scribe

Chapter 13 - The Counterclaim

Mara did not allow Cornelius to meet Gerald alone.

She arranged for Gerald to come to her office two days later, with his own attorney present if he wished. He agreed.

That created a new problem.

Perpetua’s due date had passed.

Every phone call, every legal development, every knock at the door now occurred beneath the knowledge that labor could begin at any moment.

“You do not need to come,” Cornelius told her the morning of the meeting.

Perpetua stared at him while tying the belt of her cream cardigan beneath her belly.

“Try that sentence again.”

He smiled despite himself.

“You may come.”

“Better.”

Mara’s office occupied the second floor of a renovated brick building downtown. She had arranged the conference room with water, cushions, and enough open space for Perpetua to stand when sitting became uncomfortable.

Gerald Mercer arrived ten minutes late.

He looked older than Cornelius remembered. Seventy, perhaps. His hair was white now, his shoulders narrower. He carried a dark blue accordion file against his chest.

Cornelius went still when he saw it.

Gerald’s lawyer introduced himself, then everyone sat.

Mara began.

“Mr. Mercer, you contacted my client. Before you say anything substantive, I want to be clear that we are not offering immunity, confidentiality beyond applicable law, or any agreement regarding claims.”

Gerald nodded.

“I understand.”

He looked at Cornelius.

“I am sorry about your father.”

Cornelius’s expression barely changed.

“You had five years to say that.”

Gerald looked down.

“Yes.”

He placed the blue file on the table.

“I kept this because Alistair asked me to.”

“Then why didn’t you give it to me?”

Gerald took a long breath.

“Because Blythe told me you wanted nothing to do with the company. Then she paid me to consult on governance matters, and I let convenience become an excuse.”

“You were paid forty-six thousand dollars.”

“Yes.”

“To hide documents?”

“No.”

Gerald’s answer came quickly.

Mara said, “Then explain the note: ‘Keep succession file off company server.’”

Gerald’s mouth tightened.

“Blythe did not want employees seeing ownership disputes. I agreed to keep the file in my private archive.”

“And not send copies to Cornelius?”

“That was her instruction.”

“Did you follow it?”

“Yes.”

Cornelius laughed once, without humor.

“So you were paid to hide it from me.”

Gerald looked at him.

“In effect, yes.”

The room went quiet.

Perpetua watched Cornelius’s hands. They were clenched, but he did not raise his voice.

“Open the file,” he said.

Gerald did.

Inside were copies of the original operating agreement, Alistair’s ownership schedules, meeting notes, correspondence with estate counsel, and several memoranda written by Gerald himself.

Mara compared the documents to what she already had.

Then she found something new.

A memorandum dated three months before Alistair’s death.

Subject: Succession Vote.

It recorded an argument among Alistair, Blythe, and Gerald. Blythe wanted permanent control over Cornelius’s shares because she believed he would sell the business. Alistair refused. He wrote through Gerald that if Cornelius chose to sell after receiving lawful ownership, that was his decision.

Perpetua watched Cornelius read the paragraph.

His father had trusted him with the right to make a choice even when he might dislike the choice itself.

That was the opposite of Blythe’s definition of love.

Then Mara found an email printout from four years ago.

Blythe to Gerald:

Do not initiate the age-30 transfer. C is not prepared and will not notice. I will revisit when he has a family and understands responsibility.

Gerald had replied:

The trust language appears mandatory. You should obtain legal advice before delaying.

Blythe:

I have had enough legal advice. I am asking whether the company books can continue showing the trust as holder.

Gerald:

They can, but that does not resolve beneficial ownership.

Blythe:

Then leave it that way.

Cornelius pushed his chair back.

Perpetua thought he might leave.

Instead, he walked to the window.

Gerald said, “I should have sent that to you.”

“Yes,” Cornelius replied.

“I told myself you did not care.”

“That was not your decision.”

“I know.”

Mara asked Gerald about the loan.

His face tightened.

“I advised against the personal guarantee.”

“Why?”

“Because Cornelius had not authorized it directly, and because Briarstone was not the operating company.”

“Did you know about Alder Lake?”

Gerald looked at his attorney.

His attorney nodded once.

“Yes.”

“What was it for?”

Gerald hesitated.

“Blythe called it a contingency residence.”

“For whom?”

“For herself.”

Perpetua felt the answer settle heavily.

While Blythe warned that employees could lose jobs, she had used part of the borrowed money to build herself an exit.

Cornelius turned from the window.

“Why?”

Gerald answered quietly.

“She believed that if the company failed, creditors and family litigation could force her to leave the house she lives in now. She wanted an asset outside the operating company.”

“Purchased with money guaranteed in my name.”

“Yes.”

Gerald looked sick.

“She said she would repay it once the company recovered.”

“Did it?”

“Partly.”

“Did she repay it?”

“No.”

Mara closed the file.

“Thank you. We will copy these documents.”

Gerald began to stand.

Then he stopped.

“There is one more thing.”

Everyone looked at him.

“The birth provision was not only about ownership.”

Cornelius frowned.

“What else?”

Gerald opened the back pocket of the blue file and removed a single page.

“Alistair added a governance condition to the ten-percent distribution. When your first child is born, the trust is required to deliver the units and a complete five-year accounting to you within ten business days.”

Mara’s eyes sharpened.

“A mandatory accounting triggered by the birth.”

“Yes.”

Perpetua understood before Cornelius did.

May you like

Blythe had not merely been racing to preserve control.

She had been racing a deadline that would force the books open.

Related Stories

Other posts