scribe

Chapter 3 - The Sterling House

Julian Sterling returned Claire’s call at 7:42 that evening.

His voice was controlled but breathless. He had been on a train from

Manhattan and had only just heard the voicemail. Claire described Ceci’s

account without adding what she could not prove.

For several seconds Julian said nothing.

Then he asked, “Did Belle say she was afraid of Ms. Collins?”

“She didn’t have to,” Claire replied. “Ceci saw it.”

Julian arrived at the Blake home forty minutes later with Belle beside

him.

Belle looked smaller outside school. Her strawberry-blonde braid had

been undone, and she wore a navy rain jacket over pajamas. She stood

behind her father until she saw Ceci.

Ceci did not ask questions. She simply moved aside so Belle could enter.

At the kitchen table, Claire placed hot chocolate in front of both

girls. Julian sat opposite his daughter.

“Belle,” he said, “Mrs. Blake told me Ceci saw you with Ms. Collins

today.”

Belle’s eyes dropped.

“You’re not in trouble.”

“I know.”

“Did Ms. Collins hurt you?”

Belle’s fingers tightened around the mug.

“No.”

Julian looked at Claire, then back at Belle.

“Did she scare you?”

Silence.

Ceci remembered what her mother had said about exact truth. “You don’t

have to make it bigger,” she told Belle quietly. “Just say what

happened.”

Belle’s eyes filled.

“She said I was making problems.”

“What problems?” Julian asked.

Belle shook her head.

Claire intervened. “We can stop.”

That permission seemed to break something open.

Belle whispered, “She makes me stay after class sometimes.”

Julian went still.

“For what?”

“Corrections.”

“What kind of corrections?”

Belle’s lower lip trembled. “Things I say.”

The room seemed to shrink.

Belle explained in fragments. Ms. Collins had begun calling her aside in

January after Belle told another teacher that she felt sick before math.

Ms. Collins said Belle was becoming “dramatic.” Later, whenever Belle

complained, cried, or questioned an instruction, she was required to

write apology statements.

At first they were ordinary: I will listen the first time.

Then they changed.

I understand that my feelings can be dishonest.

I understand that adults know when I am exaggerating.

Julian’s face drained of color.

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

“I tried.”

“When?”

Belle looked toward the floor.

“The night you said Ms. Collins was the reason I got into the advanced

program.”

Julian closed his eyes.

Ceci watched him absorb the memory.

He had praised the teacher. He had told his daughter she was lucky to

have someone who demanded excellence.

Belle continued. “I thought if I told you, you’d think I was

ungrateful.”

Julian reached across the table but stopped before touching her hand.

“May I?”

Belle nodded.

He took her hand.

Claire showed Julian the anonymous text.

He read it twice. “That isn’t my number. And it isn’t anyone in our

family.”

“Who knew I had contacted you?” Claire asked.

“The school.”

Julian looked at his daughter. “Did Ms. Collins ever use your phone?”

Belle frowned.

“No. But she has all our parent numbers.”

Claire’s phone buzzed again.

Another message from the same unknown number.

You are frightening Arabella by turning discipline into something

sinister.

This time Julian stood.

“How does this person know Belle is here?”

Nobody answered.

Then Ceci looked toward the front window.

May you like

A car was parked across the street with its lights off.

As she watched, the headlights came on.

Related Stories

Other posts