Chapter 18 - THE MISSING PAGE

The original crash file contained ninety-three pages.
The archive copy contained ninety-two.
Inspector Hales noticed because the index listed an item 47B that did not appear in the file.
Vehicle component photograph.
Cassian sat across from her at the station.
“What component?”
“We don’t know.”
“Who removed it?”
“We don’t know.”
“Was it removed before the case closed?”
“We don’t know.”
Cassian exhaled through his nose.
“You enjoy that phrase now.”
“I enjoy accuracy.”
The missing page had a reference number.
That was enough to locate the photographer.
Retired collision investigator Malcolm Dyer lived on the coast and answered his phone on the fourth ring.
He remembered the Vellacourt crash.
Not because of Cassian.
Because of the brakes.
Hales put the call on speaker.
“I photographed a union fitting on the front brake line,” Dyer said. “There was tool marking.”
“What kind?”
“Fresh wrench marks.”
Cassian’s heartbeat thudded.
“Did that indicate tampering?”
“Could have indicated recent maintenance.”
“Was recent maintenance documented?”
“Yes. That’s why the case didn’t go further.”
Merrow & Sons had replaced the fitting.
Hales asked, “Do you remember item 47B?”
“Yes.”
“What happened to the photograph?”
“Should be in the file.”
“It isn’t.”
A pause.
“That’s odd.”
“Do you retain copies?”
“I did then.”
“Still?”
Another pause.
“Maybe.”
Dyer called back two hours later.
He had found an old external drive.
The photograph showed the fitting in sharp detail.
A tiny M stamp was visible.
Gideon Merrow’s mark.
But something else appeared beside it.
A fresh gouge crossing the metal after the stamp had been applied.
Dyer explained.
“If Merrow stamped removed parts, then this part had been out of the vehicle at some point.”
Hales said, “Could it have been reinstalled?”
“Yes.”
“Would that be normal?”
“Not if it had been removed as defective.”
Cassian thought of the two invoices.
One replacement before the crash.
Another purchase after.
A possible sequence emerged.
Gideon removed the original fitting, stamped it, installed a new one.
Someone later reinstalled the old fitting.
Then, after the crash, someone obtained the new part or bought another to confuse the service history.
Possible.
Not proof.
Hales said it before Cassian could.
“This creates a theory. We still need a person tied to the act.”
Dyer added something else.
“There was a man at the recovery yard.”
“When?”
“Morning after the crash.”
“Name?”
“He said he was family.”
Cassian’s hands went cold.
“Did you see him?”
“Yes.”
Hales emailed a photograph of Soren.
Dyer answered in less than a minute.
“That’s him.”
Cassian stood.
Hales raised a hand.
“Sit.”
“He was at the wreck.”
“That is evidence he was at the recovery yard. Not evidence he altered the car.”
“He had no reason to be there.”
“Then we prove that.”
They pulled visitor logs.
Soren had signed in using his own name.
At 6:12 a.m.
He listed purpose: collect personal family effects.
But police records showed Elowen’s handbag and personal effects had already been released to Cassian the night before.
“What did he collect?” Cassian asked.
No inventory existed.
Then Hales found an expense claim from the recovery yard.
Replacement lock cut from vehicle evidence bay at 7:05 a.m.
“Why cut a lock?”
“We’re asking.”
The yard owner, now retired, remembered a dispute.
“Soren wanted a small mechanical part from the car,” he said.
“What part?”
“Something from the brake assembly. I told him police had tagged everything.”
“Did he take it?”
“Not while I was there.”
“Did he remain after you left?”
“He was still arguing with one of the boys.”
That employee was dead.
No easy ending.
No cinematic confession.
Just another piece.
Hales leaned back.
“You see why investigations take time.”
Cassian looked at the recovered photograph.
“Yes.”
He hated it.
But yes.
That night, Eira asked him to read the same story twice.
He did.
At the end she said, “Again.”
Cassian almost told her it was late.
May you like
Then he realized repetition was how children proved an ending stayed the same.
He began again.