Chapter 10 - THE PHOTO FROM 2008

That night, Amara spread old family photographs across Darius’s dining table.
She had asked him for everything from before she could remember.
He brought three boxes.
Marcus appeared in the earliest photographs: holding baby Amara at a hospital window, asleep on a sofa with her on his chest, standing beside Naima at a cookout.
Then the pictures thinned.
Amara at two with Naima.
Amara at three with Naima and Celeste.
Amara at four blowing out candles while a younger Darius stood awkwardly at the edge of the frame holding paper plates.
By five, Darius had moved closer.
By six, he was kneeling beside her in nearly every picture.
“Did Mom love Marcus?” Amara asked.
Darius knew whom she meant.
“Yes.”
“Even after they separated?”
“Sometimes people stop being able to live together before they stop loving each other.”
“Did you hate him?”
“No.”
“That’s not believable.”
Darius smiled without humor.
“I disliked the effect he had on her. That’s different.”
Amara picked up a photograph dated 2008.
She was four, wearing purple rain boots. Marcus stood in the background, thinner than she remembered him, one hand raised as if he were arguing with someone outside the frame.
“Who took this?”
“Celeste.”
“What was happening?”
Darius looked at the photo.
“Marcus came by unexpectedly.”
“Did I see him?”
“Yes.”
“I don’t remember.”
“You were excited.”
“What happened?”
“He promised he’d take you to the zoo the next morning.”
Amara waited.
“He didn’t come.”
Her fingers tightened around the photo.
“Was that common?”
Darius looked away.
“How common?”
“Enough.”
Amara set the photograph down.
“Why didn’t anyone tell me any of this when he came back?”
“Because you were happy.”
“That’s not a reason.”
“No,” Darius said. “It’s fear.”
“Fear of what?”
“That if I told you, you’d hear jealousy instead of warning.”
Amara looked at him.
“And were you jealous?”
“Yes.”
Again, the unprotected answer.
Darius leaned forward.
“I hated watching you light up every time he called. Not because I wanted him gone. Because I knew what it would do to you if he disappeared again.”
Amara looked back at the photograph.
Marcus was smiling toward her in the image.
The smile looked real.
That was the hardest part.
People could love you and still fail you.
People could hurt you without lying every second.
She sorted through more photographs.
At seven, she stood between Naima and Darius at a school fair, face painted like a butterfly.
At nine, she sat on Darius’s shoulders at a parade.
At twelve, Marcus was absent from every frame.
“Did he send birthday cards?”
“Not that I remember.”
“Money?”
“Occasionally.”
“How occasionally?”
“Twice.”
“Calls?”
Darius sighed.
“Amara.”
“I need the facts.”
“Then ask him too.”
“I will.”
Darius nodded.
“That’s the right thing.”
The answer irritated her because he refused to use the opportunity to win.
Her phone buzzed on the table.
Marcus.
She answered.
“Hey,” he said. “Need to see you tonight.”
“Why?”
“Investor deadline moved up.”
“I’m not investing.”
A pause.
Then his voice changed.
Not much.
Just enough.
“Amara,” he said, “you don’t understand how much is riding on this.”
Darius looked at her from across the table.
For once, he did not try to interpret the moment for her.
“So explain it,” Amara said.
Marcus lowered his voice.
“If I don’t close by Friday, I lose everything.”
Amara looked down at the 2008 photograph.
A four-year-old girl in purple rain boots smiled at a father she did not yet know how to miss.
“What does everything mean?” Amara asked.
Marcus went quiet.
May you like
As they packed the photographs away, Darius found one of Naima standing alone in the kitchen, laughing at something outside the frame. He stopped moving. Amara watched his thumb brush the edge of the photo, the same way it later brushed her diploma. She had spent so much time thinking of Naima as her mother that she sometimes forgot Darius had lost his wife. Marcus had lost a former love too, though in a different way. Their grief had traveled along separate tracks, occasionally crossing through Amara. 'Do you ever talk to Marcus about her?' she asked. Darius gave her a look. 'No.' 'Would you?' 'Probably not voluntarily.' Amara smiled. Then Darius added, 'But he's one of the few people alive who remembers her before I met her.' The admission made the family history feel less like opposing camps and more like broken pieces of the same map.
Then he said, “More than you think.”