Chapter 8 - The North Stair

Alistair did not ask Agnes to forgive him.
That was the first decent thing he did.
He stood in the infirmary while she read Samuel’s letters again, and when she finally looked up, he said, “I was wrong.”
“You were convenient,” Agnes replied.
He accepted the blow.
“My mother showed me a letter in which Samuel threatened to expose private accounts unless the theft charge was withdrawn.”
“Did you see the original?” Adrian asked.
“A copy.”
“Of course.”
Alistair’s jaw tightened. “I believed our steward and our mother. I had no reason—”
“You had a reason,” Agnes interrupted. “Samuel was poor.”
Silence.
Alistair looked at her cheek where the mark from Mathilde’s slap had faded to yellow at the edges.
“Yes,” he said. “That was reason enough for me then.”
That admission shifted something.
Not trust. But the possibility of it.
Agnes had expected excuses from him: that he was busy, that Grieve was convincing, that noble families could not investigate every servant complaint. Instead Alistair stood there with the discomfort of a man discovering that ignorance had been one of his privileges.
"When you saw the letter," she asked, "did you wonder why Samuel would blackmail the estate instead of simply asking to clear his name?"
Alistair looked down. "No."
"Did you wonder why only a copy was shown to you?"
"No."
"Did you ask whether I had received any letters from him?"
His silence answered.
Adrian shifted impatiently, but Agnes raised a hand. She did not want her anger borrowed by someone with more rank. This was hers to say.
"Then remember that, my lord. The next time someone tells you a poor person is dishonest, ask what you would ask if the accusation were against your brother."
Alistair met her eyes. "I will."
She did not tell him she believed him. A promise made in shame was not yet a habit. Still, the fact that he remained in the room mattered.
Alistair told them more. Harrowmere was burdened by three large mortgages. Two were held by respectable banks. The third, nearly twelve thousand pounds, was owed to Northmere Holdings. Interest was unusually high. Mathilde had insisted the money was needed for repairs and tenant improvements after the late Baron’s illness.
“Did the repairs happen?” Adrian asked.
“Some.”
“How many worth twelve thousand pounds?”
Alistair did not answer.
That night the brothers went to the north stair together.
Agnes remained in bed under strict orders, furious at being left behind. Nell served as messenger.
The ash room door was locked, but Alistair carried the master ring of Harrowmere. The oldest iron key opened it.
The room beyond was narrow, windowless, and coated in gray residue from the old kitchen chimney. Broken coal baskets leaned against the wall.
Adrian lit a lamp.
“Third brick from the floor,” Nell whispered. “Not third from the door.”
They searched the north wall first.
Nothing.
The west wall.
Nothing.
On the south wall, one brick near the floor carried a faint black line where soot had settled differently.
Adrian knelt and worked a knife into the mortar.
The brick came free.
Behind it was an empty cavity.
Nell’s heart sank.
“Grieve got there first.”
Alistair lifted the lamp closer.
“No.”
He reached inside and drew out a thread of faded blue cloth caught on a rough edge.
“Something was here recently.”
Nell remembered the sound she and Agnes had heard: paper tearing, metal scraping.
“His folio,” she said. “He removed it.”
Adrian searched the room more carefully.
Near the old fireplace lay scraps of paper in the ash. Most were burned black.
One corner remained legible.
...relief account, quarter ending Michaelmas...
Another fragment carried half a signature.
M. Va—
Alistair stared at it.
“My mother.”
Then Adrian noticed scratches on the floor leading toward a disused coal cupboard.
Inside stood a small metal dispatch box.
Locked.
Alistair tried every key on his ring. None fit.
Adrian touched the lid. “Grieve moved this, but did not take it.”
“Why?”
“Too heavy? Or he thought no one could open it.”
Nell looked at the lock.
A small black keyhole.
They all thought of the key on Grieve’s waistcoat.
Upstairs, meanwhile, Mathilde was hosting Clara Beaumont and her father for dinner.
The contrast could not have been crueler. Crystal glittered beneath chandeliers while, below, servants investigated money taken from servants who could barely afford boots.
Clara, twenty-six, was observant enough to notice that Alistair appeared halfway through soup with soot on one cuff.
“You have been somewhere interesting,” she murmured.
“Not interesting. Necessary.”
Mathilde heard.
Her eyes moved to the cuff.
She said nothing during dinner.
Afterward she went directly to Grieve’s office.
“The ash room,” she said.
Grieve looked up.
“They have opened it.”
His expression remained composed, but his hand moved instinctively toward his waistcoat.
The black key was gone.
At the same moment, downstairs in the servants’ passage, Nell opened her fist.
May you like
The key lay in her palm.
She had taken it while serving wine.