fourth line suggesting he speak privately to Bram. A favor from a family member might bypass the very process Hearthside needed to rely on.

For the first time he recognized how much his profession had rewarded the habit of putting emotion into a separate box. Often the separation was valuable. A lawyer who made a client's decision personal could become careless. But facts did not cease to have human consequences because they were printed in small type. Leontis could not convert his grandmother's work into a privileged part of his client's file, and he could not continue pretending that the file contained no grandmother.

At lunch he called Tamsin Bell. He had never met her, though Evadne spoke of her often. When he explained who he was, the line grew quiet.

—Your grandmother has talked about you —Tamsin said. —Usually with pride.

He swallowed. —I'm calling because I saw a document affecting your lease. I can't discuss confidential client material. But I can tell you to obtain independent legal advice immediately, and I can give you contacts for nonprofit tenant assistance.

—We already have someone looking at it. Is there something else I should know?

He paused at a traffic light, surrounded by people walking faster than he could think. He could neither reveal his firm's confidential analysis nor justify withholding the basic fact of his involvement from his grandmother forever.

—You should know that I've worked on the property's files before. I didn't realize it was your workshop. That's not an excuse. I'm withdrawing from the matter and disclosing the connection through the firm.

Tamsin said nothing for several seconds. Then: —I'll tell Evadne myself if you don't.

—I will.

The call ended. Leontis stayed by the curb as traffic swept past. He had imagined that his worst act at the wedding was failing to say a sentence in public. Now he was beginning to see a pattern of private omissions: times he chose not to ask, times he found it easier to stay ignorant, times convenience wore the clothes of diplomacy.

That evening he brought the folder's existence, not its confidential contents, into the conversation with Vesperine.

—Your father's company owns the building where Grandma teaches —he said. —The workshop may lose its lease.

Vesperine looked up. —I didn't know that.

—Neither did I, not the connection. But I've handled papers for the building. My name is on an analysis that treats the workshop as expendable.

—Surely Daddy can fix it.

May you like

Leontis heard himself preparing to agree. It would be easy, and perhaps Bram could arrange a reprieve with a phone call. Then he thought of Hearthside's students, of independent advice, of the fact that a family favor could be withdrawn as easily as it was granted.

—I don't want it fixed as a wedding gift —he said. —I want to know what they have a right to ask for.

Related Stories

Other posts