Chapter 12 - The Cost of Silence

Lord Vane’s bailiff arrived before terce with six mounted men and the confidence of someone who expected doors to open for him.
His name was Hugh Dacre. He was not a soldier but a lawyer by training, thin-faced, gray-eyed, and careful with every word.
Cecily disliked him immediately.
She respected him five minutes later.
“I am not here to decide which spouse lies,” Dacre said in the small hall. “I am here to determine whether my lord accepted defective security.”
Baldwin sat opposite Cecily.
Lady Maud occupied the chair between them like a wall.
Rosalind was absent.
Dacre laid out the disputed declaration.
Cecily saw her seal impressed in green wax.
The copy was excellent.
Her stomach turned.
“Is this your device?” Dacre asked.
“Yes.”
“Your seal?”
“Not made by my signet.”
Baldwin laughed under his breath.
Dacre ignored him. “Can you prove that?”
Cecily placed her true signet beside the wax.
Dacre examined both through a lens.
“The impression is close.”
“Close is not the same.”
“No. But courts prefer more than a woman’s certainty about scratches in metal.”
Alys stepped forward. “The ring was missing before the declaration was sent.”
Baldwin said, “And later found in the dressing chamber.”
“After a mold had been made,” Cecily answered.
Dacre looked at her. “Evidence?”
She showed him the cloak.
The bailiff’s eyebrows lifted at the damaged hem and green wax.
Baldwin’s mouth tightened.
“This is theater,” he said.
“No,” Cecily replied. “The theater was dressing your mistress in my cloak while she copied my seal inside it.”
Lady Maud whispered, “Cecily.”
Dacre’s gaze sharpened. “Mistress?”
Baldwin stood. “My household arrangements are irrelevant.”
“Not if a member of your household prepared the disputed instrument.”
Before Baldwin could answer, Rosalind appeared in the doorway.
For an instant she looked surprised to find Dacre already there.
Then she smiled.
“My lord bailiff.”
Dacre knew her.
Cecily saw it.
“So,” Dacre said quietly. “Martin’s daughter.”
The room changed.
Rosalind inclined her head. “You have a good memory.”
“Your father caused my lord several inconveniences.”
“Truth often does.”
Baldwin turned on her. “Leave.”
Rosalind’s amused expression vanished.
She left without argument.
But Cecily had learned enough.
Dacre knew Rosalind’s father and disliked his records.
After the meeting, Baldwin followed Cecily to her solar.
Alys tried to enter with her.
“No,” Baldwin said. “Wait outside.”
Cecily looked at Alys. “Stay where you can hear me.”
Baldwin shut the door.
“You humiliated this family.”
“By objecting to forgery?”
“You named Rosalind before Vane’s man.”
“She is involved.”
“You do not know what you have done.”
“Then tell me.”
He paced once across the room.
“At Candlemas, Vane can seize income that feeds three hundred people. I found a way to delay that.”
“By stealing from Riversmeet.”
“By borrowing from your abundance.”
“Without asking.”
“Because you would say no.”
“Yes.”
He stopped.
“I can make this disappear.”
Cecily almost laughed. “You created it.”
“Sign a confirmation. A real one. Three years of rents. I will withdraw the incapacity petition.”
Her blood chilled.
“So there is a petition.”
His silence confirmed it.
“And if I refuse?”
Baldwin looked toward the door.
“Alys returns to her family tomorrow.”
Cecily stared.
“She has served me since I was seventeen.”
“She serves in my castle.”
“She came with my dowry household.”
“Then call it a dispute.”
Cecily’s voice dropped. “You threaten a servant because you cannot persuade your wife.”
“I am telling you what disorder costs.”
He stepped closer.
“And if you continue, I will ask Hester and the chaplain whether your present state is safe for you or the child.”
“Hester will not support you.”
“Perhaps. Others may.”
Cecily saw then that he did not need everyone to believe she was unstable.
Only enough men with seals.
Baldwin opened the door.
Alys stood exactly where Cecily had told her to stand.
She had heard everything.
Baldwin looked at the maid.
“Pack before sunset.”
Alys went pale.
Cecily rose.
“No.”
Baldwin turned.
Cecily put one hand on her belly and the other on the back of the chair.
“You have mistaken my silence for dependence long enough,” she said. “If Alys leaves Harrowgate, I leave with her.”
His eyes narrowed.
“Where would you go?”
Cecily thought of the settlement register.
After Baldwin left, Alys remained in the doorway with her bundle half packed.
“Do not leave because of me,” Cecily said.
Alys stared at her. “Do you imagine I have served you eleven years so a frightened man can send me home with two sentences?”
“He can make your life difficult.”
“He already has.”
Cecily almost protested, then remembered how often servants absorbed the consequences of noble quarrels while receiving none of the protection attached to noble names.
“If this worsens, I can send you to Riversmeet.”
“And miss everything?” Alys gave a quick, fierce smile. “Never.”
The humor faded. “But promise me something, my lady. If they force you to choose between protecting me and protecting yourself, choose yourself. I can find another household. You cannot find another body for that child.”
Cecily’s throat tightened.
May you like
For months Baldwin had spoken of duty while stripping choices from her. Alys, who possessed far less power, was offering choice back. Cecily understood why loyalty to a person felt so different from obedience to a house.
“To the one person my father named because he expected a day like this.”