scribe

Chapter 21 - THE APOLOGY THAT WASN’T

The letter came through solicitors.

Bethan called before forwarding it.

“You don’t have to read this.”

Seren sat at her desk at work, staring at a spreadsheet she had not absorbed for twenty minutes.

“Is it relevant?”

“To the case, possibly. To your wellbeing, maybe not.”

“What is it?”

“A statement from Morcant.”

Seren knew before asking.

“An apology?”

“He calls it one.”

That answer decided her.

“Send it.”

The email arrived thirty seconds later.

Seren opened the attachment.

Dear Seren,

I am sorry for the pain this situation has caused you and Eirlys.

She stopped.

Not for what I did.

For the pain this situation has caused.

She continued.

I accept that I made mistakes while under extreme financial and emotional pressure. I should have asked for help instead of trying to handle everything alone. I never intended for Eirlys to go hungry, and I categorically deny deliberately starving her. I acknowledge that some food in the house was not suitable and that I lost my temper on the evening of the phone call.

Seren’s pulse quickened.

Lost my temper.

Not struck her.

The letter went on.

I also recognize that Seren and I had developed an unhealthy relationship around finances, with both of us contributing to conflict and mistrust.

Seren laughed under her breath.

There it was.

Shared blame.

Balanced scales.

A false symmetry between secret loans and asking where money went.

Between selling a bracelet and searching for it.

Between starving a child and being angry about it.

The last paragraph was the most polished.

I hope one day Eirlys can understand that I loved her and that none of this reflects the totality of the father figure I tried to be. I am willing to undertake therapy and parenting work to repair the damage caused by everyone involved.

Everyone involved.

Seren closed the document.

She did not feel rage.

That surprised her.

Months ago, the letter would have pulled her into argument.

She would have written responses in the margins.

No, that’s not what happened.

No, you said this.

No, I transferred that.

No, she was three.

Now she saw the structure more clearly.

Morcant did not need her to agree.

He needed her to engage.

Engagement had always given him somewhere to move the conversation.

Seren called Bethan.

“I’m not replying.”

“That is an option.”

“Will silence hurt me legally?”

“No.”

“Then silence.”

She deleted the local copy but kept the solicitor’s official file intact.

At five, she picked Eirlys up from nursery.

The child came running with paint on both hands.

“We made moons!”

Seren crouched.

“I can see that.”

“My moon is purple.”

“Of course it is.”

They walked home holding hands.

Halfway there, Eirlys asked, “Daddy Morcant say sorry?”

Seren stopped.

She had not mentioned the letter.

“How did you know?”

Eirlys shrugged.

“He says sorry when he wants happy.”

Seren felt the old ache return.

“Sometimes people say sorry because they mean it,” she said carefully. “And sometimes saying sorry is only the first part.”

“What’s second?”

“Changing what they do.”

Eirlys considered this.

“Like no moldy food?”

Seren’s throat tightened.

“Yes.”

“And no hitting?”

The world seemed to pause.

Seren knelt on the pavement.

It was the first time Eirlys had used the word herself.

“No hitting,” Seren said.

Eirlys touched her own cheek.

“He hit me.”

Seren kept her voice steady.

“I believe you.”

“He said I made him.”

“You did not make him.”

“I shouted Mommy.”

“You were allowed to call me.”

“He said I ruined it.”

Seren’s eyes filled.

“What did you ruin?”

“The phone.”

The child looked ashamed.

“Because you heard.”

Seren breathed slowly.

“No, darling. You did something very important.”

“What?”

“You called for me.”

Eirlys looked at her.

“And I heard you.”

The child’s face changed.

Not dramatically.

A tiny release around the eyes.

Then she held out her painted hand.

Seren took it.

They walked home.

That evening, Seren documented the disclosure exactly as Carys had taught her.

No interpretation.

No extra questions.

Just the words.

He hit me.

I shouted Mommy.

Because you heard.

For months Seren had replayed the phone call as the moment she failed to protect her daughter soon enough.

May you like

That night, for the first time, she heard another truth inside it.

It was also the moment Eirlys found a way through.

Related Stories

Other posts