Chapter 10 - The Signature That Could Not Exist

By sunset, Naomi had assembled a timeline.
May 2, three years earlier: Isabella flew from JFK to Madrid.
May 3, 10:00 a.m. New York time: the disputed beneficiary acknowledgment claimed she appeared before a notary in Manhattan and consented to Alejandro’s continued voting authority over the Sofia Reyes Family Trust.
May 3, 3:15 p.m. Madrid time: Isabella appeared onstage at the International Hospitality Brand Forum before eight hundred attendees.
May 4: she remained in Spain.
May 6: she returned to New York.
The acknowledgment could not be genuine.
Naomi obtained archived conference footage from Isabella’s own company files. Time-stamped photographs showed her in Madrid throughout the day.
Then she examined the notary block.
The acknowledgment had supposedly been notarized by Caroline Voss, a paralegal at Hendricks’s firm.
Naomi searched the New York notary database.
Caroline Voss’s commission had expired four months before the stated signing date.
Diego stared at the screen. “You’re kidding.”
“I rarely improve facts for entertainment,” Naomi said.
Isabella felt something settle inside her.
Anger had been hot and unstable since the engagement.
Evidence was colder.
More useful.
“Can we stop the Ashcroft deal now?” she asked.
“Possibly. But we need to decide what we are trying to stop.”
“The conversion.”
“Yes.”
“The trust proxy.”
“Yes.”
“My father using my shares.”
“Yes.”
Naomi turned the laptop around.
“And we need to prevent destruction or alteration of records. I am preparing an emergency petition in Delaware Chancery Court seeking expedited relief related to the trust vote and corporate authorization. We may also need a separate proceeding regarding the fiduciary trust records, depending on governing law.”
Diego looked uneasy. “If this becomes public, lenders panic.”
“It is already public that Isabella tried to flee her engagement through a ballroom,” Naomi said. “The question is whether the next public fact is ‘family dispute’ or ‘creditors seize assets while everyone protects appearances.’”
Diego had no answer.
Isabella’s phone rang.
Alejandro.
This time she answered.
“Come home,” he said.
“No.”
“I want to speak to you without lawyers and outsiders.”
“Julian is an outsider when you want privacy and family when you want financing.”
“Isabella.”
“Did you sign my name on the trust acknowledgment?”
Alejandro went silent.
“Did Hendricks?”
“I did not sign your name.”
It was a carefully narrow answer.
“Did you know it wasn’t genuine?”
Another silence.
“You were traveling constantly at that time,” he said.
Her stomach turned.
“That’s your answer?”
“I was told the necessary paperwork had been handled.”
“By whom?”
“Hendricks.”
“Did you know I was in Madrid?”
“I don’t remember.”
“I gave a speech for your company.”
“I said I don’t remember.”
She heard irritation, not shock.
He had known something was wrong.
Maybe not the mechanics.
Maybe not the notary.
But enough.
“Why did you reject Harbor National?” Isabella asked.
Alejandro exhaled sharply. “Diego had no right to show you that.”
“Why did you reject it?”
“Because it was designed to remove me.”
“During a review of forty-seven million dollars you lost.”
“I did not lose forty-seven million dollars personally.”
“You approved Ladera.”
“Ladera was a strategic investment.”
“It was a disaster you hid from your board.”
“You are repeating things you do not understand.”
“Then explain them.”
“I cannot run a company by committee with my children.”
“But you can marry one of them to a lender.”
His breathing changed.
“Do you think I wanted this?” he asked.
Isabella almost shouted yes.
Instead she said, “I think you wanted to stay in control.”
“That company employs four thousand people.”
“And Harbor National offered a path to protect it.”
“They would have gutted us.”
“Ashcroft plans to take Harbor Point at a discount.”
Silence.
This time Alejandro’s silence held genuine shock.
“You saw the side letter,” Isabella said.
“What side letter?”
“March fourteenth.”
Alejandro said nothing.
His confusion sounded real, but Isabella no longer trusted sound.
“You signed it,” she said.
“I signed a governance letter, yes.”
“And Harbor Point?”
“I agreed to collateral transfer protections if liquidity tests failed.”
“At a predetermined valuation?”
A pause.
“No.”
Isabella stood.
Naomi and Diego watched her.
“What did you sign, Father?”
“The final draft I was shown did not set a fixed valuation.”
Isabella looked at Naomi.
Naomi immediately pulled the side letter closer.
At the bottom of page five, Alejandro’s signature appeared.
The valuation provision was on page four.
“Did you read every page?” Isabella asked.
Alejandro’s anger returned. “Of course.”
“Then either you’re lying now, or the document changed.”
The room went still.
Isabella stared at the pages.
For the first time, Alejandro did not sound like the only architect of the trap.
He sounded like one of its targets.
Naomi lifted the document to the light.
The signature page contained faint staple holes near the upper-left corner.
Page four did not.
She looked at Isabella.
“These pages may not have always been together.”
The case had just become more dangerous.
Because a forged signature would implicate the Reyes side.
May you like
A substituted contract page could implicate the Ashcroft side.
And Arthur Hendricks stood in the middle of both.