Chapter 4 - What a Screenshot Cannot Prove

Special Agent Miriam Shaw arrived the following morning in an unremarkable gray sedan. She wore civilian clothes, carried no visible weapon, and refused Sorrell's offer to sit in on the interviews.
"I'll start with the reporting parties separately," she said.
Della watched through the duty-office window as the commander adjusted his cuffs and walked away.
Shaw interviewed Tessa first. By the time Della entered, the major's phone had been documented and placed in an evidence pouch for examination. A replacement device would come later. For now, Tessa had a receipt where the phone had been.
The ordinary appearance of the receipt unsettled Della. Last night's disaster had become an item number.
Shaw gave her time to read it. Della checked the description and asked for one detail to be corrected. The investigator corrected it without treating the request as distrust.
"Tell me what you personally saw," Shaw said.
Della began with Callie.
"She forged a message."
Shaw did not write that down.
"Did you see her create it?"
"No."
"Then tell me what you saw her do."
Heat climbed Della's neck. "She showed me a printed message. She said Major Morcant wanted me transferred."
"When?"
"August eighth. In her room after evening formation."
"Was anyone else there?"
"Becca Lyle. Nina Hart came in later."
Shaw wrote their names.
"What did Sergeant Voss say about where she obtained it?"
"That someone in administration thought I deserved to know."
"And did you ask Major Morcant?"
Della looked down at her untaped hands.
"No."
Shaw waited without rescuing her from the silence.
"I believed she'd deny it. Callie said people like her always made you feel unreasonable for asking."
"What made that convincing?"
Della opened her mouth, then shut it.
Because Tessa sometimes answered questions Della had not asked. Because she remembered Della's appointments, noticed her silences, and seemed to know when something was wrong before Della knew herself. Because being understood could begin to feel like being watched.
"Some of it was close enough to things I already felt," she said.
Shaw nodded once.
Della placed the reassignment worksheet on the table.
"This refers to my family's land."
The investigator read the routing reference.
"How do you know?"
"North Wash is forty-eight acres outside the eastern boundary. My grandmother put it in a family trust. My mother is the trustee. My brother and I are beneficiaries."
"Does Major Morcant know that?"
"I told her about the place. I don't know if I ever said how many acres."
Shaw's pen stopped briefly.
"Why might the property appear in your work?"
Della explained her temporary assignment to reconcile supporting documents for a facilities review. It was routine work: checking dates, matching reference numbers, identifying missing attachments. Three weeks before Tessa's field exercise, she had found her mother's name in a packet describing a completed drainage project and a land-use settlement.
She had asked the administrative office for the underlying agreement.
"Who answered?"
"Chief Warrant Officer Pike. He said it was outside my assignment."
"Did you continue asking?"
"Once. Then the transfer thing happened."
Shaw turned to a fresh page.
Della felt an unpleasant pressure behind her ribs. She had assumed the reassignment was the consequence of a damaged friendship. It had never occurred to her that damaging the friendship might have been part of the reassignment.
"Can you prove Tessa didn't send it?" she asked.
"Not from what we have this morning."
"She wasn't on the network."
"A timestamp can reflect processing or scheduling. A displayed name doesn't establish who operated an account. Those are things we investigate, not conclusions we skip to."
Della hated the answer. She also trusted it more than reassurance.
Shaw collected the original worksheet, provided another receipt, and asked Della to preserve anything else she already possessed without altering it.
"Don't borrow credentials. Don't enter offices you aren't authorized to enter. Don't confront people to get admissions. If someone contacts you about this, document it and tell me."
"What if my chain of command asks what I said?"
"Tell me that, too."
"Does making a report stop my transfer?"
"Not automatically. I investigate allegations; I don't issue your assignment orders. We can bring a concern about retaliation to the appropriate authority, but you still need to comply with lawful directions."
Della had imagined that telling the truth would move her onto different ground, beyond the reach of ordinary consequences. Shaw was making her understand that the ground stayed exactly where it was.
Outside, Tessa stood beside a vending machine with two paper cups. She offered one, then paused.
"Coffee?"
Della accepted it.
Neither woman mistook that for forgiveness.
"Did she believe you?" Della asked.
"She believed there was enough to preserve the records and investigate."
"That's not what I asked."
"It's the answer I have."
They stood quietly. The coffee tasted burnt.
Down the corridor, Callie emerged from another office. Her curls were damp, as if she had showered in a hurry. She looked at Della, then at Tessa, and kept walking.
Della almost called after her.
Instead, she watched the exit close.
Shaw reappeared and asked Tessa a question about access permissions during field exercises. Della moved away to give them privacy, taking her coffee with her.
On the wall outside administration hung a glossy poster of the post's new infrastructure initiative. A photograph showed Lieutenant Colonel Sorrell standing beside a civilian in a hard hat.
CAIRN LOGISTICS: BUILDING READINESS.
Behind the two men, a diagram showed a retention basin, a service road, and a shaded parcel along the eastern boundary.
Della knew that ground. Her grandmother had taught her to identify quail tracks there. During last spring's visit, she had walked past the old concrete trough and the wind-bent fence.
There had been no retention basin.
She carried the coffee back to Shaw, set it down carefully, and pointed to the poster.
"I think I asked Pike for the wrong document," she said.
"Which one should you have asked for?"
May you like
Della looked at the beautiful, impossible picture.
"Proof that they built any of it."