Chapter 19 - The Story Percival Told

At Merehaven, Percival changed tactics.
He stopped denying every document and began explaining them.
The false seal, he claimed, had been Godfrey’s solution to administrative inconvenience. The altered accounts were bookkeeping corrections. The Veyne debt had been purchased in good faith from Thomas March. The petition concerning Isolde’s judgment had been drafted only because he feared the strain of pregnancy was making her vulnerable to manipulation.
And the manipulation, he said, came from Wilhelmina and Roland.
“They discovered common cause after turning against me,” Percival told Calder during a preliminary examination. “One is a discarded mistress facing poverty. The other is a neighboring knight eager to weaken Ashcombe. My wife is caught between them.”
Calder wrote without expression.
“And the intercepted letter from Lady Eleanor?”
“A private marital matter.”
“The right-facing falcon?”
“Godfrey arranged seals.”
“The schedule in your hand projecting Wrenford revenues after sole administration?”
“A prudent estimate.”
Percival had an answer for everything because each answer isolated one piece from the others.
Isolde recognized the method. He had used it on her for years.
Agnes recognized it too. “He is making each witness answer only for the piece they saw,” she said that evening. “Ralph saw the road. Tobias saw the accounts. Wilhelmina saw the petition. None of us saw all of it.”
“That is why he keeps calling each piece too small,” Isolde replied.
Tobias spread a clean roll across the table and drew a line down its center. On the left he wrote dates. On the right he wrote the document or witness attached to each date. He was slow with names, careful not to blot the ink.
“If the earl’s clerk sees the order,” he said, “Lord Percival cannot move every event into a different room.”
Isolde looked at the young clerk. “Keep that roll. And make two copies.”
Agnes smiled. “You sound like Lady Eleanor.”
This time the comparison did not wound.
A late night was only a late night. A missing rent roll was only clerical confusion. A mistress in her chamber was only a quarrel. A petition was only concern.
He survived by making patterns disappear.
So Isolde’s task became simple: restore the pattern.
In the guest hall at Merehaven, she arranged the evidence chronologically with Agnes and Tobias.
First: Lord Alaric’s debts.
Then Percival’s courtship.
Then Eleanor’s protected settlement.
Then Godfrey’s attempt to replace the seal.
Then diverted Wrenford rents.
Then the fabricated Veyne debt and Wilhelmina’s dependence.
Then Percival’s private borrowing.
Then the petition designed to obtain sole administration.
Then the attempt to intercept Brother Anselm.
Then the attack on Roland’s party.
Roland frowned at the last item.
“We cannot prove Percival ordered that attack.”
“Then we do not claim it,” Isolde said.
Agnes looked at her.
“Even though everyone knows?”
“Knowing is not proving.”
She thought of the mysterious road-service payment before Sir Odo’s death.
“We will not become careless because he was.”
Wilhelmina entered carrying her written deposition.
“I have included the affair.”
Isolde looked up.
“All of it?”
“Enough.”
“That sounds like not all.”
Wilhelmina sat down opposite her.
“I included when it began, what he promised, the sheepfolds, the petition, and what he said about sending you to Saint Mildred’s.”
“And the distaff?”
Wilhelmina’s jaw tightened.
“Yes.”
She slid the statement across the table.
At the bottom she had written, in her own hand:
No promise by Lord Percival compelled me to strike Lady Isolde. I did that from jealousy and spite. I offer this because he relied upon that spite, but it remains mine.
Isolde read the line twice.
“That will cost you.”
“I know.”
“People may remember the blow more clearly than his fraud.”
“Then they will remember something true.”
A knock sounded.
Sir Bran entered with a man in travel-stained merchant’s clothes, wrists tied before him.
“Found at the east gate trying to leave Merehaven before sunrise,” Bran said.
The prisoner swore.
Calder entered behind them.
“Lady Isolde, Lady Wilhelmina—this is Thomas March.”
Godfrey’s cousin looked older than Isolde expected, with clever eyes and ink stains on his fingers.
Two soldiers carried in his saddlebags.
Calder emptied the first onto the table.
Coins, blank parchment, two seal knives, and three folded letters spilled out.
From the second bag came a small wooden box.
Calder opened it.
Inside, wrapped in lambskin, lay a bronze seal matrix.
A falcon faced right.
May you like
No one spoke.
Thomas March looked at Isolde and said, “If you mean to blame me for all of it, you had better read the letters first.”