scribe

Chapter 5 - The Number David Never Said

They did not go back to Lily's apartment.

David drove instead to a quiet diner two miles from the bank and chose a booth in the back where no one could overhear them. Samantha sat opposite him with the statements spread between the sugar dispenser and a laminated breakfast menu.

"What is Foster Property worth?" she asked.

David stared at his coffee.

"Dad."

"More than I told you."

"How much more?"

He exhaled.

"Last formal appraisal was three years ago. The three buildings together were valued at about four-point-two million dollars, net of the mortgages at the time."

Samantha blinked. "Four million?"

"Four-point-two. The loans are lower now, but the market has changed. I don't know today's number."

She felt anger arrive slowly, more painful for its patience.

"You told us they were worth maybe one and a half."

"Years ago. Before the neighborhood changed."

"You kept saying they were just old buildings Grandpa bought because he didn't trust the stock market."

"They are old buildings."

"Worth millions."

David looked toward the window.

"Why didn't you tell us?"

"Because I watched what money did to people in our family when your grandparents died. Your uncles stopped speaking for six years over a lake house. Your mother and I agreed we would not make the properties the center of your lives. You were supposed to finish school, build careers, marry people who knew you before they knew the numbers."

Samantha flinched at the last sentence.

David immediately regretted it. "I did not mean Marcus married you for-"

"You thought about it."

"Last night? Yes. Before last night? No."

She folded her arms over her belly. "Did Marcus know?"

David was quiet too long.

"Dad."

"He asked questions."

"What questions?"

"About the ownership structure. Voting rights. Whether the members could sell individually. Whether the company had to distribute cash."

"And you answered him?"

"Some of it is in the operating agreement. None of it is secret."

"Except from me, apparently."

David looked down.

Samantha had rarely seen him ashamed. Even when he was wrong, he tended to defend the road that had brought him there. Now the defensiveness was gone.

"You're right," he said. "I should have told you the full value. All three of you. I thought I was protecting you from becoming people who counted your future before you had lived your present. I did not consider that keeping you uninformed could make you easier to deceive."

That landed harder than an excuse would have.

Samantha turned one of the bank statements around.

"These distributions. How were they supposed to be sent?"

"To an individual investment account in your name."

"Could Marcus change that with the power of attorney?"

"Depends on the document."

"You drafted it?"

"No. Our attorney, Rebecca Shaw, did. It was supposed to be narrow. Property-tax matters only, because you were sick and a filing deadline was coming up."

Samantha remembered the hospital room: fluorescent light, IV tape on her wrist, Marcus touching her forehead while she signed where he pointed.

"I didn't read it," she said.

"You were vomiting every hour."

"I still signed it."

"Sam."

"I signed something I didn't read."

David leaned across the table. "That is not permission for someone to rewrite it."

Her eyes lifted.

"Rewrite it?"

"I'm saying we get Rebecca's copy and compare."

At 10:30, Rebecca Shaw agreed to meet them.

Her office occupied the second floor of a converted brick house with frosted glass doors and the smell of old paper. She had represented the Foster family for more than a decade and had known Samantha since she was a college student who came to meetings mainly for the free coffee.

Rebecca listened, then pulled Samantha's client file.

"The power of attorney is six pages," she said. "Limited to tax filings and communications relating to Foster Property LLC. It does not authorize Marcus to redirect distributions, open financial accounts, pledge your membership interest, make gifts, or amend beneficiary instructions."

She slid a copy across the desk.

Samantha recognized her signature on page six.

"Do you have the version Marcus submitted to the property manager?" David asked.

"Not here. But I can request it."

Rebecca picked up the phone.

Twenty minutes later, an email arrived from the management company.

Attachment: Samantha_Reed_POA.pdf.

Rebecca opened it.

Eight pages.

No one spoke.

She scrolled.

Pages one through six were nearly identical to the original.

Pages seven and eight were not.

They contained additional powers authorizing Marcus Reed to modify distribution instructions, execute banking forms related to Samantha's LLC interest, and "take such actions as attorney-in-fact deems financially prudent for the benefit of the principal's household."

At the bottom of page eight was Samantha's signature.

Perfectly formed.

A notary seal appeared beneath it.

Rebecca's face became unreadable.

"Did you sign this page?" she asked.

Samantha stared at the signature.

It looked exactly like hers.

"No."

"Were you ever in front of this notary?"

Samantha read the name.

Bethany Carter.

"I don't know who that is."

Rebecca turned to David.

"Don't call Marcus. Don't call his brother. Don't call the notary. Let me preserve what we have first."

She downloaded the attachment, saved the email with full headers, printed a copy, and called the management company back to request its submission logs.

Then she faced Samantha.

"There's something else."

She pointed to a clause near the bottom of page seven.

Samantha read it once.

Then again.

The forged document did not merely redirect income.

It authorized Marcus to sign consents affecting Samantha's ownership interest itself.

May you like

Rebecca tapped the line with one finger.

"If he used this," she said, "we need to find out what he signed in your name."

Related Stories

Other posts