scribe

Chapter 28 - THE FAMILY TREE

The trouble began with a school worksheet.

Lioren had started a small nursery program three mornings a week. She liked finger paint, hated bananas, and had developed a fierce loyalty to a boy named Theo who could whistle through the gap in his front teeth.

One Friday, the class made family trees.

The teacher sent a note home beforehand explaining that families came in many forms and children could include anyone important to them.

Cassian did not expect difficulty.

He was wrong.

At pickup, Lioren’s teacher asked to speak privately.

“She became upset,” Ms. Rowan said. “Not severely. But when another child asked where her mother was, Lioren said, ‘My first mama died and my second mama was a liar.’”

Cassian closed his eyes briefly.

“That is… concise.”

Ms. Rowan almost smiled.

“Then the other child asked whether that meant Lioren did not have a real mother. Lioren said she was a stray.”

Cassian’s chest tightened.

“Did anyone tell her that word?”

“No. She used it herself.”

“Was she crying?”

“She became angry. She tore the worksheet.”

At home, Cassian found Lioren under the dining table with Bramble and half a biscuit.

He sat on the floor outside the tablecloth.

“May I come under?”

“No.”

“Okay.”

He waited.

After a minute, her small hand appeared and placed half the biscuit on the carpet beside him.

A peace offering.

He ate it.

After another minute she said, “Theo has two mamas.”

“Yes.”

“Mina has one mama and no papa.”

“Yes.”

“I have a dead mama, a bad mama, a grandmama, and you.”

“That sounds crowded.”

“No.” She pushed the cloth aside. “Serilda is not my mama.”

Cassian chose his words carefully.

“She was your stepmother. You do not have to call her Mama.”

“Then why did you make me?”

The question struck cleanly.

Cassian remembered encouraging it after the wedding.

It will help her feel included, he had said.

He had meant Serilda.

Not Lioren.

“I thought it would help us become a family,” he said. “I should have let you choose.”

Lioren crawled out.

“What is a stray?”

“A stray animal is one that does not have a home or whose home cannot be found.”

“Am I one?”

“No.”

“How do you know?”

Cassian did not say because I am your father as though biology alone settled belonging.

He pointed around the room.

“You know where you sleep.”

“Yes.”

“You know where your yellow boots are.”

“By the back door.”

“You know who comes when you call at night.”

“You. Or Grandmama.”

“You know where Bramble lives.”

“In my bed.”

“You know who is allowed to hug you.”

“People I say yes to.”

“Exactly.”

He smiled.

“A stray is lost. You are not lost.”

Lioren looked down at Bramble.

“Can I make a new tree?”

“Of course.”

They spread paper across the floor.

Lioren drew badly shaped circles with green crayon.

One for Annelise.

One for Cassian.

One for Eudoria.

One for Marta.

One for Bramble, despite Cassian explaining that rabbits were not usually included in genealogy.

“Bramble is family.”

“Then Bramble stays.”

She left one empty circle.

Cassian noticed but did not ask.

Finally she wrote an S with help.

“Serilda?” he asked.

Lioren nodded.

“Do you want her on the tree?”

“She was in the family.”

“Yes.”

“But not here.”

Lioren drew a line from the S away from the other circles, then put a square around it.

Cassian did not interpret the drawing for her.

He let it be hers.

The next week, Ms. Rowan displayed the family trees.

Lioren’s took up two sheets of paper because Bramble’s ears were too large.

When another child asked about the square around S, Lioren said simply:

“She lived with us, but she was not safe, so now she doesn’t.”

Then she went back to painting a sun purple.

Cassian heard about it at pickup.

On the drive home, he looked at his daughter in the rearview mirror.

She was singing nonsense to herself.

The word stray had not vanished from her memory.

It had simply stopped owning the definition.

The family-tree incident became a turning point for Cassian too. He realized he had been waiting for the day Lioren would stop mentioning Serilda entirely, as though healing meant deletion. Dr. Malik corrected him.

"Children integrate experiences. They do not necessarily erase them."

"So she may always talk about her?"

"Sometimes. The goal is not silence. The goal is choice."

Cassian understood. Serilda had tried to control Lioren's story by deciding what the child was allowed to believe about herself. Cassian could repeat the mistake by deciding which memories were acceptable to keep.

When Lioren later asked whether Serilda had ever been nice, Cassian did not say no.

"Sometimes," he said. "She read you stories. She bought you the yellow raincoat you liked. And she also hurt you and lied."

Lioren frowned. "Both?"

"Both."

She thought for a long time.

"I still like the raincoat."

May you like

"You're allowed."

The next morning she wore it to school. Cassian watched her jump from the car, yellow hood bouncing. The coat no longer belonged to Serilda's narrative. It belonged to the child wearing it.

Related Stories

Other posts