Chapter 1 - It’s Complicated

Madison Cole had checked her reflection in the black screen of her phone so many times that the hostess had begun pretending not to notice.
Bistro Nouveau glowed around her in soft gold. Candles trembled inside glass cylinders. A trio near the bar played jazz quietly enough for conversations to stay private. Couples leaned toward each other over polished tables, and servers moved between them carrying wine, bread, and the promise that everyone in the room knew exactly why they were there.
Everyone except Madison.
She adjusted one small hoop earring, smoothed the skirt of her dark-red dress, and whispered to herself, “Okay, Madison. Relax. It’s just a normal date.”
Her phone vibrated.
Chris_2024: Parking. Two minutes. Don’t leave before I prove I’m funnier in person.
Madison smiled despite herself.
For two weeks, she had messaged a man named Chris whose profile showed more books than selfies, whose answers were unexpectedly thoughtful, and who had somehow persuaded her to admit things she usually buried beneath jokes. Her frustration with work. Her disastrous ex. Her fear of turning into someone who apologized for wanting a life of her own. Her mixed feelings about her sister Emma’s upcoming wedding into the Whitfield family.
Especially the Whitfields.
Chris had listened without trying to fix her. That was rare enough to feel dangerous.
A shadow fell across the table.
“Sorry I’m late, I’m—”
The man holding the small bouquet stopped so abruptly that one white ranunculus tilted over his knuckles.
Madison looked up.
Tall. Charcoal blazer. White shirt. Blue-green eyes. Short dark hair. The familiar expression of someone who had just opened the wrong door and found a fire behind it.
Her chair scraped backward.
“Brandon?”
His face lost all color.
“Madison?”
She stared at the bouquet, then at him, then at her phone.
“No.”
His eyes dropped toward the phone in her hand.
“Oh, no.”
“You’re Chris_2024?”
“Madison? Emma’s sister?”
Two women at the next table stopped talking.
Madison stood. “You’re Ethan’s brother.”
Brandon Whitfield glanced around as if perhaps the restaurant had another exit hidden in the ceiling.
“You’re about to be my brother-in-law!” Madison hissed.
“Future brother-in-law,” he said automatically.
Her eyes widened.
“That is not better.”
“Fair.”
He set the bouquet down carefully, the way someone might put a live grenade on a table.
“I genuinely didn’t know,” he said. “Your profile said Madison C. Your photo was from the side. Your hair covered half your face.”
“You used a fake name.”
“I used my middle name. Christopher is my middle name.”
“Your profile says you restore motorcycles.”
“I do restore motorcycles.”
“You said you worked in ‘corporate strategy.’”
“I do work in corporate strategy.”
“For your family’s company.”
“Yes.”
“Which you left out.”
“Because half my coworkers treat dating apps like competitive intelligence.”
Madison slowly sat down again.
Brandon remained standing.
“Please sit,” she said. “You’re making it look like you proposed and I rejected you.”
He sat instantly.
The nearby women looked disappointed.
Madison pressed both palms to her cheeks. “I told you everything.”
“I know.”
“My job.”
“Yes.”
“My ex.”
“Yes.”
“My family.”
Brandon winced.
Madison pointed at him. “Do not wince.”
“I wasn’t—”
“You were.”
“I was bracing.”
“That’s worse.”
She lowered her voice. “I told you I think my future in-laws can be controlling.”
“I remember.”
“You agreed with me.”
“I agreed that families become irrational around weddings. That was a broad philosophical statement.”
“Brandon.”
“Fine. I also said controlling people should come with warning labels.”
Madison groaned and covered her eyes.
For a few seconds they sat in the humiliating quiet of two people discovering that anonymity had been doing far more work than either of them realized.
Then Brandon said, “The sister I kept telling you I adore?”
Madison lowered her hands.
“That was Emma.”
Silence.
Madison’s mouth fell open.
“You said your sister was the smartest person in the family.”
“She is.”
“You said she was marrying a good man who sometimes had the emotional range of a dishwasher.”
Brandon grimaced. “I may have used the phrase ‘well-designed dishwasher.’”
Madison pointed at him again. “Tuesday.”
He closed his eyes.
“Don’t,” he said.
“Tuesday, I told you my sister’s fiancé was slightly unromantic.”
“You did.”
“And you said—”
“Please don’t make me hear it twice.”
“—that the guy probably needed lessons.”
Brandon opened his eyes. “That guy is my brother.”
Madison covered her face again.
This time, he laughed.
It escaped him helplessly, a warm, mortified sound that made one of the nearby diners smile into her wineglass.
Madison tried not to laugh.
She failed.
For ten seconds, the entire disaster became funny.
Then reality returned.
“The wedding is in two weeks,” Madison said. “Emma cannot know this before the wedding.”
“Agreed.”
“Ethan definitely cannot know.”
“Strongly agreed.”
“No one can know we spent two weeks telling each other private things about them.”
Brandon nodded. “We matched before either of us knew.”
“I know.”
“That matters.”
“It will not matter to my sister when she learns I complained about her future husband’s family to his brother.”
Brandon leaned back. “For the record, most of your complaints were reasonable.”
“Not helping.”
“Fair.”
The candle between them flickered.
Madison looked at the flowers. “I was actually excited for tonight.”
The humor left his face.
“So was I.”
That was somehow worse than everything else.
Brandon glanced toward the restaurant entrance, then back to her. “We could leave.”
“We could.”
“Or we could eat.”
“As what?”
“Friends who have already overshared catastrophically.”
Madison considered him.
“Dinner as friends?” he asked.
Before she could answer, their waiter appeared with a cheerful smile and two menus.
“Good evening. Welcome to Bistro Nouveau.” He looked from the flowers to Madison’s dress to Brandon’s expression. “So, is this your first date?”
Madison and Brandon answered at exactly the same time.
“It’s complicated.”
They looked at each other.
The waiter blinked. “I’ll give you a minute.”
As he walked away, Madison’s phone buzzed again.
This time, the message was from Emma.
FAMILY BRUNCH TOMORROW AT THE WHITFIELDS. 10 A.M. DON’T BE LATE. ETHAN SAYS BRANDON WILL ACTUALLY SHOW UP FOR ONCE.
Madison slowly turned the screen toward Brandon.
He read it.
Then he looked up.
“Well,” he said.
May you like
Madison stared at him across the candlelight.
“Apparently,” she replied, “it gets more complicated.”