scribe

Chapter 3 - WHAT THE CAMERA MEANT

Avery did not touch the empty case.

That was what Marcus remembered later.

She stood beside the table with her hands hanging at her sides, looking at the shaped foam where the camera had been.

Celeste began explaining too quickly.

"It was too expensive. You are going to college. There will be equipment rooms. You can borrow things."

Avery looked at her. "Dad bought it for me."

"With family money."

Marcus said, "No. With my annual bonus."

Celeste turned. "Which is family money."

"Maybe. But I chose the gift, and you knew that."

Avery's eyes moved between them.

"Did you return it because we needed money or because you thought I didn't need it?"

Celeste hesitated.

Marcus saw Avery notice.

"Both," Celeste said finally.

Avery nodded once.

"Okay."

That word made Marcus uneasy.

"Avery-"

"It's okay, Dad."

"No, it isn't."

She pressed her lips together.

Then she looked at Celeste. "I needed it for the summer assignment."

Celeste frowned. "What assignment?"

Avery's face changed in a small, almost invisible way.

"The one I told you about three times."

Marcus knew the assignment. Every incoming documentary journalism student had to arrive with a three-minute observational film shot before orientation. Equipment could be borrowed after classes began, but not before move-in.

Avery had already planned hers.

She wanted to film the old neighborhood barbershop where Marcus had gotten every haircut from age nine until he married Celeste and moved across town. The owner, Mr. Landry, was seventy-eight and closing the shop in August.

The camera was not simply a luxury.

It was time.

Avery had been afraid Mr. Landry would close before she could borrow university equipment.

"I can use my phone," she said now.

Marcus heard the retreat in the sentence.

Celeste heard practicality.

"Exactly. Phones shoot wonderful video now."

Maya stared at her mother.

Avery looked down.

Marcus said, "You should not have to pretend the replacement is the same just to make this easier for us."

Avery's shoulders tightened.

"I'm not pretending."

"You are."

Her eyes filled, but she blinked until the moisture disappeared.

"I don't want to fight over a camera."

Celeste exhaled as if this proved something. "See? Avery understands perspective."

Avery looked up sharply.

"No."

Celeste stopped.

Avery's voice remained quiet.

"I understand that if I say I'm upset, you will call me ungrateful."

The sentence silenced the room.

Marcus looked at his daughter.

He wanted to deny that this was how things worked in their home.

He could not.

Celeste folded her arms.

"I have never called you ungrateful for having feelings."

Avery gave a short, sad laugh.

"You called me dramatic when Grandma gave me money for prom shoes and you used it for groceries."

Marcus turned toward Celeste.

"What?"

Avery immediately looked regretful.

Celeste's face hardened.

"That was two years ago, and we actually did need groceries."

"I know," Avery said. "That's why I didn't tell Dad."

Marcus stared at her.

"There were other times?"

Avery did not answer.

Maya did.

"Yes."

That night, Avery opened the empty case again in her room. She sat cross-legged on the floor and placed each accessory into the space where the camera had been: battery, strap, memory card, cloth. The shape of the missing body remained obvious no matter how carefully she arranged everything else.

Maya leaned against the doorframe.

"Can I come in?"

Avery nodded.

Maya sat beside her and picked up the strap.

"I thought Mom returned it because you changed your mind."

"She told you that?"

"She said you were worried it was too expensive and had second thoughts."

Avery looked at her sister.

"I did say it was expensive."

"But you didn't want to return it."

"No."

Maya placed the strap back down.

The sisters sat with the uncomfortable discovery that the same fact could be used to build two completely different stories. Avery had worried about price because she understood what the gift cost. Celeste had turned that worry into permission.

"Do you think she believes the versions she tells?" Maya asked.

Avery considered it.

"Maybe after a while."

"That scares me more."

Avery looked at the dark window.

"Me too."

Before Maya left, Avery asked her not to become the family's evidence collector.

"If you see something, tell me or Dad. But don't start watching Mom all the time."

Maya frowned. "Why?"

"Because then even when she isn't doing anything, you're still living like she is."

May you like

Maya stared at her.

Avery did not know where the sentence had come from. She only knew she did not want her younger sister spending the rest of high school taking screenshots in her own house.

Related Stories

Other posts