scribe

Chapter 3 - The Woman in My Kitchen

Brooke Sutter called at seven the next morning. I knew her number because I had saved screenshots of eleven weeks of messages Drew claimed were ordinary. Before I could decide whether to answer, she sent a photograph of a folder lying on a white duvet.

Is this real?

The document on top appeared to be a final divorce decree. My name occupied the space reserved for a former spouse. At the bottom was a date from six weeks earlier, when Nadia and I had been preparing our response to Drew's proposed settlement.

I enlarged the image. There was a judge's signature and a court seal, or something made to resemble one. I had never been notified of a hearing. Nobody had asked me to sign a final agreement.

I forwarded the photograph to Nadia and called Brooke back.

“Where did you get that?” I asked.

“Drew gave it to me last month.” Her voice sounded scraped raw. “He said the divorce was finished and you were only waiting for the house paperwork.”

“Then why did you think you could move into my house?”

“He said you'd agreed to leave after the closing on a business property.”

I closed my eyes. Drew had somehow made the word closing serve two opposite stories. To me, it meant the end of ownership. To Brooke, it was apparently the beginning of hers.

“You took pictures in my bedroom,” I said.

Silence.

“Yes.”

“Knowing it was mine.”

“I knew you were living there. Drew said you were staying temporarily because your apartment wasn't ready.”

“So you walked through my drawers?”

“I didn't touch your things.”

“That's a very low bar, Brooke.”

She began crying. I waited. Her distress belonged to her; I didn't have to manage it.

“Did you know we were still legally married?” I asked finally.

“Not until yesterday. He told me you were punishing him because he chose me.”

“And what did you believe?”

Brooke took a long breath. “I believed what made me feel better.”

That was the first honest sentence I had heard from her.

We arranged to meet in the lobby of Nadia's office, not at my house or hers. Nadia agreed, provided Brooke understood she would not represent both of us. I left Tori's apartment an hour early, changed my mind about parking three times, and arrived with my stomach clenched.

Brooke sat beneath a framed photograph of the city courthouse. She was younger than me by eight years, with blond hair pulled into a knot and a cardigan she twisted between her fingers. She looked less like a victorious bride than someone waiting for an examination result.

I sat across from her. “Show Nadia everything.”

Brooke pushed a slim envelope over the table. Inside were a printed decree, an email from Drew, and a copy of the marriage application she said she had signed electronically the previous week. On the application, Drew had declared himself unmarried.

“My mother kept asking why there wasn't a bigger wedding,” she said. “Drew said he wanted to keep it private until your feelings settled.”

“Convenient.”

“I know.”

“You knew he was married when you started seeing him.”

“Yes.”

She didn't offer a defense. That made the conversation harder in a different way. An enemy who denied every fact was easier to hate than a person who admitted the exact thing that hurt.

Brooke's gaze returned to the photograph on the wall. “I used to imagine the two of us becoming friends after everything settled,” she said.

I almost laughed. “Did you imagine asking me first?”

“No. I suppose I didn't.”

“Then it was another future designed without me.”

She turned her ring around her finger for what felt like hours. The stone was small and oval, set in yellow gold. I remembered choosing my own wedding band with Drew at a shop where he had asked the clerk to recommend the quickest option. I had interpreted his impatience as nervousness. Now I noticed how often I had renamed indifference to make it easier to live beside.

“Have you told your family?” I asked.

“My sister knows. My mother thinks I'm on a delayed honeymoon.”

“Tell her the truth,” I said. “At least give one person the chance to help you without another invented story.”

Nadia entered and studied the papers without dramatics. “We'll verify this through the court clerk, not through the image alone. Brooke, you should consult your own attorney about the ceremony and the representations on that application.”

Brooke nodded. “He told me Laurel was selling the house to him for a dollar.”

My skin prickled. “What?”

“He said it was part of the agreement. He showed me a transfer letter.”

She searched her phone and produced a screenshot. There was a typed sentence stating that I intended to convey the Alder Street property to Drew after divorce. Beneath it appeared my signature, rendered in an uneven blue line.

“That isn't my signature,” I said.

Nadia held up a hand. “Don't jump to conclusions about how the document was made. Send me the original message and any attachments you received.”

Brooke looked between us. “He told me you signed it in front of him.”

I pictured Drew in our study, with access to the old scanner and every tax return I had filed since our wedding. For months I had mistaken his confidence for information. Now I saw how easily he might have built a story from papers nobody else had verified.

Brooke stood. “I don't expect you to forgive me.”

“Good,” I said. “Because I can't promise that.”

She accepted the answer.

At the door she hesitated. “I loved the kitchen,” she said softly.

“So did I.”

Outside, morning traffic moved through Briarfield as though no one's world had tilted. I called Tori. She asked whether I had confronted Brooke.

“I listened,” I said. “That was worse.”

May you like

“Worse how?”

“Because I think Drew told two women two different stories and expected both of us to stay inside them.”

Related Stories

Other posts