scribe

Chapter 18 - The Counterattack

Dana Creel did not come to work the next morning.

Her supervisor said she had called in sick.

CID found her at home before noon.

By then, Lieutenant Colonel Mercer had retained civilian counsel.

At 1230, his attorney sent a letter to the installation commander accusing unnamed subordinates of “weaponizing a personal altercation to revive disproven allegations.” The letter claimed Mercer’s charitable involvement had been lawful, his family’s land investments had been reviewed years ago, and recent evidence had been taken out of context.

No one in Esme’s company was supposed to see it.

Everyone did by dinner.

Rumor became faction.

Some soldiers avoided Esme and Isolde. Others treated them like heroes, which both women hated for different reasons.

“Yesterday half the barracks thought I was a snob,” Isolde said. “Today they think I am a whistleblower.”

“You can be both.”

Isolde looked at Esme.

“That was almost funny.”

“It was fully funny.”

Captain Rook called them into her office before evening formation.

“This is going to get unpleasant,” she said. “You may hear claims that you fabricated evidence after the fight. You may hear that Corporal Marrowen targeted Mercer because of her father. You may hear that Sergeant Valethorne is trying to recover family property through military channels.”

Esme folded her arms.

“Are any of those claims in official complaints?”

“One anonymous complaint was filed this morning alleging collusion.”

Isolde’s jaw tightened.

“By who?”

“Anonymous means anonymous.”

“What happens?”

“It gets screened. Facts get checked. You cooperate.”

Esme asked, “Does this affect the fight case?”

“Yes and no. Your conduct remains what it was. But I will not finalize disposition while there is a question whether evidence connected to the same incident was interfered with.”

Isolde looked down.

Rook leaned forward.

“Do not mistake that for protection. You both violated standards. Doing the right thing afterward does not retroactively make the fight acceptable.”

“Yes, ma’am,” Esme said.

“Yes, ma’am,” Isolde echoed.

That night, Dana Creel’s attorney contacted CID.

She wanted to cooperate.

Creel was forty-nine, a longtime civilian employee with no criminal record. She had volunteered for the Calder Service Foundation for six years. She told investigators that Mercer had called her after learning the locker-room incident involved a Marrowen and a Valethorne.

“He said personal family materials had no place in a disciplinary packet,” Quinn reported later. “He asked Creel to remove anything unrelated to property damage before CID saw it.”

Isolde stared.

“Did he specifically say the photograph?”

“Yes.”

“And she did it?”

“Yes.”

“What about the envelope index?”

“Also removed.”

“Destroyed?”

Quinn shook her head.

“No.”

Creel had taken both items to Mercer’s office. According to her statement, Mercer looked at the envelope fragment, swore, and told her to shred it. He told her to return the photograph directly to Isolde after the disciplinary process and say it had been misplaced.

Creel could not make herself destroy the fragment.

She put both items in a file folder and locked them in a desk drawer.

CID recovered them under consent and warrant authority.

Isolde’s photograph came back inside a clear evidence sleeve.

She held it by the edges.

For a long time she said nothing.

Then she turned it over.

MARROWEN FAMILY — RED CREEK MOBILE PARK.

Same ink.

Same crease.

Same trailer.

Esme stood beside her.

“You want me to leave?”

“No.”

Isolde traced the plastic over the image without touching the photograph itself.

“I used to keep this hidden behind the lining of my bag,” she said. “Like it was contraband.”

“Your mother kept it.”

“Yes.”

“So did you.”

“Barely.”

“But you did.”

Quinn returned the original to evidence after allowing Isolde a digital copy.

The envelope fragment proved even more important. It matched the torn piece found under the bench and carried a partial file-index code corresponding to Nora Kline’s archive.

That linked the locker-room items to the historical records before investigators had ever contacted Blue Ridge Justice Center.

It weakened any claim that Esme and Isolde had manufactured the connection later.

The anonymous collusion complaint collapsed within forty-eight hours.

But Mercer’s counterattack was not finished.

His attorney released a statement to a local newspaper describing him as a respected officer being targeted over “lawful family investments made more than a decade ago.” The statement also noted that one principal accuser was “a soldier recently involved in a violent workplace incident.”

Isolde read the article in silence.

Esme reached for the phone.

Isolde pulled it away.

“Do not read comments.”

“I was not going to.”

“You were absolutely going to.”

Esme almost smiled.

Then Isolde’s expression sharpened.

“What?”

She pointed at a sentence near the bottom of the article.

Mercer’s attorney said the officer had never received personal compensation from Kestrel Land and Timber.

Esme remembered the old bank ledger.

Sixty-two thousand dollars.

Cashier’s check.

A. J. Mercer.

“That is a very specific denial,” Esme said.

Isolde nodded.

May you like

An hour later, Agent Quinn called.

The bank’s successor institution had located the archived check image.

Related Stories

Other posts