scribe

Chapter 4 - The Cottage Nobody Mentioned

The lake house stood on the north shore of a reservoir an hour and a half from the city. It was small compared with the houses Sean liked to admire in real-estate magazines: cedar siding, a screened porch, and a path that curved down to the water. There were yellow flowers in pots on the steps. I recognized the pots. I had recommended the same ones to Nancy after seeing them at a garden shop.

Alex and I parked separately on the public road. Neither of us approached the windows or tried the door. We had come to see the place that appeared in the records, not to trespass or prove how brave we could be while falling apart.

"It's nice," he said finally.

"It is."

That was the humiliating thing. I could see why they had chosen it. I would have chosen it myself.

The county property records showed the cottage had been purchased by Cedar Bluff Holdings LLC nine months earlier. Alex's attorney had obtained additional public business filings identifying Sean and Nancy as the company's managers. The mortgage and ownership arrangements would require further examination, but there was no longer any doubt that my husband and my best friend shared a project they had kept from both their spouses.

"Nancy told me she couldn't afford a vacation this year," Alex said. "We argued about it. I offered to take extra engineering work."

I looked at the porch. Two mugs sat on a small outdoor table, one blue and one pale green. Their presence was ordinary enough to feel cruel.

"We don't know what's happened inside," I said.

"I know," he replied. "I wish I could stop imagining it."

We walked back to our cars. Alex sat on the hood of his for a moment, eyes on the water. He said the truth he feared most was not that Nancy loved someone else. It was that she had watched him apologize for being suspicious while she carried on a secret life.

"I kept asking whether something was wrong," he said. "She told me I was making her feel trapped."

"Sean said I didn't like excitement."

Alex let out a breath that might have been laughter. "Apparently we were both failing a test nobody told us we were taking."

I remembered a conversation from the previous winter. Nancy had sent me a photograph of a small lake cabin and asked how I would decorate it if money were no object. I had suggested reading lamps, washable linen, and a long wooden bench near the window by the water. She said she was only daydreaming. Standing on the roadside, I could see a bench through the porch screens, or something shaped like one. I didn't know whether she had taken my advice. That uncertainty was almost harder to bear than the records. It suggested that even our most harmless conversations might have been used to furnish a secret I wasn't allowed to know.

At home, I found Sean waiting on the front step. His expression changed when I said I'd visited the lake. He asked whether Alex had taken me, as if our presence together could somehow erase the reason we'd gone.

"You bought a cottage with Nancy," I said. "Tell me why."

"It was an investment."

"You hid an investment from me for nine months."

"It was supposed to become a rental."

"Then show me the rental listings."

He looked down. I knew his answer before he spoke.

"It's complicated."

"No," I said. "The paperwork may be complicated. Your choice not to tell me was simple."

He followed me into the kitchen but stayed near the doorway. Our anniversary flowers had withered in a vase on the counter. I had forgotten to throw them away.

"Nancy was going through a terrible time," he began. "She thought Alex was going to leave her. We talked. We got close."

"How close?"

He swallowed. "Rachel—"

"How close?"

"We were seeing each other."

I had rehearsed hearing those words. In the rehearsal I screamed, overturned a glass, or collapsed against the table. In the real kitchen I reached for a clean dish towel and folded it twice.

"For how long?"

"Almost a year."

He said it softly, as if volume could make duration less ugly.

I set the towel down. A year meant my birthday dinner, his mother's hospitalization, the Christmas party Nancy hosted, and the weekend I stayed up helping Sean revise a presentation while he claimed Nancy was traveling for work. It meant countless mornings when he had kissed me goodbye knowing what he intended to do later.

"Why suggest the swap?" I asked.

He rubbed his face. "We thought maybe if we opened things up, it wouldn't feel like betrayal anymore. Maybe we could figure out what we wanted without destroying everything."

"You wanted the permission after you had already taken it."

His silence was answer enough.

"Did Nancy know you would ask me?"

"Yes. We agreed to bring it up separately. We thought everyone might be happier if there weren't so many rules."

"You didn't want fewer rules. You wanted us to live with consequences we had never chosen."

For the first time, he seemed to understand the distance between us. He approached the kitchen table but did not touch me.

"I love you," he said.

I believed he felt something he called love. I also believed he had been willing to make me doubt my own judgment to preserve the comfort of his life. Both things could be true. Neither required me to stay.

"I'll speak to Evelyn tomorrow," I said. "We're separating."

He looked toward the hallway where our wedding photograph hung. "After eighteen years?"

"No," I replied. "After a year of lies and a week in which you asked me to bless them."

May you like

Outside, the first stars had appeared. The house was quiet. Sean stood in the kitchen as though he expected me to tell him where the extra blankets were.

This time I did not.

Related Stories

Other posts