Chapter 29 - AVELISSE ASKS WHY

At seven, Avelisse asked the question they had known would come.
Not where Grandma was.
Why.
It happened during breakfast on an ordinary Tuesday.
She was eating toast and reading a library book at the same time, an activity Oriane had forbidden twice and then quietly surrendered to.
A photograph had fallen from an old album the previous evening.
In it, Vespera stood behind Avelisse's christening chair, one elegant hand resting on Théodric's shoulder.
Everyone looked happy.
Avelisse placed the photograph on the table.
"Was Grandma nice to me when I was a baby?"
Théodric and Oriane looked at each other.
"Sometimes," Oriane said.
Avelisse frowned.
"But she hit me?"
They had never lied about that, but neither had they described the whole scene.
"Yes," Théodric said.
"Why?"
There it was.
The question adults kept trying to answer with money, history, pathology, family culture, fear, control, and legal language.
A seven-year-old wanted one sentence.
Théodric set down his coffee.
"Because you were crying for Mommy and Grandma was angry that she couldn't control what was happening. She made a wrong and harmful choice."
Avelisse stared at the photograph.
"Was Mommy sick?"
Oriane nodded.
"Grandma gave me medicine I didn't agree to take, and it made me pass out."
Avelisse's face changed.
"On purpose?"
"Yes."
"Why?"
Oriane answered carefully.
"Because I had learned something Grandma wanted to hide, and she thought making me seem sick would stop people believing me."
Avelisse absorbed that.
"Did Daddy believe you?"
The question went through Théodric like a blade.
Oriane did not rescue him.
Good.
He answered.
"Not soon enough."
Avelisse looked at him.
"Why?"
"Because I had grown up believing Grandma was usually right. I wanted everyone to stop arguing, and I confused stopping arguments with fixing problems."
Avelisse chewed the inside of her cheek.
"That's silly."
Théodric laughed softly.
"Yes. It was."
"Did you say sorry?"
"Many times."
"Did Mommy forgive you?"
Oriane took a sip of coffee.
"Mostly."
Théodric looked offended.
Avelisse giggled.
The tension broke.
Then she returned to the photograph.
"Do I have to forgive Grandma?"
Both parents answered at once.
"No."
Avelisse blinked.
Théodric continued.
"You don't have to decide that now. Or because anyone tells you to. Forgiveness is not the same as saying something was okay, and it is not a ticket someone earns to come back into your life."
"Do you forgive her?"
This time Théodric took longer.
"I don't know what word I would use. I don't want revenge. I hope she becomes better. I also don't want her close to us right now."
Avelisse nodded as though this were perfectly sensible.
Children sometimes accepted complexity more easily than adults, provided no one demanded they simplify it.
She tucked the photograph back into the album.
"Can I be late for school because family talk is important?"
Oriane pointed toward the hallway.
"Shoes. Now."
Avelisse groaned theatrically and ran upstairs.
Théodric watched her go.
"How did we do?"
Oriane leaned against him.
"Ask me in fifteen years."
That afternoon, Avelisse came home with a drawing.
It showed three stick figures beneath a yellow roof.
A smaller building stood far away with many windows.
"What's that?" Théodric asked.
"Lantern House."
"And this?"
"Our house."
Not Darnay House.
Not the cottage either.
Three years earlier, they had bought a modest house near the edge of town. It had a garden, uneven floors, and no portrait gallery.
Avelisse had chosen the yellow paint for her bedroom.
"Who's this?" Théodric asked, pointing at a fourth tiny shape in the garden.
"Fox."
"Of course."
"Daddy."
"Yes?"
"People can have old family and new family, right?"
He looked at her.
"People can build the kind of family that keeps everyone safe."
May you like
Avelisse nodded.
Then she ran outside to play.