scribe

Chapter 22 - When Forgiveness Became the Wrong Question

In therapy, Eirlys surprised herself by becoming irritated every time Dr. Pike used the word forgiveness.

To be fair, Dr. Pike rarely used it first. Other people did.

Celeste wondered whether Eirlys might forgive Corisande someday. Gideon wondered privately whether forgiveness was required before Eirlys could feel at home again. Mara asked, with teenage bluntness, whether Eirlys had forgiven “the porch thing.” Even a guidance counselor, after hearing a simplified version of the family conflict, said, “It sounds like you’re working toward forgiveness.”

Eirlys began to hate the word.

So during her first individual session with Dr. Pike, she said, “Can we not make that the goal?”

Dr. Pike leaned back. “What would you rather make the goal?”

“I don’t know. Not feeling weird every time someone mentions Corisande?”

“That sounds more measurable.”

Eirlys smiled despite herself.

They talked about the porch, the tattoo, and the things that came before it. Eirlys described how Corisande had once been the person who taught her to make scrambled eggs without turning them rubbery. How she had sat beside Eirlys during the first school mother-daughter breakfast after Amabel died, not pretending to replace anyone, simply occupying the empty chair. How, at thirteen, Eirlys had called her Mom by accident and then deliberately repeated it the next morning.

“That history complicates the injury,” Dr. Pike said.

“Yes.”

“If Corisande had always been cruel, what would be different?”

“I’d know what she was.”

“And because she wasn’t?”

Eirlys looked at the rug. “It feels like I misunderstood her. Or she misunderstood me. I don’t know.”

“Perhaps both.”

Eirlys frowned. “That sounds like you’re splitting responsibility.”

“I’m not. Understanding a relationship is not the same as dividing blame evenly.”

That distinction mattered.

Eirlys told Dr. Pike about the message on Caelan’s birthday. The restored photograph. The empty nail on the wall. Corisande not replying to Eirlys’s one-word text.

“I notice those things,” Eirlys admitted. “Then I get mad at myself for noticing.”

“Why?”

“Because if I think she’s changing, it feels like I’m betraying how bad it felt.”

Dr. Pike shook her head. “Pain is not protected by refusing new information.”

Eirlys sat with that.

“What if I trust her again and she does something like that later?”

“Then you will know something you did not know before.”

“That sounds awful.”

“It can be.”

“So what’s the point?”

“The point is not to guarantee you will never be hurt. Nobody can offer you that. The point is to become confident that you will respond to hurt without abandoning yourself.”

Eirlys looked at the tattoo on her forearm.

For years she had thought remembering Caelan meant holding tightly enough that nothing changed. Therapy was teaching her almost the opposite: love could survive change. Memory could survive forgetting. Trust could be offered in portions rather than all at once.

At the end of the session, Dr. Pike asked, “If forgiveness is the wrong question, what is the right one?”

Eirlys considered.

“Maybe… do I feel like she sees me?”

Dr. Pike nodded. “That sounds worth asking.”

May you like

The answer, for now, was not fully.

But it was no longer no.

Related Stories

Other posts