scribe

Chapter 9

Ismerie's Private List

Ismerie opened the notes application on her phone and found the list she had made after seeing Elian's check. It contained a car, a designer bag, a summer trip to New York, and a number she had entered beside her father's name. She had not known how much Dorian needed, so she had written fifteen thousand dollars. The sum looked less like generosity now and more like a guess made in the dark.

She deleted nothing. Instead she added questions. What debt? What property? Why didn't Dad tell me? What did Grandpa write in my letter?

The questions made her angry at first. They implied she had been careless with information in the same way she had been careless with the envelope. But the more she looked at the list, the more she realized anger was easier than admitting ignorance.

She found Odelia in the greenhouse attached to the kitchen. Frost feathered the outer panes, but inside the air was damp and smelled of soil. Odelia was trimming dead leaves from a row of herbs. Her movements were slow, though she never seemed impatient with the work.

'Can I help?' Ismerie asked.

'You may bring me the smaller shears.'

They worked beside each other. Odelia explained which stems were alive and which were finished for the season. Ismerie discovered that the plants required different treatment, and that cutting everything back to the same height would damage some of them.

'Why don't you hire somebody?' she asked.

'I do for the heavy work. The rest I enjoy.'

'You could buy new plants.'

'Yes. But watching something recover is its own pleasure.'

Ismerie wondered whether the sentence had been intended for her. Odelia did not give any sign that it was.

After a while she asked, 'Were you angry when Grandpa died?'

Odelia set down the shears. 'Very. Not at him exactly. At the hospital, at the weather, at all the ordinary days we thought we would have. I was angry at the teacups because there were still two of them. Grief can make foolish things seem reasonable.'

'I don't remember him very well.'

'He used to build wooden birds for you. You would line them along the staircase and name them after your dolls.'

Ismerie remembered a small yellow bird with uneven wings. She had kept it for years before losing it during a move. 'Dad said Grandpa was difficult.'

'He could be. He disliked being contradicted and hated throwing away anything with a useful screw in it.'

'Was he unfair to Dad?'

'Sometimes. He loved your father and did not always know how to show it without giving advice.'

Ismerie looked up. 'Then why does Dad talk about him like they hated each other?'

'Because it is easier to remember the person who disappointed you than the person who was trying, imperfectly, to love you. Your father might tell the story differently. He has a right to his memories. But none of us owns all of the truth.'

The conversation unsettled Ismerie more than a defense of Gideon would have. Odelia did not make her father into a villain. She made him complicated, which meant the girl could neither dismiss nor blindly repeat his judgments.

On the way upstairs she passed the closed study door. She imagined the letter behind the circle-shaped lock, the carefully chosen words her grandfather had left. If she had opened the envelope she might have dismissed those words as sentimental. Now she wanted them so badly that she felt a physical ache.

She returned to the greenhouse before supper. Odelia was wiping down the worktable.

'Grandma, I want you to know I'm sorry I threw your gift away. Not because there was money in it. I mean, that is part of why I feel terrible. But I was cruel before I knew the amount, and I would have been cruel even if it had been twenty dollars.'

Odelia held the cloth still. Ismerie looked at the plants rather than her face.

'I thought being rude made me look grown up,' the girl continued. 'It didn't.'

Odelia set the cloth aside and opened her arms. Ismerie stepped into them carefully, keeping her injured fingers out of the way. The embrace was brief. Neither cried. When they separated, Odelia said, 'That is an apology I can hear.'

She did not mention the check. Ismerie did not ask. For once, the absence of an immediate reward made the exchange feel more valuable.

May you like

At school the following week Ismerie noticed how frequently her classmates spoke about grandparents as sources of cash or gifts. Some had warm relationships behind their jokes; others barely knew the people they discussed. She recognized her own tone in a girl who complained that her birthday card contained a handwritten note instead of a larger amount of money. Ismerie almost made a remark, then stopped. She did not want to become someone who used a new insight to humiliate others. Instead she asked whether the note said anything interesting. The girl shrugged and admitted she had not read it.

The exchange stayed with Ismerie. She was not entitled to supervise anyone else's gratitude, and she knew the danger of turning remorse into superiority. Yet she could practice curiosity. That evening she called Odelia to ask how the herbs were doing after the cold snap. They spoke for twenty minutes about plants, school, and the weather. Ismerie did not mention money. When they hung up, she realized the call had been enjoyable in a way her earlier conversations with Grandma rarely were. There had been no bargain to negotiate and no performance to maintain. She had simply wanted to know how another person was doing.

Related Stories

Other posts